Discover a different approach to rental property ownership in Butler's desirable Hospital District! This duplex features two one-bedroom, one-bath apartments, each serving a distinct rental market. The first-floor apartment has been home to the same tenant for over a decade, currently generating $657 monthly (increasing to $757 01/01/2027), while the fully furnished second-floor apartment commands $1,300 monthly and boasts an impressive 96% occupancy rate over the past two years! Traveling healthcare professionals, utility and energy workers, and individuals transitioning between homes are just a few of the renters this flexible medium-term housing model has attracted. Both apartments include appliances, while the furnished unit conveys complete with furniture, linens, kitchenware, and household essentials. Four off-street parking spaces, a spacious yard, and a storage shed add everyday convenience. This property offers an established alternative to traditional duplex investing. The seller is willing to share their rental business model, rental history, and operating expenses with qualified buyers. Explore the possibilities of this distinctive Butler investment property and schedule your showing today!
A true Butler County gem, this enchanting 1800s farmhouse is an unofficial local landmark. This beautiful home was once part of a much larger farm and equestrian tract and even once home to the Skyway Drive-In Movie Theater. Charming details at every turn, creating a setting that feels both timeless and welcoming. Sitting on a meticulously maintained 0.77 acre lot, the 3 bedroom, 2 bath home is spacious and endearing. The main level offers a large eat-in kitchen with attached laundry, a formal living room, office or bedroom, full bathroom and a cozy sunroom. Upstairs are 3 additional bedrooms, full bath and walk-up attic. The home is well complemented by a picturesque detached two-car garage with porch, along with an income-producing 1 bed, 1 bath guest house with it's own 2 stall garage. Located within a commercial district yet surrounded by residential homes, this unique property offers exceptional flexibility. Continue to enjoy it as a private residence, explore permitted commercial uses, or create the perfect live-work opportunity. Currently used as a primary residence with rental income, the property also features a Governor’s driveway with ample off-street parking. Preserve the character and history of this remarkable home and last bit of the Stirling Farm —or begin an entirely new chapter.
Discover an extraordinary opportunity in the Downtown Butler Historical District, where historic architecture blends effortlessly with modern luxury and income-producing versatility. This distinguished mixed-use property enjoys a prime corner location just off Main Street, offering exceptional visibility, walkability, and the rare privilege of private off-street parking for both commercial patrons and overnight guests. The main level features a fully leased commercial space, supported by newer mechanicals, updated electric, and a newer roof—a turnkey foundation for long-term stability. With separate utilities for the commercial and residential levels, the property delivers optimal efficiency and clean financial separation for investors. Ascending to the second floor, guests are welcomed into a luxury Airbnb suite that has been meticulously reimagined with contemporary elegance. A designer kitchen showcases quartz countertops, white cabinetry, and refined finishes that elevate every stay. Two spacious bedrooms, a generous living room, and a spa-inspired bath featuring a large dual-showerhead walk-in shower create an unforgettable boutique experience. A sprinkler system, added during renovation, enhances safety and peace of mind. The third floor serves as the owner’s private quarters, offering abundant potential for customization, expansion, or additional rental income—an adaptable space ready to match your vision. Outside, a charming courtyard sanctuary provides a serene retreat for guests, a rare luxury in an urban setting and a defining feature of this exceptional property. With its blend of historic charm, modern upgrades, separate utilities, multiple revenue streams, and premium finishes, this Downtown Butler gem stands as a premier investment for those seeking elegance, stability, and long-term growth in one of the region’s most iconic districts.
**EXCELLENT INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY!** Add this updated, well-maintained duplex in the City of Butler to your investment portfolio! Featuring two separate units, this property offers excellent rental income potential with several key improvements already completed. The first-floor unit includes 1 bedroom, 1 full bath, a living room, dining room, kitchen, and basement access with laundry and storage. Updates include an updated kitchen (2024), fresh paint (2024), a new electric hot water tank (2024), and a new furnace (2024). The second-floor unit features a separate rear entrance, 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, a living room, eat-in kitchen, and attic storage. Improvements include a new gas-fired furnace (2024), fresh paint (2023), new washer and dryer lines (2023), updated lighting, and replacement landing flooring (2025). Both units have their own gas-fired furnaces, and a two-car garage adds valuable parking and storage. Tenants pay all utilities except garbage, offering an attractive setup for investors. Don’t miss this opportunity to own an income-producing property with numerous updates already completed!
Don't miss this opportunity to add a fully occupied duplex with multiple income streams to your investment portfolio. This two-unit property features a double lot and offers two 2-bedroom, 1-bath units, each featuring a spacious living area and kitchen, along with a detached 5-stall garage that is rented separately for additional income. The home's historic character, generous layout and multiple income-producing components make this an appealing opportunity for an investor looking to expand an existing portfolio. With tenants already in place and additional rental income from the garage, this property offers an established income-producing setup from day one.
Nearly 24 acres just off Bonniebrook offering a truly unique mix of residential, commercial, recreational, and investment potential. The former restaurant and bar area features a spacious outdoor patio overlooking several ponds, portions of the former golf course, and nearby Rails to Trails—creating a setting that feels private, scenic, and full of possibility. At the top of the property sits a newer 2-bedroom, 2-bath home with an attached 2-stall garage, offering comfortable living with beautiful views across the acreage. The property also includes a butcher shop with multiple walk-in coolers and freezer space, currently rented, providing an existing income-producing component. In addition, there is a large 1-bedroom, 1-bath apartment with its own 2-stall garage, also rented; along with a pavilion and lean-to that add even more usable space. With nearly 24 acres to work with, this property opens the door to countless possibilities. A brewery, winery, event venue, restaurant, retreat, recreational destination, specialty business, investment property, or a combination of uses could all make sense here. The ponds, open land, former golf course setting, trail access, multiple buildings, and existing infrastructure create a property that would be difficult to duplicate. Whether you're looking for a business opportunity, income-producing property, private compound, or a place to bring a completely new vision to life, this one deserves to be seen in person.
NVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY WITH MULTIPLE INCOME-PRODUCING POSSIBILITIES! Bring your vision to this unique Butler Township property featuring a classic 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath Cape Cod ready to be renovated and restored to its original charm and character. Whether your goal is to create a comfortable primary residence or transform the home into a rental property, this property offers plenty of opportunity to build value. Adding to the investment potential are a two-stall detached garage and two mobile homes, providing the possibility for additional rental income and multiple uses. With several existing improvements already in place, this property offers an appealing opportunity for an investor looking to expand a portfolio or a buyer seeking a property with future income potential. Situated on approximately .95 acres, the property provides a generous setting while remaining conveniently located near major transportation corridors. Enjoy easy access to schools, shopping, restaurants, and everyday amenities, making this a convenient location for residents and tenants alike. Properties offering this combination of acreage, multiple structures, and income potential don't come along every day. Whether you're looking to renovate, rent, restore, or create your own vision, this property is ready for its next chapter.
Turnkey investment opportunity! Add this income-producing property to your portfolio with confidence. This 3 bedroom 3 full bathroom home comes with reliable long term tenants, already in place...providing immediate rental income from day one! Featuring a spacious layout, an updated deck, off street parking in a desirable location with strong investment potential. This is a hassle free opportunity for both seasoned and first time investors. Start generating returns the moment you close! Close to downtown amenities and the Hospital.
This triplex is a turnkey investment offering immediate cash flow. Whether you're a seasoned investor or just starting out, this triplex is a profitable addition to any real estate portfolio. Don't miss out on this income generating property!
Unique opportunity. Hobbyists' dream or great investment with a great return. 10 garages to use for personal projects or use some and rent some. Added bonus: beautiful Victorian home that needs some loving attention. This home has wonderful space, from the large living and dining room, eat in kitchen, to bonus room on first floor. Staircase with wooden balustrade and banister leads to second floor. Full bathroom. Den, and 3 bedrooms. Third floor offers so much, additional bedroom, 2 offices, game room, family room, and storage. Restore home for yourself or to rent along with the garages. Money making property would make great investment. Property is an estate and being sold as is.
This duplex is a turnkey opportunity already rented and ready for its new owner to take over. Up and down duplex. First floor is a two bedroom, and second and third floor is a four bedroom rental. Month to month leases. Two furnaces, one newer furnace, one around 12 years old. One car detached garage. Utilities are separate. This rental has long term tenants with excellent payment history and would like to stay.
Up/Down Duplex; Both Apartments are Rented; New Roof - August 2026; All Separate Utilities; Off-street Parking for 2 Cars; Central Air - Both Units; Two Private Porches with Roofs; Washer/Dryer Hook-ups in Each Apartment; Anderson Thermopane Windows; Many Updates. Turn-key Duplex.
Welcome to an exceptional opportunity to own a brand new duplex style patio home that offers flexibility, quality construction, and a lifestyle rarely found in today’s market. Ideal for an investor, owner occupant, or multi generational living, this property allows you to live in one residence while renting the other, or provide a beautifully finished home for a family member next door. Located on a private road in Penn Township. Each home offers three bedrooms and two baths with a thoughtfully designed layout that balances comfort and functionality. A large entry welcomes you into a bright, open living floorplan illuminated by abundant natural light. Vaulted ceilings and wide plank white oak flooring enhance the sense of space, while a gas fireplace anchors the living area with warmth and timeless appeal. The kitchens are both functional and elegant, equipped with LG stainless steel appliances, quartz surfaces, ample cabinetry, and a walk in pantry for added storage. The dining area flows seamlessly into the living space and opens through a sliding door to the covered patio and private rear yard, creating an effortless indoor outdoor connection that is perfect for everyday living or entertaining. Each primary suite presents a comfortable retreat, complete with a spacious walk in closet and a well appointed bath featuring additional storage. Two additional bedrooms and a full bath are strategically placed away from the primary suite, offering privacy for guests, family members, or tenants. Laundry areas are conveniently tucked behind farmhouse style doors and include built in storage, keeping daily routines organized and out of sight. Outdoor living is equally impressive. Covered patios feature cedar lined ceilings, integrated lighting, and ceiling fans, providing a comfortable space to relax in every season. Two car garages, beautifully finished concrete driveways, and attractive walkways complete the exterior, all set on approximately one and a half acres of level land that offers space, privacy, and future flexibility. Conveniently located in Penn Township just off Route 8, this property is close to local farms, markets, and restaurants, and only minutes from Butler Regional Airport. The location combines a peaceful setting with everyday convenience and is served by the highly regarded Knoch School District. Brand new construction, low maintenance living, and exceptional versatility make this property a compelling choice for a wide range of buyers. Whether you are seeking an income producing opportunity, a flexible living arrangement, or a beautifully built home, this offering delivers on every level.
Well-maintained 3-story building (currently used as a music and art studio) is ideal for finished office space, studio use, training rooms, insurance, and more. Conveniently located just off Main Street, the building includes 2 off-street parking spaces, ample street parking, and 2 public parking lots nearby. This potential multi-unit building features separate utility meters and 2 separate entrances: a street-level entrance leading into a waiting/entry area with access to the main level unit, and a side entrance providing access to the 2nd unit (2nd + 3rd floor). Rooms include: Main Level- Front + side entrance, 1 lobby area, 1 open office/admin space, 3 private offices, 1 utility room w/ sink, & 1 Restroom with toilet/sink. 2nd Level- 2 larger private offices, 1 smaller office, & 1 Restroom with toilet/sink. 3rd Level- 1 large gathering space & 1 Restroom with toilet/sink. Basement- 1 entrance area, 1 private finished room, 1 storage room, & 1 large utility room space.
320 W. Birch St. is a fully occupied duplex located in Butler. The property is 100% occupied and consistently leased, generating $5,025.00 in quarterly rental income, or $20,100.00 annually. With a strong and reliable income stream, the duplex produces an approximate Net Operating Income (NOI) of $17,541.40 per year. Its central location and stable tenancy make this a solid investment opportunity with dependable cash flow.
122 Quarry is a fully occupied triplex located in Butler. The property is 100% occupied and consistently leased, generating $7,650.00 in quarterly rental income, or $30,600.00 annually. With a strong and reliable income stream, the triplex produces an approximate Net Operating Income (NOI) of $27,107.42 per year. Its central location and stable tenancy make this a solid investment opportunity with dependable cash flow.
320 W. Birch St. is a fully occupied duplex located in Butler. The property is 100% occupied and consistently leased, generating $4800.00 in quarterly rental income, or $19,200.00 annually. With a strong and reliable income stream, the duplex produces an approximate Net Operating Income (NOI) of $16,957.46 per year. Its central location and stable tenancy make this a solid investment opportunity with dependable cash flow.
328 W. Cunningham St. is a fully occupied duplex located in the heart of Butler. The property is 100% occupied and consistently leased, generating $5,100.00 in monthly rental income, or $20,400.00 annually. With a strong and reliable income stream, the duplex produces an approximate Net Operating Income (NOI) of $17,114.53 per year. Its central location and stable tenancy make this a solid investment opportunity with dependable cash flow.
346 Mercer St. is a fully occupied triplex located in Butler. The property is 100% occupied and consistently leased, generating $6,900 in quarterly rental income, or $27,600.00 annually. With a strong and reliable income stream, the triplex produces an approximate Net Operating Income (NOI) of $24,053.04 per year. Its central location and stable tenancy make this a solid investment opportunity with dependable cash flow.
326 W. Cunningham St. is a fully occupied duplex located in Butler. The property is 100% occupied and consistently leased, generating $3,600 in quarterly rental income, or $14,400.00 annually. With a strong and reliable income stream, the duplex produces an approximate Net Operating Income (NOI) of $11,750.77 per year. Its central location and stable tenancy make this a solid investment opportunity with dependable cash flow.
410 E Locust. is a fully occupied duplex located in Butler. The property is 100% occupied and consistently leased, generating $5,400.00 in quarterly rental income, or $21,600.00 annually. With a strong and reliable income stream, the duplex produces an approximate Net Operating Income (NOI) of $18,471.30 per year. Its central location and stable tenancy make this a solid investment opportunity with dependable cash flow.
107 Sumner Ave. is a fully occupied duplex located in Butler. The property is 100% occupied and consistently leased, generating $5,400 in quarterly rental income, or $21,600.00 annually. With a strong and reliable income stream, the duplex produces an approximate Net Operating Income (NOI) of $19,081.29 per year. Its central location and stable tenancy make this a solid investment opportunity with dependable cash flow.
210 Mercer St. is a fully occupied duplex located in Butler. The property is 100% occupied and consistently leased, generating $4,650.00 in quarterly rental income, or $18,600.00 annually. With a strong and reliable income stream, the duplex produces an approximate Net Operating Income (NOI) of $15,548.36 per year. Its central location and stable tenancy make this a solid investment opportunity with dependable cash flow.
404 E. Locust St. is a four-unit (quad) property in Butler that has been gutted to the studs and is ready for a rebuild. Following a prior fire, the structure now offers new owners a clean slate to redesign and finish the property to their vision, creating a high-quality rental asset. With other rental properties in the surrounding area proving to be profitable and income-generating, this quad presents a strong value-add opportunity. In its current state, the property has significant upside potential for investors willing to complete the renovation and bring it back as a desirable, cash-flowing rental in the Butler market.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the IDX Program of the West Penn MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Copyright 2026 West Penn Multi-List™. All rights reserved.
Butler is located in Pennsylvania. Butler, Pennsylvania has a population of 13,452. Butler is less family-centric than the surrounding county with 23.12% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 31.96%.
The median household income in Butler, Pennsylvania is $36,570. The median household income for the surrounding county is $77,065 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Butler is 39.4 years.
The average high temperature in July is 82 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 17.9 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 42.6 inches per year, with 38.8 inches of snow per year.