Welcome to 5812 Tiffin Avenue in Castalia, Ohio, a move-in-ready home located just steps from the new Margaretta single-campus school complex. Enjoy peaceful country living with convenient access to Sandusky, Lake Erie, Route 2, and US-6. Inside, the modern kitchen flows into a bright living room with a large bay window and mini AC unit, creating an open, comfortable space for everyday living. The upper level features three spacious bedrooms and a beautifully updated full bathroom. The finished lower level offers extra living space perfect for a family room, playroom, or home office, with laundry nearby. A standout three-seasons room provides the perfect spot to relax or entertain while overlooking the expansive backyard. Additional highlights include a large garage with workshop space and backyard accessible overhead door, scenic rural views, and recent updates such as a ~10-year-old roof, fresh carpet, new lighting, and fresh paint. Move-in ready and ideally located enjoy the best of Castalia country charm with close proximity to schools, parks, and Lake Erie amenities.
Welcome to 104 Braileya beautifully updated ranch offering modern comfort, stylish upgrades, and your own private backyard oasis! This home has been thoughtfully renovated from top to bottom, featuring a 50-year McElroy metal roof (special ordered), new furnace and added central air (2020), new hot water tank (2018), and updated electrical panel (2018) for peace of mind.The home includes new doors (front & sliding2018) with additional kitchen entry door replaced in 2025, plus a fully updated kitchen (2025) with fresh finishes that make daily living and entertaining a breeze. Step outside to enjoy the newly built front porch (2025), new shutters (2025), and a spacious backyard perfect for relaxing. Also the entire home is hardwired for internet. There's a plug inside the fireplace box for an electric fireplace.The highlight? Your very own backyard oasisideal for hosting, unwinding, and summertime fun with an above-ground pool.This ranch is truly move-in ready with quality improvements throughout. A must-see property that blends updates, charm, and outdoor living all in one!
This spacious 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath home offers an impressive blend of comfort, functionality, & thoughtful design w/attached 2 car garage & boasting a first floor primary suite w/heated bath floor, great room with gas log fireplace w/remote (2022). Rich oak flooring extends through much of the first level with a nearby dedicated Den/Office & first floor laundry plus laundry hookup on upper level! Enjoy your deck overlooking private back yard with greenhouse & garden shed. Below the main living area, the full, dry partially finished basement w/walkout offers abundant room for storage, hobbies, or future expansion. Even more appealing is the additional lower-level garage, complete with a tool rooman exceptional setup for DIY projects, equipment storage, or workshop space. NEW updates & special features already completed for new owner are: ALL NEW kitchen appliances plus washer/dryer (2023-2025), NEW 50 year Certain Teed Overall Roof (2023), NEW Central A/C (2023), 6'' insulated walls, 2 electric water heaters, 2 gas furnaces, front porch pull down blind, invisible dog fence PLUS Extra Refrigerator & Newer Chest Freezer in basement that stay. Possession at closing! (room sizes approximate, some pictures are virtually staged for decor ideas including actual picture of empty room, well is on site not used).
Well kept home owned by 1 owner. Open spacious layout with lots of room. Large front living room with large picture window. There is a dining room and an extra room off of the Kitchen. Large pantry closet. First floor laundry located in Mud Room between Garage and Dining Room. Back room offers many windows overlooking the back yard with door out to yard. There are 3 bedrooms with 2 bathrooms. PLUS - This Castalia home has a BASEMENT! Generator. Some hardwood floors. Lovely yard with an extra large shed that can house a riding mower, snow blower and any other equipment. This home includes an attached 1 car garage plus extra long driveway with a section for extra parking. Newer heat pump and hot water tank. Replacements windows in original part of home are Thermopane replacement by Olde Towne Windows.
Charming Countryside Home. Welcome to this delightful one-story home that perfectly blends comfort, functionality, and peaceful country living. Inside, you'll find 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 full baths, including a private master suite with its own entry. The inviting kitchen features beautiful custom wood cabinetry, generous storage, and comes fully equipped with all appliances.A finished basement with new flooring adds versatile living space ideal for a family room, recreation area, or cozy gathering spot. On the main floor, a large laundry area with extra storage offers everyday convenience. Storage is abundant throughout, with two floored attics (each with pull-down stairs and lighting) and a large outdoor shed. Step outside to the covered patio and enjoy the peace and quiet of country life.For hobbyists or those needing workspace, the finished and insulated 2-car garage features a floor drain, while the heated workshop includes built-in cabinets, an 8-foot workbench, and a private entrance perfect for projects year-round.Amenities include a generator, water softener, sump pump, security system, and dehumidifier all included with the home.Located just a short drive from area schools, shopping, and nearby communities, this property offers the serenity of the countryside with the convenience of town living truly the best of both worlds. Bonus Opportunity: A buildable lot on Susan Dr. is also available for purchase, offering even more potential to expand or invest in this beautiful area.
Major price improvement of $72,000! Rare opportunity in Castalia! Nestled on nearly 7.5 acres, this one story all-brick home offers the perfect blend of space to live, work, play, and build or grow your business—truly a property with endless possibilities. The land features two large outbuildings, including one with a dedicated office space, plus a deer blind for hunting enthusiasts—ideal for hobbyists, business owners, or anyone seeking room to spread out. Inside, the open floor plan flows into a warm and inviting family room with a woodburning fireplace and sliding doors leading to a deck overlooking the beautiful acreage. The attached 2-car garage provides added convenience. Acreage, outbuildings, and a home all in one package—this is a truly rare find in Castalia.
Andrea D. Conner, License BRKP.2017002935, Xome Inc., License REC.2015001703, [email protected], 844-400-XOME (9663), 11427 Read Hartman Hwy, Suite 236, Cincinnati, OH 45241
Information is provided exclusively for consumers personal, non - commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Copyright 2026, Firelands Association of REALTORS, all rights reserved.
Castalia is located in Ohio. Castalia, Ohio 44824has a population of 1,120. Castalia 44824 is more family-centric than the surrounding county with 24.2% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 21.06%.
The median household income in Castalia, Ohio 44824 is $44,120. The median household income for the surrounding county is $60,149 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Castalia 44824 is 28.4 years.
The average high temperature in July is 82.7 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 19.3 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 35.9 inches per year, with 24.1 inches of snow per year.
