The median home value in Matlacha, FL is $365,500.
This is
lower than
the county median home value of $380,000.
The national median home value is $338,100.
The average price of homes sold in Matlacha, FL is $365,500.
Approximately 47.5% of Matlacha homes are owned,
compared to 12.69% rented, while
39.81% are vacant.
Matlacha real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Matlacha real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Waterfront Gem in Historic Matlacha – Five Plex Investment Opportunity Welcome to a rare find in the heart of Matlacha’s historic district, a charming old Florida mullet fishing village that has retained its unique character and laid-back lifestyle. This waterfront property offers a perfect blend of investment potential and dream home possibilities. Property Highlights: • 5 Waterfront Apartments: Fully renovated and in top condition, ready for immediate rental or personal use. • Income Potential: Generates $50,000–$55,000 annually, with a strong 4.5% return on investment. • Double Boat Dock: Features a spacious double boat dock, ideal for boating and fishing enthusiasts. • Spectacular Sunsets: Unwind each evening with breathtaking sunset views from the boat deck. • Future Potential: Rent the property for consistent income while you plan and build your dream home on this stunning waterfront location. Matlacha is the last piece of old Florida living, offering a vibrant arts community, incredible fishing, and serene coastal vibes. This property is more than an investment—it’s your gateway to an unparalleled lifestyle. Don’t miss out on this unique opportunity. Explore this waterfront treasure! This home is marked as located in a historic district but Second Street is NOT which means you are allowed to build there your new dream home on stilts -no worries about flooding- on this superb location
Completely Renovated 3/2 Deep Water Access with Pool in Matlacha! This perfect island getaway is situated on a wide deep water access canal with over 80 ft of frontage and is within walking distance to the heart of the funky coastal village of Matlacha! For fun on the water, Matlacha is surrounded by some of the best fishing in the world, beautiful native wildlife, kayak trails and pristine white sand beaches of the Gulf of Mexico. This home offers an open floor plan, tile throughout, with 3 bedrooms, renovated kitchen, renovated baths and a sunroom perfect for enjoying morning coffee! The outdoor living space really sets this home apart, featuring a heated pool ideal for taking in the famous Matlacha sunsets and an oversize dock complete with 10k covered boatlift and fish cleaning table which makes boating a breeze! Some of the other outstanding attributes include, impact resistant windows and doors, metal roof, fenced yard and garage! Don't miss the drone footage, so you can truly see the stunning surroundings of this home! Come see this perfect island home today and start Living the Island Life!
This is a must see property!! The location of this house is priceless for people that enjoys living in a small community that brings out their love for art, nature, fishing, music, relaxing and good food! Enjoy the Matlacha Pass Aquatic Preserve is the tidal node between Charlotte Harbor to the north and the Caloosahatchee River and San Carlos Bay to the south. As per the last census of Matlacha in 2022, population was 837. This is really a beautiful small town where you can walk, ride your bike or boat everywhere. Park your boat right next to your lanai and begin a trip into the relaxing preserve for a fishing day. Relax in your front porch while watching beautiful sunsets. This house is a concrete built house, it has 3 bed 1 bath on a oversize lot and facing a deep wide canal with direct gulf access. Park your boat right next to your lanai and begin a trip into the relaxing preserve for a fishing day. This property has Metal roof installed in 2019 and a new A/C unit installed in 2023 also features remote control and accordion hurricane shutters. Come and see it and make it your own.
Located close to restaurants, shops,and fishing in Historic Matlacha, this delightful waterfront home boasts stunning westerly views of the Bay and a tranquil mangrove preserve—creating an idyllic backdrop for the quintessential Florida lifestyle. Key features of this spacious 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom home include laminate wood-look flooring throughout, a fully renovated kitchen equipped with high-end GE Profile appliances, Quartz countertops, and a sizable kitchen island. For added convenience, the laundry area is cleverly hidden behind a barn door, and a cozy fireplace enhances the ambiance for relaxing evenings. The primary bedroom offers a peaceful retreat with large windows, a ceiling fan for comfort on warm Florida nights, an en-suite bathroom featuring a beautiful walk-in shower. The finished lower level boasts a kitchenette, full bath, private entry, and sliding doors that lead to a pavered lanai overlooking the water and breathtaking sunsets. Additionally, there is a 10,000 lb. boat lift and dock, perfect for boating enthusiasts eager to explore the waters of Matlacha and beyond. Just imagine, kayaking in the beautiful water getting close to nature. Constructed in 2007, the house features sturdy 2x6 walls, impact doors, and windows on the upper level, along with storm shutters for the lower level. The stairs leading to the balcony and the balcony have been completely rebuilt with durable TREX decking. Imagine unwinding while soaking in the spectacular sunsets from your living room or balcony, or simply enjoying the sight of ospreys flying to their nests. Entertain family and friends in the spacious downstairs guest suite, adorned with classic Florida charm. This home is more than just a place to live—it's a retreat crafted for relaxation and coastal enjoyment. Having been utilized as a vacation rental, this property has garnered outstanding reviews. Whether you seek a permanent residence, a vacation getaway, or an investment opportunity, this meticulously maintained home offers a perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and scenic tranquility. Don’t miss your chance to own a piece of paradise in beautiful Matlacha!
Waterfront Boater's Paradise with No Rental Restrictions! This property is in a hidden gem off Florida's Gulf Coast, offering a unique blend of natural beauty, artistic flair, and coastal living. Nestled between Pine Island and Cape Coral, this historic fishing village has transformed into a vibrant, colorful community that attracts artists, boaters, and nature lovers alike. This turnkey, concrete-built two-story home offers over 2,300 sq. ft. of living space, making it an incredible investment or personal retreat. With three spacious bedrooms, two bathrooms, a private pool, and a garage, this property is ready for you to move in or start generating income immediately. Boating enthusiasts will love the direct Gulf of Mexico access, complete with a boat lift, captain's walk, and a composite dock equipped with water for easy cleaning after a day on the water. Relax and unwind on the top balcony, where you can take in unforgettable sunset views over the water—one of the best features of this coastal gem. Located just outside city limits, this home has no HOA or rental restrictions, offering unmatched flexibility. It is also within walking distance of Matlacha's vibrant attractions, including The Blue Dog Bar & Grill, Perfect Cup Café, Yucatan Waterfront Bar & Grill, and local seafood markets. Don't miss this opportunity to own a piece of paradise in the heart of Matlacha. Schedule your showing today!
Sitting on the dock of the Bay - the best seat in the house! Never ending views of water and sunsets right in your back yard. Fully remodeled and impeccably updated! A beautiful cottage with mega million dollar views! If you are looking for a simple life or a great VRBO, and your life is water, fishing, boating...then this was made for you. Two bedroom, one bath. Fish Camp? Retreat? VRBO? This home has a great rental potential, please call for rental info. THE most charming little cottage rebuilt after Hurricane Milton, all new everything including dock and boatlift. Fish right off the dock, endless panoramic and amazing straight water views - lots of dolphins, manatees and sea life surround you! This is truly a one of a kind, magical home filled with light and a carefree island vibe. Be part of the small fishing and boating community of Matlacha and come live your best life!
Welcome to Pine Island, your gateway to paradise! Nestled in the heart of St. James City, this Gulf-access waterfront lot is every boater and angler's dream. Imagine launching your boat from your backyard and being just minutes from open water, with easy access to Sanibel, Captiva, Ft. Myers Beach, or even Key West. This lot is cleared and ready for your vision—whether that’s a cozy getaway or your forever home. Plus, you'll love the charming island vibe with local restaurants, lively bars, and an unmistakable sense of community. Don’t miss this chance to own your slice of paradise!
If you're dreaming of your own slice of paradise in Matlacha, FL, then 2556 Cay Cove is where you need to be. This place has had the full makeover treatment - we're talking a brand-new roof, so you won't have to worry about leaks or repairs anytime soon. The kitchen? Totally redone with all new, shiny appliances that you'll love cooking with. Inside, it's like stepping into a fresh start; the entire interior has been remodeled to give you that modern, airy feel with two comfy bedrooms and one bathroom. Now, let's talk about the outside - the new dock is your ticket to endless fun on the water. Whether you're into fishing, boating, or just watching the sunset, it's right there at your doorstep. The exterior of the house has been spruced up too, making it not just a home but a statement in this colorful, artsy community. This place feels like the perfect airbnb or fishing retreat. It's perfect for anyone looking to dive into the Matlacha lifestyle. You'll be steps away from galleries, quirky shops, and some of the best seafood joints you'll ever try. So, if you're ready to live where others vacation, give me a shout, and let's talk about making 2556 Cay Cove your new home sweet home.
Discover the charm of Majestic Matlacha! This cleared, quarter-acre vacant lot offers direct Gulf access with no bridges, ensuring smooth sailing to some of Florida’s most iconic waters. Featuring approximately 200 feet of sturdy concrete seawall along the picturesque Matlacha Pass, this property provides the perfect foundation for your custom waterfront retreat. Envision your dream home complete with a pool, surrounded by stunning tropical vistas. Enjoy breathtaking sunrises and sunsets, abundant wildlife, and a welcoming community of boaters and anglers in a location celebrated for world-class fishing. With easy boat access to Pine Island Sound, Charlotte Harbor, Tarpon Pass, Redfish Pass, and the open Gulf, this is your opportunity to embrace the ultimate Florida lifestyle. Don’t miss your chance to make this slice of paradise your own!
Enjoy direct Gulf access with no bridges, offering seamless boating adventures. This quarter-acre cleared lot boasts exceptional features, including a beautiful Ipe wood boat dock, a 500-square-foot boathouse with a durable Galvalum metal roof, and 200 feet of solid concrete seawall along the scenic Matlacha Pass. Imagine designing your dream waterfront retreat, complete with room for a pool, to create your tropical haven. Bask in breathtaking sunsets and sunrises, thriving wildlife, and a lively boating community in a location renowned for world-class fishing. With effortless boat access to Pine Island Sound, Charlotte Harbor, Tarpon Pass, Redfish Pass, and the Gulf of Mexico, this property is your gateway to the quintessential Florida lifestyle. Don’t miss this rare opportunity to make your waterfront dreams a reality—claim your piece of paradise today!
Welcome to your opportunity to own a unique island paradise! This amazing gulf access home sits at the tip of a peninsula so you have amazing water views on 2 sides! This home offers a great family room with cathedral ceilings on the upper level and a balcony with ample room for entertaining or just enjoying the sunset over Matlacha Pass. There are 2 full bedrooms and 2 baths as well. The Primary bedroom offers a walk in closet and incredible water views. Watch the dolphins from your bed! The lower level offers over 1300 sqft (Under Air) of unfinished bonus space providing endless possibilities for customization, whether you choose to create a home office, gym, additional bedrooms, or additional living area. There is also plumbing in place for an additional 2 bathrooms! The 3 bay carport ensures that your vehicles are protected from the elements, while also providing extra storage space for all your outdoor gear. This unique island opportunity is a rare find, offering a peaceful escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. With a new roof in 2020, new AC upstairs and down in 2023, and a solid block base this home is ready for some cosmetic repairs. Don't miss your chance to own this slice of paradise and make memories that will last a lifetime. Live the island life you've always dreamed of in this beautiful home.
This is a beautifully renovated and restored Matlacha Cottage that represents the resiliency and spirit of this special little island. This home has superior wind protection with impact windows, doors and metal roof-----and suffered no known damage with the last two hurricanes! Walking distance from this home are restaurants, shops, a community park and boat launch, plus more business opening soon. This home must be seen as it is a jewel!
This Waterfront Lot is located on a 100ft wide canal, with Direct Access/No Bridges and only 5 lots away from Matlacha Pass!! Enjoy Matlacha living at it's best! This lot is ready for your new Florida Dream home!. Walk or bike to all Matlacha has to offer. You are just a short stroll to restaurants and shops. Public water and sewer are available/to be hooked up by buyer.
Dreaming of a cozy waterfront cottage with unbeatable access to world-class fishing and boating in Southwest Florida? This unique property is situated on two lots, has been remediated after flooding and is ready for your personal touch. Located just seconds from open waters, it's the ideal spot to embrace the laid-back lifestyle of Matlacha. A quaint, vibrant fishing village that's steadily reclaiming its charm and vitality. Call this sweet spot your own and come live the island dream! NOTE: Vacant lot directly to the West is included in the sale.
There’s no place like this home! Nestled just steps away from downtown Matlacha this Gulf Access property offers enormous potential. This historic home was built in 1946 and was just remodeled in 2023. A brand new storm resistant Florida room was added in the summer of 2024. This home is just as cute as can be and could easily be turned into a cash flow machine hosting vacation rentals. The oversized deck in the back is perfect for entertaining or just watching the boats go by and the dolphins play! Come check out this gem today!
Matlacha is an "Old Florida" fishing village, home to many bright and colorful art galleries, island boutiques, seafood restaurants, and traditional Floridian cottages. Matlacha is a community anyone is lucky to be a part of; it's one big family. This 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom charming pool home is right in the heart of Matlacha and it is one of the few homes on a double lot with 98 feet of waterfront. The home is equipped with a boat dock and boat lift, impact windows and doors, and a new roof installed in 2023. There is nothing quite like relaxing on your screened in patio, soaking up the sun in the pool and listening to the Osprey or hopping on your boat in your own back yard and cruising out to do some world class fishing or island hoping. You are literally ONE house from Matlacha Pass!! Charlotte Harbour, Boca Grande, Cayo Costa, North Captiva, Sanibel Island, and Fort Myers Beach are all at your fingertips! The opportunities are endless. In the mood for seafood but did more fishing than you did catching? You're in luck, you can enjoy some of the best restaurants with the freshest seafood (right off the commercial fishing boats in Matlacha) or pick up fresh seafood from one on the many seafood markets to enjoy at home. This property will be a true treasure to someone whether you want to fix it up as is, lift the home, build up the home, or tear it down and start fresh (this is a double lot so there is potential to build two homes). There is truly nothing like Matlacha!
Matlacha is an "Old Florida" fishing village, home to many brightly colored art galleries, island boutiques, seafood restaurants, and traditional Floridian cottages. Matlacha is a community anyone is lucky to be a part of; it's one big family. This 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom charming pool home is right in the heart of Matlacha and it is one of the few homes on a double lot with 98 feet of waterfront. The home is equipped with a boat dock and boat lift, impact windows and doors, and a new roof installed in 2023. There is nothing quite like relaxing on your screened in patio, soaking up the sun in the pool and listening to the Osprey or hopping on your boat in your own back yard and cruising out to do some world class fishing or island hoping. You are literally ONE house from Matlacha Pass!! Charlotte Harbour, Boca Grande, Cayo Costa, North Captiva, Sanibel Island, and Fort Myers Beach are all at your fingertips! The opportunities are endless. In the mood for seafood but did more fishing than you did catching? You're in luck, you can enjoy some of the best restaurants with the freshest seafood (right off the commercial fishing boats in Matlacha) or pick up fresh seafood from one on the many seafood markets to enjoy at home. This property will be a true treasure to someone whether you want to fix it up as is, lift the home, build up the home, or tear it down and start fresh (this is a double lot so there is potential to build two homes). There is truly nothing like Matlacha!
Welcome to the Matlacha Tiny Village – Where COASTAL CHARM meets BIG Opportunity! This extraordinary property features THREE charming, Amish built TINY HOMES, each uniquely designed to capture the artistic and vibrant spirit of Matlacha. Each tiny home features a well-appointed kitchenette with induction cooktop, refrigerator, microwave and coffee maker, providing all the comforts of home. These charming units are highly sought after, renting for $225+ per night during peak season and $129-$149 per night off-season, making them an outstanding year-round income opportunity! Perfectly situated on a prime GULF ACCESS waterfront lot with OVERSIZE DOCK (up to a 32’ boat) and kayak launch, six guest parking spots, utilities and room for two or three more tiny/RV homes. The property offers dockside fishing, serene sunrises and direct access to the Gulf of Mexico’s world-renowned fishing and waterways. Nestled in the heart of Matlacha, this one-of-a-kind property perfectly embodies the area’s artistic and laid-back vibe. Matlacha is a tiny, Old Florida fishing village with iconic galleries, restaurants and boutiques. The property’s prime waterfront location offers direct access to the Gulf of Mexico, making it an outdoor enthusiast’s paradise for fishing, kayaking or simply enjoying breathtaking sunsets. Perfectly suited for nightly, short-term or monthly vacation rentals. This is a great entrepreneurial venture for the innovative spirit looking to capitalize on the growing trend of sustainable, minimalist living while providing a truly unique experience for visitors. A property like this is truly one of a kind, combining unparalleled income potential with the unique opportunity to be on the ground floor of Matlacha’s pivotal and inspiring revitalization. Whether you’re an innovative entrepreneur, savvy investor, seasoned VRBO owner or dreamer seeking a slice of paradise, the Matlacha Tiny Village is your canvas to create something remarkable. This business opportunity can be turnkey, with an established website, active social media presence, etc. making it ready to generate income again immediately. Create a SOCIAL MEDIA SENSATION by transforming this property into a must-visit destination for eco-conscious travelers and tiny home enthusiasts. With its sustainable design, minimalist charm, and prime location in vibrant Matlacha, this property is poised to capture the hearts of tourists and influencers alike. Showcase its unique appeal through captivating content and turn it into the next viral hotspot for authentic, unforgettable experiences. This is a legally, non-conforming, grandfathered RV Park with a future land use designation of commercial C-1, offering abundant opportunities for future development and growth. This location offers exceptional visibility and exposure, ensuring your property stands out and attracts attention. Walking distance to Matlacha Community Center, Park, Art Center, Public Parking, Boat Launch, Restaurants & Shops. Call us!
Welcome to your dream waterfront escape in Matlacha, where tropical charm meets modern convenience. This 2-bedroom, 2-bath home is a true island oasis, located just minutes from the Gulf. Whether you’re spending a family day on the water or heading out for a fishing adventure, this property offers seamless access to paradise. The home is a blank canvas, ready for your personal touch, with desirable features already in place. Enjoy peace of mind with impact windows and stay connected with outside security cameras. The kitchen boasts stainless steel appliances, while the versatile utility room/man cave adds extra functionality and a closed in sun room that adds an additional 200+ sq ft to the home. Outdoors, this property truly shines! Take advantage of two boat lifts and a convenient fish cleaning station for all your Gulf catches. Relax or entertain under the remodeled tiki hut, surrounded by the privacy of a fenced backyard. This unique property is perfect for those seeking coastal living at its finest. Don’t wait—make this slice of paradise your own today!
Enjoy the breathtaking sunset views from this amazing Matlacha Property. It’s all about location and this is the location to be. Just a few steps from downtown Matlacha and just minutes to the open waters of the Gulf. The property has a historic home on it. The home can be lifted and repaired or you may chose to start fresh and build your own dream on the property. Whichever the case you will have a great island get-away! The custom pool is perfect for enjoying those lazy summer days. Watch the dolphins play as you take a dip. Make this property yours today!!!
2/3 pool home in Matlacha! This home is located in the heart of Matlacha and is within walking distance to downtown Matlacha. This home has a great layout inside and out and the square footage is used wisely including lots of storage. The outside living space of this home is ideal for an island home and even features a full bath including a workshop! Home also features a newer roof. This home is everything you would want in an island home and is ready for your vision to become a reality! Come see today and start Living the Island Life!
Relax in this charming cottage home on direct gulf access with NO bridges! Enjoy listening to the osprey, doves, mockingbirds and more while watching manatees and dolphins play! Located in the heart of Matlacha an artsy community. This home is located at the upper end of Island Avenue, with less traffic, a calm environment and a very deep and wide canal - you are one minute out to the open waters of Matlacha Pass. The owners have remodeled the interior of the home and every inch of space is used, including a new island in the middle of the kitchen. Recently, the garage floor was epoxied with bright yellow and green chips, PERFECT for a studio setup. Throughout are porcelain floors with an Italian torgenol design, oversized bedrooms, two updated bathrooms, storm rated windows, doors, new a/c and water heater; a lift and dock are included with an option to buy the boat. Enjoy the screened in lanai with an attached and inviting pergola. The community has over 200 homes, and this home is within walking distance to restaurants and shops. Enjoy kayaking from your dock to the mangrove island where Roseate Spoon birds and other Florida birds feed. The home had water intrusion from Milton and is in the process of being remediated. When you enter the front door, enjoy the brightness of the interior and the scenic view of the canal. Matlacha is known for it's iconic, photographic sunrises and sunsets. Don't pass up a chance to live a relaxing life in Olde Florida.
Welcome to your slice of paradise in Matlacha, Florida! This charming 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom home is a hidden gem waiting for your personal touch. Nestled in a vibrant neighborhood known for its artistic flair and laid-back lifestyle, this property offers a unique opportunity for those seeking a coastal retreat or a savvy investment. As you approach the house, you'll immediately notice its potential. While it's in need of a full rehab, this blank canvas allows you to create your dream home from the ground up. Imagine the possibilities as you transform each room to reflect your personal style and coastal inspirations. One of the standout features of this property is its enviable location with sailboat access. Boating enthusiasts will be thrilled by the private dock, complete with a convenient kayak launch. Picture yourself setting sail on crystal-clear waters or paddling through serene mangrove tunnels – all just steps from your back door! The home's interior spans a comfortable 1,154 square feet, providing ample space for relaxation and entertainment. The layout is well-designed, with the two bedrooms offering privacy and comfort for residents and guests alike. The two bathrooms ensure convenience for all, eliminating those morning rushes we all know too well. Despite its need for renovation, this property boasts some impressive updates that will save you time and money in the long run. The metal roof provides durability and protection against Florida's sometimes temperamental weather. Impact windows provide peace of mind during storm season. Energy efficiency is also a priority here. The tankless hot water heater ensures you'll never run out of hot water (goodbye, cold showers!), while also reducing energy consumption. The elevated AC unit and handler are smartly positioned to protect against potential flooding and improve overall system efficiency. The surrounding community is a treasure trove of amenities and natural beauty. Just a short distance away, you'll find Bat House Park – a unique local attraction that's sure to be a conversation starter with visitors. For your daily needs, Publix Super Market at Coral Shores is conveniently located nearby, ensuring you're never far from fresh groceries and essentials. This property isn't just a home; it's an opportunity. With its excellent location and potential for customization, it could serve as a lucrative rental investment. Imagine the appeal to vacationers looking for an authentic Florida experience, complete with water access and local charm. As you consider this property, envision the coastal oasis it could become. Whether you're looking for a permanent residence, a vacation home, or an investment opportunity, this Matlacha gem offers a canvas for your dreams. The combination of location, potential, and key updates makes this a unique find in today's market. Don't let this opportunity sail away! Schedule a viewing today and take the first step towards owning your piece of Florida paradise. Who knows? Your next great adventure might be just a renovation away! Sellers make no warranties or guarantees that any appliances left are in operating order - the washer/dryer have not been turned on. Please do your due diligence. •quartz countertops • A/C unit and handler 2023 • Lanai ceiling, screens and door replaced 2023 • carport ceiling 2023 • Exterior painted 2022
CALLING ALL BOATERS! Here's your chance to create the custom home of your dreams! This waterfront property, set on just under a quarter of an acre, is ready to be reimagined and rebuilt to your exact specifications. The home suffered damage from Hurricane Ian and is being sold AS IS, awaiting your finishing touches and personal style. A new roof was installed in 2023. Enjoy sprawling views of Matlacha Pass, and see dolphins, manatees, and birds from your lanai. You can catch snook, snapper and even tarpon from your yard. Relax by the pool and spa with a good book or a refreshing beverage as you take in the stunning Southwest Florida sunsets, making every evening a picturesque and tranquil experience. Boaters, fishermen, canoe, and kayak lovers will find endless potential right from your backyard leading to the Gulf of Mexico and direct access to Cayo Costa, Captiva, and Fort Myers Beach. Locally, youâ??ll love the artsy and quaint Malatcha lifestyle with art galleries, restaurants, ice cream shop just minutes from your home. This is your opportunity to embrace the waterfront lifestyle and create a truly personalized home! Agents please see remarks.
All the potential in the world - a complete unicorn and destination property located in the heart of Matlacha right across the Matlacha Bridge and the gateway to Pine Island. This is the former Olde Fish House Restaurant and Marina. Property was damaged during Hurricane Ian and Milton and is sold as - is. This rare property has the potential to be a destination restaurant and had at one time, 12 slips and two gas pumps. Buyer to do due diligence as Seller has never occupied property. Matlacha is an historic fishing community with some of the best fishing and boating in SWFL, with easy access to Cape Coral. This includes both properties at 4520 and 4530 Pine Island Rd NW. Both parcels are designated as Historical Parcels.