The Island Trading Post is a well-known island business with great visibility and frontage along Periwinkle Way, Sanibel Island's main thoroughfare. Once a bustling store with multiple showrooms and a loyal following, this is your chance to grab a prime location in the heart of Sanibel Island. This amazing offering is combined with the neighboring parcel offering a total of 150 feet of prime Periwinkle frontage and three structures including a 2,358-square-foot retail store in front with multiple showrooms and great parking. There is also a 2,390-square-foot residence in back offering four bedrooms, two baths and private natural views, and the next-door workshop and storage below with a nice apartment above, all along a pond teeming with birds and the Bailey Homestead Preserve beyond. There is plenty of parking in front all with multiple and easy access points to Periwinkle Way. This is your chance to establish a great business with prime frontage, and own multiple residential units all in the heart of Sanibel Island.
Unlock the potential of a unique dual property offering in the heart of Sanibel. Located at the highly visible corner of 1544 Periwinkle Way, this prime commercial property is the perfect anchor for your business, boasting maximum exposure on the island’s main thoroughfare. The additional parcel, 905 Fitzhugh Street, adds incredible versatility with a warehouse and an upstairs apartment, combining functionality with residential convenience. The main corner lot is ideal for retail, office, or service businesses, featuring ample space and unbeatable frontage to capture foot and vehicle traffic. The secondary property behind it expands your possibilities with a spacious warehouse for storage or operations and an apartment perfect for rental income, staff housing, or personal use. These properties offer the rare combination of high visibility, flexibility, and income-generating potential, all just moments from Sanibel’s beaches and island charm. Whether you're an investor, entrepreneur, or business owner, this is your chance to own a true gem on the island. Opportunities like this don’t come often—schedule your showing today and turn your vision into reality!
Rare opportunity to own a prime commercial property on beautiful Sanibel Island. This former restaurant, with an apartment upstairs is situated on a large lot, .62 acres and boasts 200' of frontage on Tarpon Bay Rd. The commercial space is approximately 1400 SF and the apartment is 1000 SF under air with a 376 SF wrap around screened porch, perfect for owner, staff or investment. Located in a busy area opposite the post office, this property offers potential for a variety of businesses. Property has been completely remediated has a new roof and impact windows and doors. Unlock the potential of this exceptional property!
Sanibel; named by Travel & Leisure as one of the top 50 “Best Places” internationally to visit in 2025, with its restaurants, shops and of course, Sanibel’s incredible beaches, rebuilt and open for business. Located in the resort zone and historically operated as a vacation daily rental, this quaint 3 unit Inn is part of that comeback, booking reservations since reopening in March 2024. This gem is a once in a lifetime opportunity for a buyer looking for an impressive income stream. Just steps away from the Donax St beach, it has consistently been a priority destination for visiting tourists that love Sanibel for its shells, beaches and small town vibe. New Central Air Conditioner, new furniture and enhancements in upper unit. The other 2 units have been rebuilt in totality, ground up. Also new roof, new siding, new landscaping, we have focused on each part of the process with forethought and care to make this again a destination for guests throughout the Country and Internationally. This Inn has been rented on the major online accounts since 2017 and has built up a reputation for consistent bookings. 2025 calendar is already booking out, so a buyer will close with income already in place. In addition, many previous guests book direct and come back year after year. This special property is a 100 year land lease with over 50 years remaining and a smart and stable investment without the volatility of other investment options. With all the working policies and procedures already in place, a new owner can virtually take over an established business, streamlined with proven efficiencies and income.
ADDITIONAL PROPERTIES TO BE SOLD AS A PACKAGE INCLUDE: 4788 TRADEWINDS DRIVE - 19-46-22-T2-00400.0540 RESIDENTIAL HOME 1344 JAMAICA DRIVE - 19-46-22-T2-00400.0570 DUPLEX 1350 JAMAICA DRIVE - 19-46-22-T2-00400.0580 DUPLEX Don’t miss this incredible investment opportunity to acquire income-producing properties on Sanibel Island. This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to acquire a distinguished portfolio of properties located on and near the Gulf of Mexico. Included in this extraordinary portfolio: Four separate parcels, all within a few yards from each other. A six-unit Gulf-front hotel with unobstructed views of breathtaking sunsets. Two separate duplexes just yards away from the hotel and beach access. A residential piling home with a pool located across the street from the beach and the hotel. Imagine not just owning one, but four exclusive island parcels mere steps away from the pristine shores of the Gulf of Mexico. Seize this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own four slices of paradise on Sanibel Island.
Courtesy: DomainRealty.com LLC
Adrian Kastner
2.29 Acres of commercial property ready for redevelopment! Don't miss this opportunity! This great investment is approved for remodel! The sale includes the 7500SF 200 seat restaurant with a full service bar/lounge and 4COP liquor license, all furniture and furnishings, all restaurant and kitchen equipment, land, and business name. Donât miss this tremendous MONEY MAKING opportunity to live and work in Paradise!
 |
| The source of the foregoing property information is a database compilation of an organization that is a member of the Southwest Florida Multiple Listing Service. Each Southwest Florida Multiple Listing Service member organization owns the copyright rights in its respective proprietary database compilation, and reserves all such rights. Copyright © 2025. The foregoing information including, but not limited to, any information about the size or area of lots, structures, or living space, such as room dimensions, square footage calculations, or acreage is believed to be accurate, but is not warranted or guaranteed. This information should be independently verified before any person enters into a transaction based upon it. |
 |
The data relating to real estate for sale on this Website come in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than this broker are marked with the BR Program Icon or the BR House Icon and detailed information about them includes the name of the Listing Brokers. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available through the BR Program. The accuracy of this information is not warranted or guaranteed. This information should be independently verified if any person intends to engage in a transaction in reliance upon it. Some properties that appear for sale on this website may no longer be available. |
Sanibel is located in Florida. Sanibel, Florida has a population of 6,437. Sanibel is less family-centric than the surrounding county with 1.95% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 20.71%.
The median household income in Sanibel, Florida is $103,413. The median household income for the surrounding county is $63,235 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Sanibel is 68.2 years.
The average high temperature in July is 91.7 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 53.4 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 53.8 inches per year, with 0 inches of snow per year.
