The Wigwam, a beautifully restored and fully renovated 1860 cottage on Kelleys Island, set on roughly .75 acres with space to relax and entertain. This 4-bedroom home blends historic character with thoughtful updates, offering flexibility as your own island home, a rental, or a mix of both, and with the separate guest studio, it lives like a 5-bedroom. Inside, you'll find an open-concept layout with a fully updated kitchen, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, farmhouse sink, and a dedicated coffee bar. The dining area is designed for gathering, and the home has been professionally styled to blend historic character with fresh, modern finishes throughout. Outdoor space includes a spacious yard, patio, fire pit, and multiple areas for relaxing and entertaining. Currently operating as a successful short-term rental with an established history, this property offers flexibility as a personal island home, income-producing property, or a combination of both. Furnishings are negotiable for a potential turnkey transition.
Welcome to the Island's hidden gem. Enjoy the best both worlds with the large secluded lot that feels like you're living in the middle of the woods but still close to your own private beach and a short golf cart drive to downtown. Relax on the large wrap around deck with a drink or invite your whole family and friends over to enjoy this large 3,460 square foot home. This house has been meticulously crafted with high end finishes including cathedral ceilings, hard wood floors through out, and a wood burning fireplace. The kitchen has beautiful quarts counter tops, custom subway tile backsplash, and stainless steal appliances. The bathrooms have tile shower surrounds, marble counter tops and tile flooring. In the off season the large attached 2.5 car garage has been remodeled into a finished game room. The house also has a private drive that has been recently cleared and graveled. The property has potential to be rented with all rental inspections complete. Don't miss your change to own a piece of the island with this turn key property!
Welcome to the Island's hidden gem. Enjoy the best both worlds with the large secluded lot that feels like you're living in the middle of the woods but still close to your own private beach and a short golf cart drive to downtown. Relax on the large wrap around deck with a drink or invite your whole family and friends over to enjoy this large 3,460 square foot home. This house has been meticulously crafted with high end finishes including cathedral ceilings, hard wood floors through out, and a wood burning fireplace. The kitchen has beautiful quarts counter tops, custom subway tile backsplash, and stainless steal appliances. The bathrooms have tile shower surrounds, marble counter tops and tile flooring. In the off season the large attached 2.5 car garage has been remodeled into a finished game room. The house also has a private drive that has been recently cleared and graveled. The property has potential to be rented with all rental inspections complete.Don't miss your change to own a piece of the island with this turn key property!
Rare opportunity to own true Lake Erie frontage with no road between you and the water. Located on a private drive in the desirable East Point Subdivision on Kelleys Island, this beautifully remodeled home offers privacy, breathtaking views, and effortless Island Life and Living! Completely rebuilt and expanded with a large open addition in 2024, the home features extensive updates including a new roof, siding, stone exterior, windows, HVAC, framing, subfloor and joists, kitchen, bathrooms, appliances, electrical, plumbing, and spray foam insulation. Every detail was thoughtfully upgraded for modern comfort and long-term durability. Inside, the spacious layout includes 4 bedrooms and 3 full baths, comfortably accommodating up to 12 guests. Large windows throughout the home capture stunning Lake Erie views from nearly every room, filling the interior with natural light and waterfront scenery. The custom kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, featuring custom cabinetry and granite countertops, with the same quality finishes carried through all bathrooms. New Paved Road to Be Installed in 2026. Seller Will Cover the Cost of Road. Outdoor living is just as impressive. Relax on the spacious front porch overlooking the water, or entertain guests on the large stamped concrete back patio perfect for gatherings after a day on the lake. Just steps away, your private Lake Erie frontage provides a front-row seat to island sunsets and waterfront recreation. Furnishings are negotiable. Enjoy everything Kelleys Island has to offer, including charming shops, popular restaurants, scenic walking trails, and a beautiful state park, all just minutes away. Schedule Your Private Showing Today.
Charming Ranch on Kelleys Island Enjoy Easy, Single-Floor Living in this Inviting 2-Bedroom, 1-Bath Ranch Located in a Private, Family-Friendly Neighborhood. Perfectly Situated between Downtown Kelleys Island and Kelleys Island State Park and Sandy Beach, this Home offers Both Convenience and Tranquility. The Open Floor Plan Creates a Bright and Welcoming Living Space, ideal for Relaxing or Entertaining. The Kitchen Flows Seamlessly into the Living Area, and the Full Bath features a Tub and Shower Combo for Comfort and Functionality. Step outside to a Covered Front Porch Perfect for Morning Coffee and a Spacious Wooden Sun Deck off the Back, Ready for Summer Gatherings. The Attached 2+ Car Garage Provides Plenty of Room for Vehicles, Boats, Golf Carts, Bikes and Extra Storage, Complemented by an Oversized Pantry/Storage Room. New Roof in 2019! City Water. Paved Road. Septic System Features Multiple Leachfields Whether You're Looking for a Year-Round Residence or a Seasonal Getaway, This Well-Located Ranch Offers the Perfect Island Retreat.
Charming Ranch on Kelleys IslandEnjoy Easy, Single-Floor Living in this Inviting 2-Bedroom, 1-Bath Ranch Located in a Private, Family-Friendly Neighborhood. Perfectly Situated between Downtown Kelleys Island and Kelleys Island State Park and Sandy Beach, this Home offers Both Convenience and Tranquility.The Open Floor Plan Creates a Bright and Welcoming Living Space, ideal for Relaxing or Entertaining. The Kitchen Flows Seamlessly into the Living Area, and the Full Bath features a Tub and Shower Combo for Comfort and Functionality.Step outside to a Covered Front Porch Perfect for Morning Coffee and a Spacious Wooden Sun Deck off the Back, Ready for Summer Gatherings. The Attached 2+ Car Garage Provides Plenty of Room for Vehicles, Boats, Golf Carts, Bikes and Extra Storage, Complemented by an Oversized Pantry/Storage Room.New Roof in 2019!City Water. Paved Road. Septic System Features Multiple LeachfieldsWhether You're Looking for a Year-Round Residence or a Seasonal Getaway, This Well-Located Ranch Offers the Perfect Island Retreat.
Andrea D. Conner, License BRKP.2017002935, Xome Inc., License REC.2015001703, [email protected], 844-400-XOME (9663), 11427 Read Hartman Hwy, Suite 236, Cincinnati, OH 45241
Information is provided exclusively for consumers personal, non - commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Copyright 2026, Firelands Association of REALTORS, all rights reserved.
Kelleys Island is located in Ohio. Kelleys Island, Ohio 43438has a population of 289. Kelleys Island 43438 is less family-centric than the surrounding county with 4% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 21.06%.
The median household income in Kelleys Island, Ohio 43438 is $82,188. The median household income for the surrounding county is $60,149 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Kelleys Island 43438 is 65.9 years.
The average high temperature in July is 81.5 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 19.9 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 34.4 inches per year, with 23.4 inches of snow per year.
