Buy Now and enjoy all that Candlewood Lake has to offer especially in the summer! A 250-acre lake with boating, fishing, and kayaking. Come tour this completely updated 3BR, 2 Full BA with large 2 car garage complete with golf cart to drive to the pool, beach, nature trails, courts, and visits to meet and greet your new friends. Open Floor Plan with Covered Back Deck great for entertaining! Economical electric furnace with heat pump. 24/7 Security. Monthly fees include water, sewer, trash. Community events for all ages. Just 45min north of Columbus. OPEN HOUSE Sat May 16 from 2:00-4:00pm
Stunning custom Amish built home in the private gated lake community of Candlewood Lake. Sitting lakefront on over half an acre with a private dock on a quiet cove. This custom home has a large well-appointed chef's dream kitchen. The first floor includes a large primary suite, closet, spa-like bathroom with large shower and soaking tub with separate vanities all attached to the laundry room. First floor also includes another bedroom/flex office space, great room with gas fireplace, a dining room, sitting room, 1/2 bath and a mudroom with a dog shower. The lower level has 2 more bedrooms with a jack/jill bathroom, a wood-burning fireplace, a man's dream bar and a room that can be made into whatever you can dream up. There is plenty of storage and even a lower-level garage and workshop. A 24kw Generac natural gas powered whole home generator is also included. Dual mode Trane HVAC system for perfect comfort year round. Many porches including a screened porch to enjoy the lake views.
Buy Now and enjoy all that Candlewood Lake has to offer especially in the summer! A 250-acre lake with boating, fishing, and kayaking. Come tour this completely updated 3BR, 2 Full BA with large 2 car garage complete with golf cart to drive to the pool, beach, nature trails, courts, and visits to meet and greet your new friends. Open Floor Plan with Covered Back Deck great for entertaining! Economical electric furnace with heat pump. 24/7 Security. Monthly fees include water, sewer, trash. Community events for all ages. Just 45min north of Columbus.
Escape to the serene beauty of Candlewood Lake with this inviting 3-bedroom, 3-full bath log cabin nestled in Mt. Gilead. Perfectly blending rustic charm with modern comfort, this home offers a true lakeside retreat. Step inside to discover a warm, open-concept living area featuring natural wood finishes, exposed beams, and large windows that flood the space with sunlight while framing breathtaking water views. The fully equipped kitchen is ideal for preparing family meals or entertaining guests, flowing seamlessly into the cozy dining and living spaces. Each of the three bedrooms is generously sized, offering privacy and comfort for family and friends. The three full bathrooms provide convenience and a touch of luxury, perfect for a weekend getaway or full-time lake living. Outside, relax on the deck or patio while soaking in panoramic views of Candlewood Lake, or enjoy water activities just steps from your door. The property also offers ample outdoor space for gatherings, barbecues, and making lifelong memories. Whether you're seeking a peaceful retreat, a family getaway, or an investment property in one of Mt. Gilead's most desirable lakefront areas, this log cabin delivers charm, comfort, and spectacular scenery. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of lakeside paradise. Schedule your showing today!
Charming and affordable living on nearly half an acre in the Village of Mount Gilead! This well-maintained 2-bedroom, 1-bath home offers the perfect blend of small-town convenience and peaceful surroundings. Inside, you'll find a spacious eat-in kitchen, a cozy living room featuring a propane fireplace, and a bright 3-season room that adds additional living space to enjoy throughout much of the year. The home also includes a full basement for extra storage or workspace potential and a detached garage with a newer garage door. Updates include a new roof installed at the end of 2023 and a new hot water heater in 2026. Appliances convey, including the washer and dryer, making this home move-in ready. Enjoy the benefits of Columbia Gas, public water and sewer, and high-speed internet, all while being tucked away on a quiet dead-end street that offers a country-like setting with the convenience of village living. Subject to Probate Court Approval.
Don't miss this brand-new Amish custom-built Schlabach home in the private gated community of Candlewood Lake. This home sits lakefront on a double lot with almost 1 acre of land and a custom dock with stunning views. The entry level open floor plan includes a dream kitchen with large island, dining room and great room with stone gas fireplace. This level also includes a primary suite with beautiful en-suite bath, laundry room, den with French door, 2 additional bedrooms with 1 full bath in between. The large maintenance free deck overlooking the lake is stunning from the double sliding glass doors in the great room. The walk out lower level offers a large recreation room with pool table and shuffleboard along with a full bathroom and plenty of storage. Just outside the lower level you will find a beautiful paver patio and firepit area with hot tub and maintenance free stairs down to the covered boat dock and oversized open area to hang out on those summer days and nights. *MORE PHOTOS COMING THURSDAY 5/14!
Welcome to Resort-style living in desirable gated Candlewood Lake - where you can enjoy mornings on your balcony with views of the lake while waving at neighbors who drive by on golf carts. Truly a friendly community with activities for all ages! Two Swimming Pools, 3 playgrounds, Private Beach, Tennis-Pickleball courts, 2 Nature Trails, Fishing tournaments, Kayaking, Pontoon and Speedboats. Raised ranch house with 2 Full Baths, 3 Bedrooms one of which could be a Lower Level Rec Room. On 3 lots with a shed, this property has plenty of space for yard games or potentially an additional out building. 45minutes north of Columbus. Call for your private tour and move in by early June to enjoy the entire summer, including one of the best Fourth of July fireworks in the area!
Welcome to Resort-style living in desirable gated Candlewood Lake - where you can enjoy mornings on your balcony with views of the lake while waving at neighbors who drive by on golf carts. Truly a friendly community with activities for all ages! Two Swimming Pools, 3 playgrounds, Private Beach, Tennis-Pickleball courts, 2 Nature Trails, Fishing tournaments, Kayaking, Pontoon and Speedboats. Raised ranch house with 2 Full Baths, 3 Bedrooms one of which could be a Lower Level Rec Room. On 3 lots with a shed, this property has plenty of space for yard games or potentially an additional out building. 45minutes north of Columbus. Call for your private tour and move in by early June to enjoy the entire summer, including one of the best Fourth of July fireworks in the area!
Rustic charm abounds in this beautiful Candlewood lakefront home! This 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home features a first floor open floor plan, showcasing a full kitchen with high-end, Viking and Sub Zero stainless steel appliances, Corian countertops, dining area, and a living room with gas stone fireplace. This room opens to an airy, glass filled sunroom with a spectacular view of the lake. The first floor also features a master suite with attached full bath, and a second bedroom and additional half bath. The fully finished lower level includes a large recreation/family room, an additional sunroom overlooking the lake, as well as 2 additional bedrooms, and a luxurious full bath, with combination glass enclosed steam/shower room and standalone bathtub. Extending from the first floor is a spacious outdoor deck, with a stone fireplace, perfect for entertaining. Additional multilevel decks extend from the house, with stairs leading to a large dock with two boat lifts, which also includes an adja
Located in the heart of Mount Gilead, this beautifully restored historic home offers the perfect blend of timeless charm and modern convenience -- all within walking distance to local coffee shops, restaurants, and downtown shopping. Inside, you'll find a spacious layout that has been completely updated while thoughtfully preserving the character and warmth of the home. The first-floor mother-in-law suite with full bath, kitchenette and its own private entrance creates endless possibilities, whether for guests, multi-generational living, or short-term rental income potential. The oversized kitchen is built for gathering and entertaining, featuring abundant storage space and an impressive 10-burner range. Upstairs, the primary suite includes a beautifully updated en suite bathroom, along with four additional bedrooms and another renovated full bath. Enjoy outdoor living on the covered front porch or relax on the back deck overlooking the property. Major improvements provide peace of mind, including updated electric, plumbing, lighting, flooring, furnace, central air, tankless water heater, metal roof, vinyl siding, and windows. Historic charm, modern updates, and a walkable location -- this is a rare opportunity in downtown Mount Gilead.
Rustic charm abounds in this beautiful Candlewood lakefront home! This 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home features a first floor open floor plan, showcasing a full kitchen with high-end, Viking and Sub Zero stainless steel appliances, Corian countertops, dining area, and a living room with gas stone fireplace. This room opens to an airy, glass filled sunroom with a spectacular view of the lake. The first floor also features a master suite with attached full bath, and a second bedroom and additional half bath. The fully finished lower level includes a large recreation/family room, an additional sunroom overlooking the lake, as well as 2 additional bedrooms, and a luxurious full bath, with combination glass enclosed steam/shower room and standalone bathtub. Extending from the first floor is a spacious outdoor deck, with a stone fireplace, perfect for entertaining. Additional multilevel decks extend from the house, with stairs leading to a large dock with two boat lifts, which also includes an adjacent, private lakefront sauna. A 2-car detached garage completes this fantastic property. Two boats and a golf cart are negotiable. Your family and friends will enjoy all the unique features this must-see home has to offer!
ONLINE AUCTION, the RESERVE (Minimum Bid) is $100,000. The auction ends at 7:00 PM, Thursday, June 4, 2026. BUYERS MUST SIGN ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF TERMS to bid. Agents, please see 'A2A'.Unique, private home in a lake community is ready for new owners! Situated on a double lot, backing to woods, this A-Frame home sleeps 5-7 with a first floor bedroom and second story loft. Hardwood floors on the main level, newer windows and doors, gas stove, dishwasher. Plenty of room to play outside with large yard, fire pit, shed, full access to the lake, boat docks, pool, pickleball courts, and Lodge.
Located in the heart of Mount Gilead within the desirable Mount Gilead School District, this charming two-story home at 112 N. Walnut St. offers a blend of character and opportunity. Built in 1900, the property features 1,141 square feet of living space situated on a 0.17-acre lot. The home includes two bedrooms located upstairs, along with a full bathroom on the second floor. A half bath is located on the main level and includes plumbing hookups but is not currently functional. Interior features include a mix of carpet and solid wood flooring, providing both comfort and durability. Additional highlights include a one-car garage, public water and sewer service, and a mini split system for the downstairs with window A/C accessibility upstairs for seasonal comfort. This property presents a great opportunity for buyers seeking a home with historic charm and potential, whether as a primary residence or investment. Conventional financing or cash offers will be considered. Don't miss your chance to own a piece of Mount Gilead with this well-located property offering both value and potential.
This is the kind of home buyers wait for in Candlewood. Tucked into a private wooded setting, this fully remodeled home has been thoughtfully updated over the past five years and feels like something out of a magazine. The kitchen stands out with black custom cabinetry, exposed beam, farmhouse sink, gas range, butcher block island, beverage fridge, and a built-in coffee bar that blends high-end design with everyday living. Upstairs, the primary suite offers a calm, finished feel with a shiplap accent wall and a spa-style bathroom featuring dual vanities and a full marble walk-in shower. The finished basement adds an additional 867 square feet of living space for entertaining or guests, while the outdoor setup is built for relaxing with a deck, pergola swing, patio, and wooded backdrop that provides rare privacy. Homes like this don't come up often in Candlewood, and when they do, they don't last. Listing agent is related to seller.
This is the kind of home buyers wait for in Candlewood. Tucked into a private wooded setting, this fully remodeled home has been thoughtfully updated over the past five years and feels like something out of a magazine. The kitchen stands out with black custom cabinetry, exposed beam, farmhouse sink, gas range, butcher block island, beverage fridge, and a built-in coffee bar that blends high-end design with everyday living. Upstairs, the primary suite offers a calm, finished feel with a shiplap accent wall and a spa-style bathroom featuring dual vanities and a full marble walk-in shower. The finished basement adds an additional 867 square feet of living space for entertaining or guests, while the outdoor setup is built for relaxing with a deck, pergola swing, patio, and wooded backdrop that provides rare privacy. Homes like this don't come up often in Candlewood, and when they do, they don't last. Listing agent is related to seller.
5 bedrooms, 2 baths, first floor main with private main bath, fireplace, awesome new front porch. Nearly 2000 sqft of country living in the city, YES! Built in the 1900 era with incredible original Killer OAK woodwork throughout! This is a family house dream! Agent is related to the Seller.
Stunning custom Amish built home in the private gated lake community of Candlewood Lake. Sitting lakefront on over half an acre with a private dock on a quiet cove. This custom home has a large well-appointed chef's dream kitchen. The first floor includes a large primary suite, closet, spa-like bathroom with large shower and soaking tub with separate vanities all attached to the laundry room. First floor also includes another bedroom/flex office space, great room with gas fireplace, a dining room, sitting room, 1/2 bath and a mudroom with a dog shower. The lower level has 2 more bedrooms with a jack/jill bathroom, a wood-burning fireplace, a man's dream bar and a room that can be made into whatever you can dream up. There is plenty of storage and even a lower-level garage and workshop. The Trane HVAC system has dual modes for separate heating and cooling for both levels. A 24kw Generac natural gas powered whole home generator is also included. Many porches including a screened porch to enjoy the lake views.
Wonderful opportunity to own a spacious home in the heart of Mt. Gilead, offering convenient access to parks, shops, restaurants, local events, State Route 95, and schools. Situated on a quiet street with a true small-town feel, this property features a charming wraparound porch. Perfect for relaxing and enjoying peaceful surroundings. The inviting floor plan offers exceptional main level living space, including hardwood flooring throughout, a living room, family room, dining room, full bath, utility area, and a generously sized kitchen. The home is filled with natural light and showcases numerous updates. See the attached improvement list totaling over $45K in updates. Upstairs, you'll find four spacious bedrooms, a 5th room that can be used as a flex space for a second office, nursery or additional closet space and a full bath, providing ample room for family, guests, or flexible use. The dry lower level is equipped with a newer French drain system, offering added peace of mind. Outside, the property includes a 48x20 barn ideal for storage, workshop space, or additional parking, along with a loft area in the garage. The expansive outdoor space provides plenty of room for gardening, entertaining, or simply enjoying the setting.
Beautiful 2.5 year old, 3-bedroom, 2 full bath home on 3 nice lots in wonderful Candlewood Lake! Open concept family/kitchen/dining room. Ensuite primary bedroom with full bath. Stainless steel appliances, solid surface kitchen countertop. Separate W/D/utility room, insulated crawl space, and poly composite storage shed. Start enjoying the lake life now, with boating, fishing, nature trails, pool, community lodge, tennis, pickleball, and much more. Too good to miss out on!
Beautiful 2.5 year old, 3-bedroom, 2 full bath home on 3 nice lots in wonderful Candlewood Lake! Open concept family/kitchen/dining room. Ensuite primary bedroom with full bath. Stainless steel appliances, solid surface kitchen countertop. Separate W/D/utility room, insulated crawl space, and poly composite storage shed. Start enjoying the lake life now, with boating, fishing, nature trails, pool, community lodge, tennis, pickleball, and much more. Too good to miss out on!
**FOR SALE AT ONLINE AUCTION** Auction will start to end May 20, 2026 at 7 pm. Don't miss this opportunity to own 15.3 acres in the Northmor School District featuring a 1,632 sq ft ranch home with 3 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, and an attached 2.5-car garage. The property also includes a large pole barn with two sections (60x40 and 40x24), offering plenty of space for storage, equipment, or hobbies. Ideal for a hobby farm or for those looking for room to spread out, featuring a versatile outbuilding and a country setting. Call to schedule a showing before the auction ends on May 20, 2026.
Looking for an incredible opportunity to restore a property to its full potential? This unique rural estate in the Mt. Gilead Local School District offers flexibility, space, and endless possibilities. Situated on up to 20.033 acres, this property can be purchased with approximately 10 acres or the full 20 acres, giving buyers the option to fit their vision and budget. The 2-story home offers over 2,800 sq ft with 3 bedrooms and 1 full bath, providing a spacious layout ready for renovation and transformation. Outside, you'll find three substantial outbuildings, including: 2,240 sq ft pole barn 1,632 sq ft pole barn 3,520 sq ft pole barn Perfect for farming, storage, livestock, equipment, or hobby use. Enjoy peaceful country living with room to grow, while still being a commuter's dream with convenient access to major routes. Being sold AS-IS, WHERE-IS. Bring your vision and unlock the full potential of this rare opportunity!
Wonderful opportunity to own in desirable gated Candlewood Lake! Well-maintained home with a one-of-a-kind Oversized Heated 2-car Garage! Perfect for anyone who wants a place for woodworking or auto mechanics! Enjoy the variety of community activities for all ages with 2 Pools, Playgrounds, Private Beach, Pickle ball, Tennis, Nature trails, 24/7 Security plus Boating and Fishing tournaments. Sellers are giving new owners a choice in furniture. Ask about the Pontoon Boat and Golf Cart! Covered Front Porch faces morning sun; spend a day on the lake or at the pool, then enjoy an evening on the Secluded Back Deck in your own Hot Tub! Just relax and enjoy Lake Life within the beautiful "Resort-Style"community! Call for your private tour today!
Wonderful opportunity to own in desirable gated Candlewood Lake! Well-maintained home with a one-of-a-kind Oversized Heated 2-car Garage! Enjoy the variety of community activities for all ages with 2 pools, playgrounds, private beach, pickle ball, tennis, hiking trails, 24/7 Security plus Boating and Fishing tournaments. Sellers are giving new owners a choice in furniture. Ask about the Pontoon Boat and Golf Cart! Covered Front Porch faces morning sun; spend a day on the lake or at the pool, then enjoy an evening on the secluded Back Deck in your own Hot Tub! Just relax and enjoy Lake Life within the beautiful ''Resort-Style''community! Call for your private showing today!
Located in the heart of Mount Gilead, this rare 3-story Victorian brick home offers over 5,000 square feet of living space, blending timeless character with modern updates. The interior features 4 bedrooms, plus 2 additional bonus bedrooms on the third floor, 2 full bathrooms, multiple living spaces/sunrooms, original oak floors and trim, zoned heating and cooling, and 2 laundry locations. Recent updates include a new roof in 2022, new kitchen flooring/backsplash, and fresh paint throughout. The exterior features a manicured lot with several outdoor living spaces, including a back deck and front porch, as well as a detached garage for storage. Enjoy living within walking distance to local shops and dining. Don't miss the chance to make this gem your own!
Andrea D. Conner, License BRKP.2017002935, Xome Inc., License REC.2015001703, [email protected], 844-400-XOME (9663), 11427 Read Hartman Hwy, Suite 236, Cincinnati, OH 45241
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Copyright © 2026 Columbus and Central Ohio Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.
Mount Gilead is located in Ohio. Mount Gilead, Ohio has a population of 3,108. Mount Gilead is less family-centric than the surrounding county with 28.13% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 30.14%.
The median household income in Mount Gilead, Ohio is $42,697. The median household income for the surrounding county is $63,411 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Mount Gilead is 33.9 years.
The average high temperature in July is 83.2 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 16.5 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 40.9 inches per year, with 33.2 inches of snow per year.
