Experience true lake living on highly sought-after Witmer Lake, part of the Indian Lakes Chain (Witmer, Westler, Dallas, Hackenburg & Messick). This fully updated 4-bedroom, 2-bath lake home offers 100 feet of channel frontage, direct boat access, and a rare double lot—ideal for enjoying the upcoming lake season. Nearly every interior feature has been refreshed, including new flooring, trim, NEWER windows throughout, doors, fixtures, shiplap accents, fresh interior paint, and remodeled bathrooms. The main-level laundry adds convenience, while the upstairs private guest suite—complete with a kitchenette, living area, bedroom, and full bath—creates excellent flexibility for guests or potential rental income. Step outside to a large patio, attached 2-car garage, and plenty of outdoor space for entertaining, fishing, or relaxing by the water. With direct access to both ski lakes and fishing lakes, this home delivers the full Northern Indiana lake lifestyle. Purchase now and be moved in before spring and summer, ready to enjoy boating, lake days, and evenings on the water from day one. Whether you’re looking for a move-in-ready lake home, a seasonal getaway, or a versatile waterfront investment, this Witmer Lake property offers updates, space, and an unbeatable location!
3 bedroom 1 bath home updated bath, flooring ,freshly painted nice yard and detached 2 car garage with access from easement out back
NEW PRICE A cute 2 cozy bedroom 1 bath home with lots of potential on the channel between Messick Lake and HackenBurg Lake. Sale will include row boat and Bass boat. Comes with all the appliances. 2 Car garage with extra room to store that motorcycle or lawn equipment. with extra space below that can be used to store your lake gear or jet ski. A sun room and nice sized yard offers a perfect space to host friends and family for all your summer activities. Motivated Sellers
Welcome to this beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 1-bath seasonal home offering affordable lake access in peaceful Wolcottville, Indiana! Seconds away from Hackenburg Lake part of the Indian Lake chain. This move-in ready retreat features modern updates throughout, including newer windows, LG mini-split heating and cooling units, and stylish finishes for year-round comfort. Inside, enjoy a bright, open layout with tasteful décor—sold fully furnished and turnkey. Step outside to a quiet, non-ski lake known for its serene atmosphere and excellent fishing. Easy access to the water makes this one of the most affordable ways to enjoy lake life in Northern Indiana. Close to ski lakes & boat dock and a boat lift included in the sale! Perfect for weekend getaways or seasonal living, this well-maintained property combines convenience, value, and tranquility in one package. Don’t miss this opportunity to own a modern, updated lake-access home at an unbeatable price!
Spectacular A Frame style home ON THE WATER. Big Long Lake in Wolcottville IN. Detached Garage, Lake Front Home on Lot 174. East Side of the Lake. Awesome View across the Lake. Large Deck, with Covered and Screened Gazebo Area. Cozy Interior with Fireplace and LOTS of Glass for your view of Water and Fun. Detached 2 car Garage. Large Deck overlooking the Lake. First floor Master, GasLog burning Fireplace. Trees in the front for shade. Don't miss out of winter nesting and next year ON THE WATER. This home has been priced to sell immediately.
Looking for a home with a story to tell? Welcome to 115 E. Wolcott Street in Wolcottville, where 19th-century history meets 21st-century comfort. This one-of-a-kind timber-frame home was originally built around 1844 by one of Elkhart County’s earliest Amish settlers. Nearly 180 years later, the entire frame was carefully deconstructed in 2023 and given new life on a brand-new foundation by the renowned Levi Wickey of L&M Reclaiming. The result? A home that looks like it’s stepped out of history but lives like it was built yesterday. Step inside and you’re greeted by hand-treated, exposed timber beams and reclaimed wood paneling set exactly as it was in the original home—horizontal on exterior walls, vertical on interior walls. Narrow red oak floors, salvaged and re-milled from the original house, shine beneath your feet and pair beautifully with antique doors and maple stair treads. The distressed alder cabinetry in the kitchen, made by Clear Waters Cabinetry, is warm and inviting, complemented by custom countertops from Countertops Plus. On a chilly evening, you can cozy up by the Jotul wood-burning stove, which anchors the main living space with a rustic yet refined glow. Every detail blends heritage with modern ease. The main-floor bath features a corner shower for convenience, while the upstairs bath boasts a luxurious Japanese soaking tub, perfect for unwinding. A charming primitive corner cabinet just outside the main bath offers a nod to simpler times with a practical twist. Behind the historic beauty is a solid new build. You’ll find thermally modified southern yellow pine siding from Arbor Wood Co., a new metal roof by Troyer Roofing & Remodeling with seamless gutters, energy-efficient Sunrise windows, and 1-inch closed-cell foam plus R-21 fiberglass insulation, topped with 16 inches of cellulose in the attic. The home runs on an electric HVAC system with upstairs mini-splits, and all plumbing and electrical were completed new by AJ’s Plumbing & Electric. The 12-inch concrete foundation walls were specially poured to cradle the original 12-inch sill beams and provide a 9-foot-tall basement ceiling with an exterior cellar entry by Flying Eagle Concrete. Add in reclaimed red oak flooring, a Berber-carpeted den, porcelain-tiled baths, and you have a home that’s as warm and welcoming as it is historic and efficient. This is more than a place to live, it’s a chance to own a living piece of Indiana history, beautifully rebuilt for today’s lifestyle.
Channel front home at Witmer Lake with a concrete sea wall. Home has 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, enclosed porch and deck. Included in sale is a shed, boat lift and cover, dock, deck furniture, electric stove, refrigerator, microwave and dishwasher. Laundry hook-up in entry behind cabinet.
Who says lake season ends in September? This turn-key, fully furnished channel-side home keeps the lake life going all year long. Whether you’re sipping coffee by the water in the quiet off-season or ready to launch the jet ski the minute the ice melts, this property is ready when you are! The home offers three bedrooms, two full baths, and an open, inviting layout that’s easy to enjoy in every season. A reverse-osmosis water system, a 4 well installed about three years ago, and a jet-ski ramp with pier add everyday practicality to the charm. Step out onto the deck with gazebo and soak in the peaceful channel views—no crowds, no noise, just calm. Buying in the off-season means less competition, better value, and time to make it your own before spring arrives. With a recent $30,000 price improvement, this one delivers both instant equity and a lifestyle that lasts all year long.
Cozy Lake Retreat with 278 feet of Channel Frontage on Big Long Lake! Discover the charm of lakeside living in this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home tucked along the peaceful channel of beautiful Bid Long Lake. With an incredible 278 feet of waterfront, you'll have plenty of room for docks, boats, and quiet mornings on the water. Inside, enjoy an inviting open layout filled with natural light, perfect for relaxing after a day on the lake. A spacious kitchen opens to the living and dining area, creating that comfortable gather together feel that makes this the perfect weekend escape or year-round home. Step outside to the deck and take in the serene channel views - ideal for morning coffee or sunset gatherings. There's room to expand, entertain, and soak up the laid - back lake life. Big Long Lake is an all - sports, clean, and spring-fed lake, loved for its peaceful energy and friendly community. Whether you're looking for a quiet getaway, a summer retreat, or an affordable way to get on the water, this property delivers the best of Big Long- space, privacy and simplicity.
Lakefront home on Westler Lake! Part of the Indiana Chain of lakes! Nice gradual sandy beach! Enjoy the lake from the deck or relax in the enclosed porch! This cute 2 bedroom has provided the current owners with wonderful memories over the last several years! Now it is time to pass it on to the next owners to make memories of their own! If you enjoy boating, swimming or fishing - this chain of lakes has it all! All appliances are included in this turnkey package! Pack your bags and grab your swimsuit and start enjoying lake life! 2 sheds are included for all those must have lake toys! There is even a back lot for additional parking or a place to build your new garage!
The name of the lake says it all! PRETTY LAKE! You don't want to miss the opportunity to own a lake home on one of the most pristine fishing lakes in LaGrange County. This home is nestled on a large, wooded lot and offers an oversized 2 car garage with an updated roof in the last 4 years. There is an extra bonus room off the back of the garage that is great for storage or a playroom. As soon as you step into the home the first thing you will notice is the beautiful panoramic view of the lake from the Family Room. This view is beautiful with every season of the year. The home features 2 bedrooms plus a den that could be used as a bedroom plus 2 full baths with one of the baths having a stand-up shower and washer and dryer. Summer evenings are a perfect time to sit on the deck and read your favorite book and get to know your lake neighbors as they walk by. Partial basement with newer furnace and is great storage for all the lake toys This home has an easement to the lake with pier access across the road and it is just a hop, skip and jump away. Pretty Lake association offers many fun activities thru the year, and the Club House is just around the corner and up the hill. Move in just in time to still enjoy lake living. Home is being sold in AS IS condition.
Albert Wright Page, License RB14038157, Xome Inc., License RC51300094, [email protected], 844-400-XOME (9663), 4471 North Billman Estates, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Information is provided exclusively for consumers personal, non - commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Copyright 2026, Southern Indiana Realtors Association. All rights reserved.
Wolcottville is located in Indiana. Wolcottville, Indiana has a population of 1,114. Wolcottville is less family-centric than the surrounding county with 24.15% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 34.8%.
The median household income in Wolcottville, Indiana is $55,625. The median household income for the surrounding county is $63,292 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Wolcottville is 32.7 years.
The average high temperature in July is 83.1 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 15.7 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 37.6 inches per year, with 29.4 inches of snow per year.
