Looking for a five-unit investment property near I-376 and Route 30 with separate utilities and strong rental upside? 217-219 5th Street in Wilmerding offers a rare opportunity to own both a duplex and a triplex on one deed and parcel, minutes from North Versailles, Monroeville, and major eastern suburb employment centers. This distinctive property consists of two separate residential buildings, a duplex at 217 5th Street and a triplex at 219 5th Street, providing flexibility for investors seeking rental income, portfolio expansion, or long-term value appreciation. The duplex features upper and lower units with matching floor plans. Each unit offers a covered front porch, a spacious 14x13 living room, 14x10 dining room, 13x8 kitchen, one bedroom measuring 14x11, and a full bathroom. Separate utilities allow for simplified management and tenant responsibility. The triplex at 219 5th Street includes three individual units. The first and second floor apartments feature nearly identical layouts, each with a generous 17x7 covered front porch, a 13x13 living room, 11x9 dining room, kitchen, one bedroom measuring 14x12, and a full bathroom. The third floor apartment offers its own unique layout with a 14x13 living room, 12x9 dining room, 12x11 bedroom, and 10x10 kitchen. An outdoor covered space off the kitchen includes a spiral staircase leading to the first floor, adding character and functionality to the unit. Additional value comes from significant capital improvements completed throughout the property. Electrical service has been updated throughout both buildings. The triplex furnaces and hot water tanks were replaced approximately in 2019-2020, helping reduce future maintenance concerns and providing added peace of mind for investors. Ideally located in Wilmerding within the East Allegheny School District, this property offers convenient access to I-376 and Route 30, making commuting throughout the eastern suburbs and into Downtown Pittsburgh easy. The property is just minutes from Monroeville, North Versailles, shopping, dining, and public transportation. Major employers and employment centers, including the Amazon fulfillment facility in North Versailles, help support continued rental demand in the area. Residents also enjoy proximity to the historic Westinghouse district and the broader Monroeville retail and business corridor. Whether you are expanding an existing portfolio, completing a 1031 exchange, or searching for a rare five-unit property with separate utilities, updated mechanical systems, and strong upside potential, 217-219 5th Street presents an exceptional investment opportunity in a location positioned for convenience, accessibility, and long-term rental appeal.
Former St Jude the Apostle Church and Rectory for Sale - Church has +/- 16,000 sqft of space and Rectory has +/- 6,788 sqft Property is zoned R-3 High Density Residential in the Borough of Wilmerding
Great opportunity in Wilmerding!! HUGE brick warehouse with so much potential! Centrally located!! Could be used as office space, retail space, warehouse space, etc. Blank slate waiting for it's new owner!
This Unique And Versatile Property Boasts A Rich History - Originally Built As A Church, Later Converted To A Funeral Home, And Most Recently Used As A Personal Care Home With The Same Caring Name Retained. Offering A Blend Of Classic Character And Functional Space, This Property Presents An Excellent Opportunity For Continued Care Use Or Creative Repurposing. Step Inside to Discover A Thoughtfully Laid-Out Interior Featuring A Total Of 9 Rooms With 19 Beds And Multiple Bathrooms, Designed For Easy Flow And Practical Daily Use. The First Floor Includes Five Spacious Rooms And Two Full Bathrooms, Along With A Dedicated Office Area That Offers Convenient Access To The Interior Of The 2-Car Garage - Perfect For Staff, Storage, Or Operational Needs. The Second Floor Features Four Additional Rooms And Two Full Bathrooms. Up On The Third Floor You’ll Find Three More Rooms And One Full Bathroom, Offering Flexibility For Staffing Quarters, Private Suites, Or Additional Living Areas. This Property Sits In A Quiet, Established Neighborhood In Wilmerding With A Residential Feel, Yet Remains Close to Local Amenities, Schools, Parks, And Shopping. Easy Access To Major Roads Makes Commuting To Downtown Pittsburgh And Surrounding Areas. Whether You’re Looking To Continue Assisted Living Operations, Develop A Unique Residential Community, Or Explore Other Adaptive Reuse Possibilities, 200 Caldwell Avenue Offers Space, Character, And Potential In A Prime Location.
TURNKEY RESTAURANT & (4) 2 BEDROOM APARTMENTS FULLY RENTED! Located in the Eastern Suburbs of Pittsburgh within Historic Wilmerding, this restaurant offers endless possibilities. Stand on the shoulders of Success with this one as the Current Owner Looks to Retire. Currently still operating & in business for 32 years, Johnny's Italian Restaurant is prime for its next owner. Take advantage of the great reputation & loyal customer base with 550+ google reviews & 4.6 rating. The current layout provides flexibility with occupancy for 130 guests in the dining room, lounge, & banquet room. Located in a town full of charm & history, makes this a great destination site with convenient access to routes 30, 148, & the TriBoro. Sale Includes the building with many mechanical updates, equipped kitchen with updated equipment, walk in cooler & freezer, fryers, hood, fully furnished, point of sale software, PA Hotel liquor license, 4 Rented Apartments, & more. Still operating please schedule APPT.
The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the IDX Program of the West Penn MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Copyright 2026 West Penn Multi-List™. All rights reserved.
Wilmerding is located in Pennsylvania. Wilmerding, Pennsylvania has a population of 1,846. Wilmerding is less family-centric than the surrounding county with 18.1% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 27.79%.
The median household income in Wilmerding, Pennsylvania is $26,985. The median household income for the surrounding county is $66,659 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Wilmerding is 38.1 years.
The average high temperature in July is 83.9 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 21.1 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 39.1 inches per year, with 17.3 inches of snow per year.
