Courtesy: RE/MAX In Motion
607-277-1500
Beautifully updated and move-in ready, this home offers flexibility as a full-time residence or proven Airbnb. Recent upgrades include new flooring, mini-split heating and cooling, and a new hot water heater. Set on just over an acre with a large, private yard—ideal for relaxing or entertaining. Guests and owners alike will love the location along the Cayuga Wine Trail, just minutes to Cayuga Lake, Trumansburg, and area colleges. Modern comfort, easy maintenance, and great access to all the Finger Lakes has to offer.
Courtesy: Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc.
607-257-0666
Create your own private lakeside retreat on over 4 private acres with 211 feet of level Cayuga Lake shoreline. This rare offering includes two historic, beautifully maintained & thoughtfully updated cottages, a large dock with boat lift & 3 storage sheds. The Upper Seasonal Cottage (1926): Feel the breezes flow thru this cottage as it perches on a small rise above the lake and above the banks of Lively Run as it cascades along its light filtered path to the lake. Inside, you’ll find 3 comfortable bedrooms and 1 ½ updated baths. The galley kitchen retains its vintage charm while offering modern conveniences for effortless cooking. Vaulted ceilings & skylights in the main living area create a bright, open feel, with a central brick fireplace for cozy evenings. A spacious screened porch stretches across the front of the cottage, the perfect place to relax with a view of the lake. A gentle path—wide enough for an ATV—leads you down to the shoreline & sweeping southeastern views. The Lower Year-Around Cottage (1893) : Nestled along the shoreline, this Victorian-inspired gem blends timeless character with modern updates. Featuring 3+ bedrooms, 2 marble full baths, & a white quartz kitchen, it’s designed for comfort & entertaining. The pier-&-beam foundation & full insulation, paired with a warming gas fireplace, make it suitable for year-round enjoyment. Vaulted ceilings & abundant windows fill the home with natural light. Outdoors, two inviting porches provide the ultimate in lakeside living—the screened lower-level porch offers bug-free dining & relaxation, while the upper porch delivers private, panoramic views of the lake. The Grounds: Beyond the cottages, over 4 acres invite exploration. Follow the timber-lined trail through the woods to a charming bench tucked into a shaded glade. In spring, daffodils bloom along the path, creating a magical seasonal display. Lovingly cared for & curated over the decades, these two properties offer a truly unique opportunity to own a private retreat on the West shore of Cayuga Lake, adjacent to the Kidders/Sheldrake neighborhood. Check out the virtual tour which combines both cottages into one easy to view tour.
Courtesy: Four Seasons Sotheby's Int'l
585-394-7111
Opportunity awaits with this pristine 11.4 acre waterfront property in the sought after Sheldrake community along the west side of Cayuga Lake. Look out over the serene waters from your sun-shaded front porch and enjoy easy access to 220’ of private frontage with dock and beach for lakeside recreation. This 5-bedroom, 2.5-bath Cape Cod offers three first floor bedrooms (two with private bath), a wood-burning fireplace, sweeping lake views, and lots of room to spread out – inside and out. New backup generator ensures that you’ll never be without power. Additional lower level square footage allows for a game room, home gym, and/or workspace, along with ample lockable storage. Bring your imagination for the expansive back acreage and newly restored gable roof barn that could be used to host weddings, live music, or other events, with plenty of surrounding space for parking. The shop outbuilding also invites creativity as a studio or converted to a guest house. Walking distance to Sheldrake Point Winery, O’Malleys Tavern, and public boat launch; 15 minutes from the shops and eateries in Trumansburg; and a short commute to either Ithaca or Seneca Falls. Whether purchased as a primary home, summer getaway, or rental investment, this property is prime for accessing the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail and the many year-round attractions the Finger Lakes region has to offer.
Courtesy: RE/MAX In Motion
607-277-1500
This perfectly maintained Cape-style residence offers over 2,100 square feet of comfortable living space on a sprawling 1.6-acre lot. Inside, three spacious bedrooms and two full baths, an eat-in kitchen boasting newer appliances, multiple living spaces, main floor full bath, and a full, finished basement. One of the standout features is the expansive bonus room, ideal for a home office, game room, entertainment area or potential main floor primary bedroom. Take the sliders to the back deck, complete with privacy, tranquil setting, surrounded by mature trees, flowers and bushes, a small water feature and foot bridge. The newly added fire pit area serves as a focal point for gatherings, creating a cozy and inviting atmosphere while extending the usability of your outdoor area into the cooler months, providing warmth and ambiance. Located in Trumansburg School District, Seneca County and town of Covert, this property provides everything you have been looking for.
Opportunity awaits! At over 3000 square feet and 5 bedrooms, this property could remain a large single family home, OR easily be turned in to a multi unit for the savvy investor. Located just outside the Village of Interlaken, this property sits on over an acre of land with a barn and additional outbuilding, gardens and a partially fenced in yard. Less than 10 minutes to Trumansburg and only 20 minutes to Cayuga Medical Center!
3 unit investment property located in the Village of Interlaken. A true moneymaker! This property features a single family 1 bedroom cottage and 2 mobile homes with 2 bedrooms each. All 3 units have municipal services! This is a well priced straightforward turnkey property for a savvy investor. Or you can live in the cute little cottage for free and let the mobile home rentals pay your mortgage. This is a well kept property and sits privately away from the road. The cottage is privately situated from the mobile homes.There is a great rental history with month to month leases. The size of the cottage is 546 Square Feet. The Mobile Homes are about 938 square feet each.
Affordable opportunity! Looking to build your rental portfolio while on a budget? This Ranch offers main level living, which is sought-after by many. Additionally, it is privately set in just over 1 acre with a seasonal pond. Currently rented month-to-month. With a vision and some modern updates this could be a great starter home, or a short term or long term rental. New roof on sunroom. Newer windows. Full, unfinished basement. Expansive back deck. Pool as is. In the heart of the Finger Lakes, close to Cayuga Lake, and short drive to Seneca Lake!
Interlaken is located in New York. Interlaken, New York has a population of 486. Interlaken is more family-centric than the surrounding county with 27.43% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 26.06%.
The median household income in Interlaken, New York is $48,125. The median household income for the surrounding county is $59,086 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Interlaken is 50.4 years.
The average high temperature in July is 80.8 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 16.6 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 35.2 inches per year, with 62.9 inches of snow per year.
