This rare 23.5-acre parcel overlooking Otisco Lake offers approximately 600 feet of private waterfrontage and an exceptional blend of seclusion, scenic beauty, and long-term value. Tucked away along picturesque Willowdale Road in the Finger Lakes Town of Spafford, the property is set within one of the most desirable rural corridors near the Skaneateles and Otisco Lake regions, providing privacy without sacrificing accessibility. Expansive acreage and direct lakefrontage make it well-suited for a range of residential uses. Large residential parcels of this size are increasingly scarce, enhancing the property’s appeal and long-term value. Market data and public valuation records support a well-aligned and defensible pricing position, with automated valuation models generally indicating values centered in the mid $300,000s, offering buyers and investors confidence in both current value and future potential Redfin - (Redfin - $354k/ HouseCanary - $365k / ATTOM - $330k / CoreLogic- $340k /ClearCapital - $335k) The Town Assessor has established a fair market value of $343,584, further reinforcing the property’s strong market standing. This is an excellent opportunity to secure significant land holdings in a market where large residential parcels are increasingly scarce.
Building lot on just under three acres in the Marcellus School district. Come build your dream home.
Rare opportunity presents itself—37.38 acres of breathtaking land overlooking Skaneateles Lake. This spectacular property offers a serene setting complete with a picturesque pond, all within walking distance to Skaneateles Country Club and the Village. Enjoy truly unparalleled views in a setting that combines privacy with convenience. Public water has been approved for Andrews Road and coming soon, adding even more value and potential. Opportunities like this are exceptionally rare—especially this close to the Village—making it ideal for a private estate, development, or investment. A one-of-a-kind offering with endless possibilities.
"Village Meadow" is now available! An exceptional opportunity to begin building your dream home in this thoughtfully designed eight-lot subdivision. Ideally located within walking distance to the village center and local schools, Village Meadow offers the perfect blend of convenience, charm, and community. Bring your vision to life with a fully custom home crafted by Mark Anthony Homes in collaboration with Space Architecture. Every detail of this new subdivision has been carefully planned to create a beautiful and cohesive setting for modern village living. Design. Build. Dream. Village Meadow is ready to welcome you home.
Legacy Lakefront Opportunity – 226’ of Skaneateles Waterfront Rarely does a 3+ acre waterfront parcel with 226 feet of pristine Skaneateles Lake frontage become available just minutes from the village center. The existing cottage sits at the water’s edge — an irreplaceable setting — offering sweeping lake views toward downtown and unforgettable sunsets from the lakeside deck. Included in the sale are approved septic and building plans for a 4-bedroom residence, along with approval for a permanent dock, creating a seamless path to building your custom lakefront estate while enjoying the property immediately. Private, expansive, and positioned in one of the Finger Lakes’ most coveted locations, this is a rare opportunity to secure significant frontage, usable acreage, and future building potential on Skaneateles Lake.
Part of the renowned Shore Elms Estate, this exceptional lakefront parcel on the west side of Skaneateles Lake offers an unparalleled opportunity to build along one of the most coveted shorelines in the Finger Lakes. Encompassing approximately 2.05 acres with 205 feet of private, level frontage, the property combines accessibility, serenity, and architectural potential in one of the region’s most prestigious settings. A gentle slope to the water provides walk-in lake access, while a grandfathered 17’ x 11’ cabana structure rests at the shoreline. Zoned for single-family residential use, the parcel can accommodate a custom home of approximately 5,000–6,000 sq. ft., subject to standard coverage and setback requirements. Located just 5.5 miles from the Village of Skaneateles, it offers rare privacy with proximity to village amenities. This parcel is being marketed and shown independently; however, it will not be sold, conveyed, or closed prior to the successful closing of the primary residence at 1870 West Lake Road. The seller reserves the right to sell both properties together as a single estate offering at any time prior to a separate sale of the lot. An extraordinary chance to acquire a significant piece of the Shore Elms legacy on one of the cleanest and most celebrated lakes in the world.
Looking to Build Your Dream Home in the Skaneateles School District? This 1.46 -acre lot offers a rare opportunity to create your ideal home overlooking Skaneateles Lake. Nestled in the award-winning Skaneateles School District, this lot is ready for construction—just bring your vision. Whether you're looking for a peaceful year-round residence or a seasonal retreat, this picturesque setting offers the perfect canvas. Don’t miss your chance to own a slice of the Finger Lakes in one of Central New York’s most sought-after communities.
Property for sale is part of tax map listed above. Property needs to be subdivided by buyer at buyer's expense. House and barn not occupied and both need extensive rehab. Please do not attempt to enter. Well and septic on site, condition unknown. New electric to pole. Sold "AS IS" Property for sale will be: Approximately 2 Acres on the East side of Route 41A, to include the barn, not including road to lake and approximately 1 acre on West side of Route 41A to include house, well, septic, electric and lawn area. The remaining property has crops and is not included. Property is marked along 41A. Access road to lake negotiable. Map will be uploaded once complete on approximate acres being sold. Taxes are based on total acreage, taxes will be adjusted once subdivided.
Breathtaking lake views, discover the perfect canvas for your family compound on this picturesque 13-acre lot, containing two lots ready for building your dream estate, where nature's beauty meets endless possibilities. Nestled amidst rolling hills and framed by majestic trees, this idyllic property is adorned with colorful wildflowers, offering a serene backdrop for your future home. Adjacent 17 acre West Lake Farm estate is also for sale.
Just under twelve acre building lot for sale in a desirable area. All located in the Skaneateles School District only three miles from the village. Come build your custom dream home.
Five acre building lot for sale in a desirable area. All located in the Skaneateles School District only three miles from the village. Come build your custom dream home.

Skaneateles is located in New York. Skaneateles, New York has a population of 7,155. Skaneateles is more family-centric than the surrounding county with 28.53% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 26.38%.
The median household income in Skaneateles, New York is $90,762. The median household income for the surrounding county is $66,012 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Skaneateles is 51.1 years.
The average high temperature in July is 81.3 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 15.9 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 41.2 inches per year, with 89.5 inches of snow per year.