An amazing opportunity to own a unicorn property with SO much potential and so many different options. Take advantage of this opportunity to build and expand upon current owner upgrades - this resort property is located in Matlacha, a renowned old Florida art and fishing village with easy access to Cape Coral, Pine Island and the multiple surrounding islands and also located directly on the Great Calusa Blueway - a 200 mile guided kayaking and paddling water trail. Matlacha is known for its Olde Florida community, tourism and some of the best fishing and boating right in your back yard, with endless views, a nature lover's paradise. Over 275 feet of water frontage, endless views, 5 boat slips (could be 6), magnificent potential and currently used as a short term vacation rental/hotel. Total Units: 12 units plus one office option(convertible to a 3rd bedroom in Unit 2 of the quad)and mirrors the 3-bedroom layout in Unit 3. Two buildings - Two-story building: 9 units (2× 2BR, 6× 1BR, 1 hotel room currently used as laundry), Single-story building: 1× 3BR, 1× 2BR, 2 studios, Square Footage: 7,400 SF (4,650 SF + 2,750 SF), Land: 1 Acre, direct waterfront, Zoning: multi-family on canal / hotel. This was fully renovated in 2025 and is in spectacular condition - attention to detail in all upgrades and this entire property and each unit is spacious, with upscale decor and furnishings. Financials are available with NDA. Opportunity for short and long term rentals.
Position your business at Matlacha’s most visible corner location! This fully remodeled commercial property at 4574 Pine Island Rd NW is currently operated as a real estate office and offers exceptional exposure plus two access points for smooth ingress/egress—ideal for trucks, service vehicles, and client traffic. Recent upgrades include a NEW roof, new flooring, and impact-rated hurricane doors and windows for peace of mind. The interior is light, bright, and inviting, creating a professional atmosphere for clients and staff. An ADA-accessible ramp enhances usability and compliance. Fantastic opportunity for a real estate office, professional services, medical office, retail showroom, or boutique business looking for maximum visibility at the gateway to Matlacha/Pine Island. Extensive parking and NEVER flooded! Traffic Count (16,100 AADT (average annual daily trips/vehicles per day) along the Pine Island Road corridor near Matlacha.
All the potential in the world - a complete unicorn and destination property located in the heart of Matlacha right across the Matlacha Bridge and the gateway to Pine Island. This is the former Olde Fish House Restaurant and Marina. Property was damaged during Hurricane Ian and Milton and is sold as - is. This rare property has the potential to be a destination restaurant and had at one time, 12 slips and two gas pumps. Buyer to do due diligence as Seller has never occupied property. Matlacha is an historic fishing community with some of the best fishing and boating in SWFL, with easy access to Cape Coral. This includes both properties at 4520 and 4530 Pine Island Rd NW. Both parcels are designated as Historical Parcels.
Prime waterfront commercial property for sale in the heart of Pine Island, Florida. 4547 Pine Island Road offers a rare chance to own both the building and land with three fully leased income-producing units. Zoned C-1, this well-maintained property is ideal for a variety of commercial uses, from retail and office space to service-based businesses. Featuring open water frontage and canal frontage, it delivers unique waterfront appeal that is hard to find in the Matlacha and Pine Island area. With over 15 dedicated parking spaces, the property is easily accessible for customers and tenants alike. Located in a high-visibility, high-traffic area close to shopping, dining, and popular attractions, it is just a short distance to Matlacha Park and the famous Fishing Bridge. The property’s waterfront location provides stunning open-water views, enhancing its value and appeal. Fully occupied with reliable tenants and boasting a strong rental history, this investment offers excellent income potential and long-term growth in one of Southwest Florida’s most desirable commercial corridors.
The information being provided is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Use of search facilities of data on the site, other than a consumer looking to purchase real estate, is prohibited. © 2026 MIAMI Association of REALTORS®, all rights reserved.
 |
| The source of the foregoing property information is a database compilation of an organization that is a member of the Southwest Florida Multiple Listing Service. Each Southwest Florida Multiple Listing Service member organization owns the copyright rights in its respective proprietary database compilation, and reserves all such rights. Copyright © 2026. The foregoing information including, but not limited to, any information about the size or area of lots, structures, or living space, such as room dimensions, square footage calculations, or acreage is believed to be accurate, but is not warranted or guaranteed. This information should be independently verified before any person enters into a transaction based upon it. |
Matlacha is located in Florida. Matlacha, Florida has a population of 827. Matlacha is more family-centric than the surrounding county with 47.81% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 20.71%.
The median household income for the surrounding county is $63,235 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Matlacha is 64.6 years.
The average high temperature in July is 91.9 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 52 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 53 inches per year, with 0 inches of snow per year.
