Courtesy: RE/MAX Integrity
585-229-4094
Waterfront home with 4 bedroom 2 bath with open kitchen living room on the first floor with 2 bedrooms and family room with 2 more bedroom down with walkout to lake, Huge deck off the living room with awesome views of the lake and hills. Detached garage with upstairs for workshop or storage. The waterfront is all gravel, Established rental history call for details! Easy showings!!
Courtesy: Cassara Realty Group
585-329-4419
Quintessential Honeoye Lake Cottage – Level Beach, Sunset Views & Ultimate Privacy. Welcome to true Finger Lakes living at 5436 Hamilton Point! Tucked away at the end of a quiet private road with no through traffic, this year-round 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath lakefront cottage offers peace, privacy, and incredible short-term rental potential on Honeoye Lake. The heart of the home features a light-filled kitchen with vaulted ceilings, skylights, and exposed wooden beams, along with a warm propane freestanding stove. In the living room, sliding doors open directly onto the deck overlooking the water—perfect for seamless indoor-outdoor entertaining. Downstairs convenience continues with first-floor laundry, while the upper-level primary bedroom features vaulted ceilings and a private balcony with front-row seats to spectacular Finger Lakes sunsets. Outside, enjoy versatile outdoor living with both front and back decks. A level shale beach makes water access effortless for swimming, kayaking, or boating. The property also includes a detached 2-car garage and a storage shed to keep all your water toys and gear secure. Located just minutes from local breweries, dining, parks, and shopping, you’re also perfectly positioned for easy trips to nearby Naples, Canandaigua, and Bristol Mountain. Whether you're seeking a permanent waterfront retreat, a classic vacation escape, or an income-generating investment, this Honeoye gem is ready for its next chapter. First showings Friday 11/6 at 12pm. All offers reviewed Monday 11/9 at 3pm.
Courtesy: Core Agency RE INC
585-420-8520
Discover the possibilities with this year-round Cape Cod nestled on a private, wooded 3.7-acre lot with beautiful lake views! Surrounded by nature, this property offers a peaceful setting with plenty of room to make it your own. Whether you're looking for a year-round residence, a weekend retreat, or a renovation project, this property presents an exciting opportunity.The home features an open-concept kitchen and living area, creating a comfortable and inviting gathering space. The kitchen includes a stainless steel refrigerator, gas stove and dishwasher. A woodstove currently serves as the home's heat source. The bedrooms formerly housed electric baseboard heating. A charming front room with wall-to-wall windows brings the outdoors in, filling the space with natural light and offering beautiful views of the surrounding woods and glimpses of the lake. Step outside onto the front deck, where you can relax and take in the scenic lake views through the trees. A detached two-car garage provides ample space for vehicles, recreational toys, tools, and storage. PUBLIC WATER HOOK UP IS AVAILABLE, offering additional possibilities for future improvements. ***The home is in need of repairs and updates and is being sold strictly as-is, where-is*** Bring your vision and creativity to unlock the potential of this unique property. Enjoy the privacy of a wooded retreat while remaining conveniently located close to town and everyday amenities. An opportunity to create your own getaway or year-round home in a beautiful natural setting! Enjoy easy access to Canadice Lake, Honeoye Lake, and craft breweries, wineries, and Finger Lakes destinations surrounding Honeoye & Canandaigua Lakes. Allow 24 hours for review of all offers.
Courtesy: Finger Lakes Premier Prop.
888-599-4810
Welcome to 8829 Sandy Bottom on Honeoye Lake! Offering 1,814 square feet of living space and an impressive 121 feet of gorgeous, level lake frontage, this spacious 4-bedroom home with the potential for a 5th bedroom is ready to make lake memories. The open-concept kitchen and living area create the perfect gathering space, featuring beautiful cabinetry, granite countertops, and a generously sized dining area with room for a crowd. The first floor offers two bedrooms and a full bath, while the second floor provides an additional two to three bedrooms and another full bath, giving family and guests plenty of room to spread out. Gorgeous windows fill the home with natural light and showcase stunning lake views. Step outside to the covered patio for morning coffee, or gather around the fire in the evening after a day on the water. And there's more! The property features a private boat launch, two garages, one for parking and storage and the other currently set up as a gaming and entertainment space. Located near Sandy Bottom Park, complete with nature trail, playground and public boat launch. Walking distance to local restaurants and all the amenities.With an excellent rental history, this property offers the flexibility to enjoy as your own year-round lake home, a relaxing getaway, or an income-producing investment. With level lake frontage and room for everyone, this is Honeoye Lake living at its best! Delayed negotiations until Thursday, November 12, 2026.
Courtesy: Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester
585-362-8900
The hillside Finger Lakes retreat you’ve been waiting for! Nestled on 3+ wooded acres...nature at its finest with hiking trails and mini waterfalls. Enjoy year-round views of Honeoye Lake from some rooms! Whether you are seeking a turn-key vacation home/rental, or a place to call home every day with privacy, natural beauty, updated mechanicals, modern finishes, and easy access to town & outdoor recreation... this home is for you! From a location standpoint, this place checks all the boxes. 20 minutes to Bristol Mountain. 10 minutes to Hunt Hollow Ski Club. Nearby Honeoye Lake and boat launch, perfect for kayaking and fishing. Easy access to Rochester, Canandaigua Lake, breweries, wine trail and everything the FLX has to offer! Inside you’ll find a modern lodge vibe with open concept living and dining, fully remodeled kitchen with stainless steel appliances and butcher block counters! New LVT flooring throughout 1st floor. Half bath adds convenience. Upstairs has room for everyone with 5 bedrooms and full bath, laundry, hardwood floors. Entertain in the bonus game room and enjoy hillside views. Game room was formerly an attached 1-car garage. UPDATES GALORE! Metal Roof 2019. Brand new septic system 2022. LP Furnace 2020. Hot water tank, water pump and filtration 2023. Vinyl windows. Detached 2 car garage. High speed fiber internet. All furnishings & hot tub (2023) convey with sale. Total square footage of over 2,000 square feet! Sq Ft based on attached floor plan. Quick close available - be in before the holidays!
Courtesy: Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester
585-362-8900
No delayed negotiations! Lake views! Welcome to 6052 N Old West Lake Road, where Finger Lakes charm meets everyday comfort! This inviting 3-bedroom Cape Cod offers beautiful views of Honeoye Lake and a location that puts you close to everything the area has to offer. Inside, you’ll find a spacious kitchen, first-floor laundry, a full bath and a comfortable, easy-to-maintain layout. Upstairs, three bedrooms offer peaceful lake views to wake up to each morning. A wood burning fireplace to keep you warm all winter! Outside, enjoy nearly half an acre of space along with a detached two-car garage—perfect for vehicles, lake gear, kayaks, bikes and extra storage. Whether you’re looking for a year-round home, weekend getaway or your own home base in the Finger Lakes, this property offers an opportunity to enjoy lake-country living without the waterfront price tag. Just minutes from Honeoye, with easy access to the lake, outdoor recreation, skiing and everything the Finger Lakes region has to offer. Come see what life near Honeoye Lake is all about!
Courtesy: Cassara Realty Group
585-329-4419
Unrivaled year-round lakefront sanctuary situated on the highly coveted east side of Honeoye Lake! Set on a private 0.69-acre parcel featuring over 107 feet of prime waterfront, this custom post-and-beam estate offers an unmatched luxury resort lifestyle or high-performing turnkey investment opportunity. Thanks to its premier east-shore position, the property captures extraordinary west-facing, unobstructed sunsets every evening. Step inside to soaring cathedral tongue-and-groove timber ceilings, panoramic floor-to-ceiling lake vistas, and an open layout centering around two distinct living zones—one anchored by a stone fireplace and another featuring a wood-burning stove with walk-out deck access. The fully renovated gourmet chef’s kitchen boasts a gorgeous marble island, elegant leathered granite countertops, a built-in beverage refrigerator, a commercial gas range, stainless appliances, and a spacious dining area surrounded by water views. Main level accommodations include two comfortable bedrooms and an updated full bath with double marble vanity. The upper level features a huge bunk room that can sleep up to 8, a lofted reading nook overlooking the water, second bedroom equipped with its own sink, and a second full bath. Outside lies your private shoreline resort featuring an outdoor grill/kitchen area, a rare in-ground heated pool sitting directly along the water's edge, an adjacent hot tub, custom stone fire pit patio, double-tiered wrap-around decks, and a 38-foot private dock with pebble beach access. Exceptional storage and utility options abound with 4 total garage bays between the attached garage—which includes a private sauna—and the second detached garage, plus tons of parking available for vehicles, boats, water toys, and guests. Sqft includes 2017 addition. Enjoy a prime four-season location just minutes from the vibrant communities of Honeoye, Canandaigua, and Naples, with quick access to top Finger Lakes wineries, craft breweries, dining, and skiing at Bristol Mountain and Hunt Hollow. Don't miss this rare chance to own one of Honeoye Lake's premier resort-style properties; available fully furnished for immediate four-season enjoyment.
Courtesy: Real Broker NY LLC
585-470-8181
You usually have to choose between a view of Honeoye Lake, access to the water, and room to breathe. Here, you get all three. Tucked away from the road, this unique sage-green log cabin overlooks Honeoye Lake from a private setting of nearly three acres. As a bonus, it includes a right-of-way providing deeded water access to Honeoye Lake just across the road. Step onto the large deck or into the light-filled enclosed porch and you will immediately feel what makes this property special. Nearly every room captures a view of the water, bringing the peacefulness of the lake inside with you. With a first-floor bedroom, three additional bedrooms upstairs, and plenty of flexible space, there is room for everyone to visit and exciting possibilities for whatever you dream up next. The home has been well maintained and lovingly cared for, offering the rare combination of lake views, water access, privacy, and acreage without the lakefront price tag. This isn't simply a summer escape, either. Enjoy the changing leaves, quiet winter scenery, and everything the Honeoye Lake area offers throughout the year, all just minutes from Honeoye's everyday amenities. Some homes give you a beautiful lake view (and close neighbors.) This one gives you the view, access, and space. Delayed negotiations until 9/8 at 8pm. OPEN HOUSES 9/5 1-3PM, 9/7 5:30PM-7:30PM
Courtesy: eXp Realty, LLC
888-276-0630
Enjoy scenic views of Honeoye Lake from this charming seasonal ranch cottage overlooking the water! Sitting on a private .59 acres, this 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom ranch cottage offers 672 sq. ft., a 3-car garage and an open floor plan featuring hardwood floors, knotty pine walls, and two bay windows showcasing beautiful lake views. Equipped with a full kitchen w/ electric oven/stove, mini fridge, a dining room area and a sizable living room w/ big windows for natural sunlight. The lot is partially wooded, is only 4 miles from Sandy Bottom Beach and the flat backyard has major potential for a patio or deck to expand the lake views. A major highlight is the impressive 3-car garage offering 1,024 sq. ft., extra high ceilings (12+ ft), electric, water, ample storage, and plenty of workshop space. New tear-off roof on the house and garage in 2025. Updated windows throughout. A public water line is also conveniently available right by the house. Electric baseboard heat and a drilled well. There is plenty of opportunity here whether you want to use it as a seasonal getaway, investment or just somewhere to go for the lake views!
Courtesy: Cassara Realty Group
585-329-4419
Excellent investment opportunity. Some original details throughout. Ready to shine again. Two units downstairs one more unit upstairs. Apartment 3 has separate rear entrance. Nice front porch which leads to a common area foyer. Back garage bonus space is zoned commercial get creative with town approval. Electric is separate. Oil tank in basement not in use. Furnace is a 2025. Wonderful amenities all in close proximity. Right next door to dollar general, across from library, close distance to bank, Sandy bottom park and Honeoye Lake. Finger Lakes area provides two ski resorts, wineries, breweries, culinary delights, boating, fishing... so much to offer. Honeoye lake, Sandy bottom and mill creek right in the rear of the property. Also minuets to Canandaigua Lake (west side Onanda), Canadice lake and Hemlock Lake. AS IS SALE. Add to your portfolio, sweat equity at its finest.
Honeoye is located in New York. Honeoye, New York 14471has a population of 638. Honeoye 14471 is more family-centric than the surrounding county with 34.97% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 28.73%.
The median household income in Honeoye, New York 14471 is $65,225. The median household income for the surrounding county is $70,694 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Honeoye 14471 is 56.1 years.
The average high temperature in July is 80.5 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 16.4 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 34.9 inches per year, with 51.9 inches of snow per year.
