855.375.4001
Listing Courtesy of: Michael A Gleeson - Coldwell Banker Sol Needles Real Estate
$3,150,000 affordable loan icon Calculate Payment

3937 Bayshore Cold Spring, NJ 08204

Down payment assistance icon
Single Family Residence
5 Beds
4 Baths
... Bed/Bath
4,584 Sq. Ft.

Property Activity

Time on Site
days
Days on Market
Views
Saves
Last updated on 4/8/2026 3:00 PM
A rare offering on Cape May Island, this extraordinary waterfront estate blends modern coastal architecture with complete privacy and natural beauty. Set on 1.02 secluded acres along the canal, this custom-built home is quietly surrounded by protected forest while remaining just minutes from Cape Ma...yâ??s celebrated restaurants, shops, and beaches. Completed in 2023, the residence was thoughtfully designed to capture light, views, and connection to the outdoors. Oversized windows frame sweeping canal and forest views from nearly every room, while expansive decks provide the perfect vantage point to watch boats glide by or enjoy peaceful evenings immersed in nature. Inside, the home offers 4,584 square feet of refined living space with 11-foot ceilings throughout the first floor and a dramatic vaulted great room featuring a loft and architectural catwalk. A striking masonry fireplace with custom white oak millwork anchors the living space, creating a warm and elegant focal point. The chefâ??s kitchen was designed for both entertaining and everyday living, featuring high-end appliances, an oversized 12-foot island, and a walk-in butlerâ??s pantry, flowing seamlessly into a dining area highlighted by a custom white oak dining table crafted specifically for the space. A 12-foot sliding glass door opens to the outdoor deck and patio, creating a seamless indoorâ??outdoor living experience ideal for entertaining. The home includes five bedrooms, four bathrooms, and two flexible living spaces currently used as a playroom and private sitting room/office, offering versatility for hosting guests or working remotely. A rare feature in Cape May, the property also includes a 2,415-square-foot basement with 9-foot ceilings designed for recreation and wellness. Highlights include a fully equipped gym; a custom-built cedar sauna with an oversized electric heater and 180-pound rock capacity; and a large childrenâ??s play area with a climbing wall and play structures, along with extensive storage. Additional features include: â?¢ 2.5-car garage with vaulted ceilings â?¢ Dual laundry rooms â?¢ 554 sq ft of decks and porches overlooking the water â?¢ Direct canal access â?¢ Large horseshoe driveway with ample parking â?¢ Solar panels, wood-burning furnace, well, and a septic system for enhanced sustainability and self-sufficiency. Despite its waterfront setting, the property sits at one of the highest elevations on Cape May Island and borders a protected state forest with scenic trails connecting to Higbee Beach and Sunset Beach. Offering a unique blend of waterfront living, acreage, privacy, and architectural design, this is one of the most distinctive homes on Cape May Island. Available fully furnished for a seamless, move-in-ready coastal retreat or luxury rental opportunity. Continue reading
MLS#
260870
Property Type
Single Family
Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
4 Full
Year Built
2023
Square Feet
4,584 sq. ft
Price per Sq. Ft.
$687.17
Stories
2.0
Sewer
Septic

Receive an email as soon as the price changes

Receive an email

as soon as the price changes
Get Price Alerts
price alerts icon

Get Price Alerts

Don't miss your chance. Receive an email as soon as the price changes.

Notify Me

Get email alerts when
a home price changes

Sign up
view of kitchen

Walk Score measures the walkability of any address, Transit Score measures access to public transit on a scale of 1-100.

Source: Walk Score®
scales icon

How much home can I afford?

Kickstart your home search journey with our online Pre-Approval.

Get Started
megaphone icon

See How Much You Could Save

Thinking about buying or selling? Talk to one of our Mortgage Professionals today to see how much you could save on your next home. Call us at 833-981-2030.

Let's Talk
Listing Courtesy of: Michael A Gleeson - Coldwell Banker Sol Needles Real Estate
Andrea D. Conner, License  1758875, Xome Inc., License 2326449, [email protected], 844-400-XOME (9663), 750 Highway 121 Bypass, Suite 100, Lewisville, Texas 75067
The information being provided is for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Copyright 2026 Cape May MLS. All Rights Reserved.
This content last refreshed on 4/8/2026 3:00 PM. Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available.
Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed.
save icon Save
save icon Save
share icon Share
checkmark icon Get Pre-Approved