Terry’s Pizza Shoppe, Newcomerstown’s beloved hometown pizza shop is for sale! This is a well-established family business of 46 years and is a turn-key business opportunity for the next owner to continue its success and growth. The business features a fully equipped kitchen and is fully staffed with 2 full-time and 3 part-time employees. The 1480 square foot space includes a main dining area that seats approximately 65 people with 13 booths and two 8’ foot tables with 12 chairs. Great location, close to all the schools, and ample parking. The building is leased at 433 W. State Street, Newcomerstown, and the sale is contingent on lease agreement with Lessor.
This commercial property offers excellent curb appeal and convenience with its prime location on a highly trafficked street. Property Features, High-traffic location: Positioned on one of the main streets, providing great visibility for businesses and easy access for clients. Ample parking: Includes 25 parking spaces, ensuring convenience for staff and customers alike—especially beneficial for high-traffic businesses. Single-story layout: The one-floor design is ideal for accessibility and efficiency, making it perfect for professional offices, medical or dental practices, or other service-oriented businesses. Flexible interior: Open layout, easily customizable to fit the needs of various businesses, whether a medical office, law firm, or other professional offices. No banks or financial institutions.
NOW AVAILABLE--26x37 with 12x14 Improvement Shop Building with 1.31 Acre Fully Fenced-In Material Storage Yard with Two Loading Docks. Proximity to US 36 & I-77 creates this property to be positioned in an excellent location. Located in the Village of Newcomerstown in Tuscarawas County, this property has city utilities and a private restroom. Any contents in property on day of possession will convey to the new owner at closing. Additionally available is an adjacent property with MLS#224017247 that consists of a large, first floor commercial office building with handicap accessibility that can be purchased together or in conjunction with this property. Contact a licensed real estate agent for a private showing.
Check out this established business front. Property features, two business storefronts, four rented apartments, offstreet parking for apartments. Apartments are all electric with baseboard heat, owner is currently paying water and sewer. There are additional apartments that need updated for potential rent in the future. Market rent for one bedroom units in Tuscarawas county is $650. Owner had storefront rented out for $450. Baseboard heaters were added in 2015, new flooring and 2015 and painted in 2015 for all back three apartments. New roof on storefront to the left in 2016. Owner is unsure of age of roof for other storefront.
Opportunity abounds with this 110-acre property that includes a gravel pit with available reserves estimated at about 14,000,000 tons and currently valued at over $4.4 million from 66 minable acres. The remaining acreage is wooded and wetland, and the property has around 1,500 feet of frontage on the Tuscarawas River. Also included is equipment valued at $125,000, and a log cabin nicely tucked away near the river. The cabin has geothermal heating, air conditioning, laundry hookups and more. Call and schedule your private showing today!
Opportunity abounds with this 110-acre property that includes a gravel pit with available reserves estimated at about 14,000,000 tons and currently valued at over $4.4 million from 66 minable acres. The remaining acreage is wooded and wetland, and the property has around 1,500 feet of frontage on the Tuscarawas River. Also included is equipment valued at $125,000, and a log cabin nicely tucked away near the river. The cabin has geothermal heating, air conditioning, laundry hookups and more. Call and schedule your private showing today!
21.777 acres beautifully prepped for housing development. This property is tucked in behind Cy Young Memorial Park approximately .5 mile from State Route 36. Property has been surveyed into approximately 45 lots. Developmental Plat Maps are available to see the possibilities. Property is with in city limits and public utilities are available. There is a 3 bedroom 2 bath home on the property that owners purchase to have direct access to the development. It was purchased with the intent to be torn down.
Come to downtown Newcomerstown to own a beautiful piece of history with heavy foot traffic. Home of Woody Hayes and CY Young. The Village of Newcomerstown is revamping this downtown area (Projects and Developments in supplements). It will have newly painted buildings, benches, new sidewalks, plants and lights. This vacant former bank branch with drive-thru and still has the vault. This would be well suited for a variety of uses. It is situated on a main retail corridor with thriving businesses. A few ideas - this would make a great restaurant, sports bar or distillery on main floor and could rent out office spaces above and below. This is a spacious Romanesque building 7000+ sq ft. Right off the 36 and 77 interchange. Home of Woody Hayes and CY Young. The local Village is prepared and willing to work with new owner to encourage new business to Main St. Building has recently been power washed. This building also features additional large amount of square footage on second floor, currently enclosed behind walls. Removing walls would significantly expand the usable 2nd story space of this building. Additional space on outside of building facing cross street of approximately 336 sqft that is part of building as well was previously used as barber shop.
Andrea D. Conner, License BRKP.2017002935, Xome Inc., License REC.2015001703, [email protected], 844-400-XOME (9663), 11427 Read Hartman Hwy, Suite 236, Cincinnati, OH 45241
Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Copyright © 2025 Columbus and Central Ohio Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.
Newcomerstown is located in Ohio. Newcomerstown, Ohio has a population of 3,809. Newcomerstown is less family-centric than the surrounding county with 20.85% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 27.62%.
The median household income in Newcomerstown, Ohio is $42,031. The median household income for the surrounding county is $57,545 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Newcomerstown is 40.3 years.
The average high temperature in July is 83.6 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 20.1 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 39.9 inches per year, with 20.7 inches of snow per year.
