Listing Courtesy of: 917-670-1900 - Karen Goodell - ERA Team VP Real Estate
716-413-0200
$399,750
Calculate Payment
Calculate Payment
3969 ROUTE 394 MAYVILLE, NY 14757
Single Family
Residence
4
Beds
3
Baths
...
Bed/Bath
2,224
Sq. Ft.
Property Activity
Time on Site
days
Days on Market
Views
Saves
Step into a home unlike any other! This former church has been thoughtfully transformed into a warm and inviting 4 bedroom 2.5 bath home featuring a cozy loft perfect for a hangout space or year round retreat. The moment you walk in, you’ll be welcomed by soaring ceilings, beautiful natural light, ...and preserved architectural details—including several decorative, church-style windows that add a beautiful touch of character and history. The expansive great room serves as the heart of the home, combining the living, dining, and kitchen areas into one open, airy space ideal for gatherings. All 4 bedrooms offer comfortable space and flexibility, making this home suitable for a variety of needs—whether full-time living or vacationing. Upstairs, the loft adds even more versatility—a perfect spot for a reading nook, gaming space or office. Please note, about 300 sq. feet in this area is in addition to the approximate 2300 sq. feet listed. Originally built in 1858 and decommissioned after 165 years, this former church has been carefully rebuilt and updated. Significant improvements include reinforced floor joists, new flooring, new heating and electrical systems, a new well, and a new septic holding tank (public sewer available in 2026). Additional updates include all-new siding, insulation, and 10 new windows. The home features a custom kitchen with stainless steel appliances, a large island, and solid surface countertops. The 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and ample closet space throughout were thoughtfully created from the former classrooms. Located at the attractive rear entrance, the home features a new laundry area and mechanical closet, with plenty of space for storage. The rear area of the property offers plenty of room for parking, the potential for a garage, and a relaxing rear terrace. Located just two miles from Chautauqua Institution, close to Chautauqua Lake, and near popular snowmobile trail systems, this property offers the perfect blend of historic charm, modern comfort, and access to year-round recreation—from arts and culture to boating, fishing, and winter sports If you're looking for character, space, and a home that truly stands out—this is it.
Continue reading
MLS#
R1653014
Property Type
Single Family
Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
2 Full/1 Half
Year Built
1858
Square Feet
2,224
sq. ft
Lot Size
0.36
Receive an email as soon as the price changes
Receive an email
as soon as the price changes
Get Price Alerts
Don't miss your chance. Receive an email as soon as the price changes.
Get email alerts when
a home price changes
Sign up
Walk Score measures the walkability of any address, Transit Score measures access to public transit on a scale of 1-100.
Source: Walk Score®
How much home can I afford?
Kickstart your home search journey with our online Pre-Approval.
Nearby Homes For Sale
Just Listed
And
Homes Available
In
See How Much You Could Save
Thinking about buying or selling? Talk to one of our Mortgage Professionals today to see how much you could save on your next home. Call us at 833-981-2030.