The median home value in Old Lyme, CT is $465,000.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $227,800.
The national median home value is $219,700.
The average price of homes sold in Old Lyme, CT is $465,000.
Approximately 40.78% of Old Lyme homes are owned,
compared to 10% rented, while
49.22% are vacant.
Old Lyme real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Old Lyme real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Rare opportunity to own a year-round property in Point O' Woods beach just in time for the summer season! Enjoy expansive water views from the deck or open living space. Easily entertain in the kitchen with double ovens and modern features, or the vast living room/dining room with cathedral ceilings and large picture windows across the front of the home with views of the Niantic Bay. Hardwood floors are throughout the home and all three bathrooms have been newly renovated. Four fireplaces lend heat and ambiance for chilly nights and a state of the art generator lends of peace of mind during storms. Massive primary suite includes Jack and Jill bathroom, vanity, fireplace, primary closet as well as a cedar closet. A spiral staircase leads to a loft with a bar where you can enjoy sunrise views from the highest point in POW! Soothing sounds of a babbling brook are the perfect backdrop for the detached office space. You'll love the generous sized yard, shed and parking for 8 cars. The Point O' Woods Association offers a private beach, boat basin, pavilion, boardwalk, tennis courts, basketball courts, bocci courts and endless summer recreational activities. The community is golf cart friendly. Easy access off I-95 and close to Amtrak to Boston and New York as well as the Metro North commuter Rail to New York. This one will not last!!
Located just north of Old Lyme village, this shingle ranch sits well back, framed by century old stone walls. Enter through the three-season porch with slate floor. Three steps lead to an expansive great room with wood burning fireplace flanked by built-in bookcases. Two large closets sit opposite providing storage space and a laundry area. French doors open to the kitchen with quartz tops, breakfast bar and new stainless appliances. This opens nicely to the dining room. Find three bedrooms and two full baths including the primary bedroom with ensuite bath and tile shower. The warm air furnace was installed June 2024 and the roof 2016. Outside find a gorgeous, level yard dotted with specimen trees and perennials flanking the drive. The oversized, two-car detached garage doubles as a perfect workshop! This home is located less than a mile north of Old Lyme center and convenient to dining, shopping, grocery and post office, 3 miles to Saybrook Station and 15 minutes to Groton, New London. Just lovely.
Enjoy the serenity of lakeside living with this charming cottage perched on the picturesque shores of Rogers Lake in Old Lyme. This idyllic retreat offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of waterfront paradise. The cottage exudes a warm, inviting atmosphere with its cozy living spaces that capture expansive views of the lake. Windows frame the natural beauty outside, while the open-concept design ensures you're never far from the water's edge, whether you're lounging in the living room or preparing meals in the kitchen. Step outside onto the deck, where you can bask in the sun, dine al fresco, or simply watch the sunset paint the sky over Rogers Lake. The property includes a private dock, perfect for boating, fishing, or swimming. The cottage's rustic charm is complemented by modern comforts, making it an ideal year-round escape or a seasonal getaway. Located in Old Lyme, this lakefront cottage offers a lifestyle of simplicity and joy. Whether you're seeking a family retreat, a peaceful sanctuary, or a place to entertain friends, this Rogers Lake gem is a unique find.
Bring your Waterfront Dreams! Beautiful Estuary Views from everywhere you look, and swaying marsh reeds that border the 25 acre Watch Rock Preserve. Check out this .85 Acre lot in the Heart of Old Lyme. Convenient to everything and just steps from Old Lyme Country Club. Along with your very own views, comes several neighborhood accesses to the waterfront for kayaking, boating, swimming, and fishing.
Welcome home to Old Lyme Shores. This 3 bedroom 1.5 bath ranch BEACH home is an amazing place to make everlasting memories. Walk right in and enjoy the updates. No expense has been spared. The beautiful kitchen with granite counters and stainless appliances is sure to please and its opens to a vaulted family room. Off of here you have a beautiful sunroom perfect to relax or have a home office. The primary bedroom offers a 1/2 bath and an additional two bedrooms offer amble space for guests to sleep. Outside you will find the most beautiful backyard oasis complete with an outdoor shower, kitchen and entertaining area. DO NOT MISS THIS OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE THIS HOME YOURS!
Introducing a remarkable property in beautiful Old Lyme! This recently renovated home boasts a stunning first-floor primary bedroom complete with an ensuite bathroom and the convenience of a washer and dryer. Imagine the luxury of having all your essentials on one level! Step outside onto the inviting exterior deck patio, which is absolutely perfect for enjoying the warm summer months. The property also features a picturesque pond, surrounded by ample land, providing a tranquil and serene atmosphere. As you make your way upstairs, you'll discover four additional spacious rooms, offering endless possibilities for bedrooms, guest rooms, or even a home office. There is also a second full bathroom, ensuring comfort and convenience for everyone in the household. But that's not all! This property offers an abundance of bonus room space, providing you with endless options. Whether you desire a dedicated living area, a formal dining room, a home office, or a cozy den, you'll have the flexibility to create the perfect space to suit your needs. Located in close proximity to beautiful beaches and reputable schools, this property offers the ideal combination of convenience and tranquility. Don't miss the opportunity to make this extraordinary property your new home!
Welcome home to your own private retreat! This charming cape features hardwood floors throughout, chef's kitchen featuring large center island with sink, granite countertops, WOLF gas range with griddle and two ovens, expansive cabinet storage, radiant floor heat, breakfast bar and French doors opening to an Ipe-wood deck overlooking a brook; perfect for entertaining. Also on first floor, a center chimney with new high efficiency wood stove insert, recessed lighting, comfortable living and dining rooms, large bedroom, full bath, and an additional room which can be used as an office or guest bedroom. On second floor, a spacious master bedroom with walk-in closet, another bedroom, and a full bath. The walk out basement provides plenty of storage. A separate building has a 4 bay garage with walk-up loft, room to store vehicles, boats/kayaks, and outdoor furniture. Paved second driveway can be used for RV or boat storage. Garden shed, updated electric and water filtration systems. Beautifully landscaped yard perfect for privacy, relaxing, bird watching while enjoying your morning cup of coffee. Convenient to Rogers Lake, Coffee's Country Market, hiking trails, beaches and highways. Your dream home is waiting for you! Come take a look!
This well-established restaurant offers a unique and captivating dining experience, situated amidst the picturesque beauty of expansive marsh views. Nestled in the heart of a charming shoreline town, where the Connecticut River meets Long Island Sound, the location adds a distinctive charm to the culinary venture. The surrounding area is a vibrant region with art galleries, shopping opportunities, and a lively beach community, drawing in additional patrons during the summer months. With a rich history spanning over 33 years, this restaurant has become a culinary favorite in the community. Boasting a spacious interior, it provides a variety of seating options. The large first-floor dining room immerses patrons in the natural beauty of marsh views. Ascending to the second floor, a dining loft space continues to offer breathtaking panoramic views of the marsh. Adding to its versatility, the restaurant features two private dining rooms. These private spaces offer a spacious setting for special gatherings, community events, and celebrations. The bar area is a focal point of socializing, with a full circular bar complemented by additional table seating. The business is being offered as a turn-key operation including furnishings, tables, chairs, barstools, glassware, stemware, dishes, plates, beverages and liquor. In addition, the sale includes the computer systems ensuring a seamless transition. A rare opportunity for an entrepreneur to step into an established business.
Build your dream home! Get exactly what you want. 4.21 acres of untouched land in a beautiful well established neighborhood with very good looking homes. Privately sited, close to everything.
Discover the opportunity to create your dream home in Old Lyme with this to-be-built farmhouse-style residence. Envision a blend of timeless design and modern amenities, all tailored to your personal taste and lifestyle. This custom-designed home promises to offer a spacious and open floor plan, perfect for both comfortable family living and elegant entertaining. The proposed design includes a welcoming wrap around porch that epitomizes the classic farmhouse aesthetic, inviting you into a world of rustic charm infused with contemporary elements. The main level is planned to feature a chefs kitchen and generous living area that connects to the dining space, ensuring a cohesive flow throughout the home. With three bedrooms envisioned, each will offer comfort, style, and privacy. The primary suite will offer a luxurious retreat, complete with a spa-like en-suite bathroom and a spacious walk-in closet. Located on a country road, come see all that Old Lyme has to offer. Builder is Dave Tetlow of Tetlow Homes!
50.22 acres surrounded by Connecticut State Land Trust. Private yet easy access off of Boston Post Rd. Subdivision was approved for 5 building lots. Residential subdivision has frontage off of Boston Post Rd.
Salisbury Place is a stunning, pristine property in the heart of Old Lyme village. Sited on over an acre of flat, professionally manicured and mature grounds, this home is move-in ready both inside and out. Suitable for an antique lover, one who desires character and grace, or someone looking for modern amenities, Salisbury Place delivers on all fronts. Much of this property has been recently updated and reconfigured to the highest standards. The kitchen was moved to create a modern space adjoining the wood-paneled family room, the bluestone patio, the newly formed mudroom and the garage. Now with an eat-in space, there is room for a large table overlooking the private and beautifully landscaped backyard. The dining room, with built-in bar and fireplace, gleams with light, sophistication and charm. The library features gorgeous detailed woodwork, a large bow window, and a spectacular marble fireplace. The primary suite encompasses a large, vaulted ceiling bathroom with a deep soaking tub and double sinks, a study with fireplace, plus two walk-in closets. Two additional bedrooms and bath round off the second floor. The third floor contains two bedrooms, a sitting room, and a full bath. The home also boasts an expansive, wood paneled multipurpose room over the post and beam garage. A Buderus boiler, a whole house generator, and a wood shingle roof are just some of the recent structural and mechanical updates to the home. This property is truly a perfect, elegant gem!
This is a rare opportunity to create a fabulous residence on a large parcel of land on Meetinghouse Lane, a lovely and quiet cul-de-sac road close to the Village of Old Lyme and within walking distance of the wonderful Old Lyme Country Club. This property can also be subdivided into two already approved building lots. Permitted subdivision mapping available and a wetlands crossing has been approved.
Flat, level .12 Acre lot centrally located in Old Lyme (across the street from the Miami Beach Association). Close to Beaches, Marinas, Casinos, Restaurants, and Area Attractions. 2 hours from NYC and Boston. Close to I-95 and Old Saybrook Train Station. Great opportunity.
Imagine a time when artists lived and loved on the CT shoreline nearly a century ago... When you arrive at this 6.75-acre estate set far back on Sill Lane with water frontage south and west, you'll be immersed in privacy and quiet. The unparalleled attention to detail relaxes-with the expansive lush green lawn, boxwoods, and roses. Walk into your graciously appointed home and enter the life of the Roaring '20s. Simplicity at its best. Special touches include arched doorways, French doors, and fir hardwood floors. The patio off the dining room-combined with the butler's pantry and kitchen with high cathedral ceiling-provides excellent flow for hosting lively dinner parties. The living room, set with a warm wood-burning fireplace, offers a magical setting for sharing ideas and limitless views of the flowing Lieutenant River. Pass into the sunroom and be one with nature-3 walls of glass, cathedral ceilings, and HVAC-your new favorite room. Just a slider away, you'll step out to the piece de resistance: the patio of life! You'll be immersed in nature and transported to a whimsical time, not lost in this idyllic backdrop. Unparallel birdwatching, a pair of Bald Eagles, garden area, and soccer field complete the experience. There's much more to this charming home. The current owner has updated the cedar shingle roof, HVAC, well pump, painting, landscaping, and Level II EV charging in the 2-car garage. Long Island Sound is just a few paddles down the River from the dock
Welcome to beautiful Old Lyme Shores! Town lists this as a 2 bedroom home, but there is a room behind the garage that can be used as Bedroom 3. This is perfect timing to get that seasonal beach getaway you always dreamed of. This truly turn-key property is all updated and ready for you to move right in, grab your beach bag and head down the street to the beach; come back and enjoy lazy afternoons in your sunporch doing that jigsaw puzzle and balmy summer evenings on your deck with friends. This is the beach life we all plan for. The beautifully updated kitchen has stainless appliances and quartz countertops with plenty of storage. Bathrooms are also updated. Company can spill over from the open dining area out to the deck with the remote-controlled awning to protect you from the sun or light showers. This home sits on a larger lot than is usually found in beach communities and offers plenty of privacy in back where you have the convenience of an enclosed outside shower. This one has it all!
This brand new construction Farm Style home has a thoughtful design offering a unique feature- an inviting second-level guest suite, perfect for hosting family and friends. Step inside to an open-concept layout connecting the living spaces, creating a welcoming atmosphere. The main level has a chefs kitchen with quartz countertops and Bosch appliances, an adjacent dining area and living room with propane fireplace ideal for gatherings and entertaining. The primary en-suite has tons of closet space with build-ins. There are 2 more bedrooms and an office space/flex space. The second level offers a very versatile space. Outside there is plenty of room for enjoyment and recreation, whether lounging on the front covered porch or the back deck. This beautiful home abuts the Lay-Allen Preserve. Come see all that Old Lyme has to offer.
GET AWAY FROM THE URBAN JUNGLE. Your own Private Retreat. Make this your Small private Estate, escape from Urban Life to a charming, small Connecticut town, convenient to beaches, marinas... Your own private, Nature Preserve...in an affordable, yet suburban Connecticut, country residence ... CONVIENT to EVERYTHING, NYC, HARTFORD, STAMFORD, BOSTON, TRAIN STATION. IT IS A UNIQUE CONTEMPORARY FEATURING EXPANSIVE FLOOR TO CEILING GLASS and CONCRETE WALLS, FULL CYPRESS WOOD INTERIOR INCLUDING CEILINGS, RADIANT STONE FLOORS, 2 AMAZING WOOD BURNING FIREPLACES, OVERSIZED 1ST FLOOR MASTER with FULL BATH, 4 BEDROOMS, 4 FULL BATHS, 400 AMP. ELECTRICAL, DETACHED-OVERSIZED GARAGE, IN-GROUND POOL. PEACEFUL VIEWS OF 5.10 ACRES OF WILDLIFE and PRIVACY. TRULY UNIQUE!
Charming beach community of Old Lyme, this ranch-style home offers a perfect blend of coastal living and modern comfort. Located in the sought-after Miami Beach association, this residence is a haven for those who appreciate the tranquility of a private beach setting. Step inside, and you'll discover a thoughtfully remodeled interior that seamlessly combines classic charm with contemporary design. The three bedrooms provide comfortable living spaces, each designed to maximize space and functionality. The full bathroom features modern fixtures and tasteful finishes, ensuring a relaxing retreat. The heart of this home is the custom kitchen adorned with stainless steel appliances and quartz countertops. The tile floors add a touch of elegance. The outdoor shower perfect for rinsing off after a day spent at the beach. C/A. The proximity to the beach is a major highlight, allowing residents to enjoy the sun, sand, and surf just a short walk from their doorstep.
Discover the epitome of coastal living at OLD COLONY BEACH, a coveted private beach community nestled along the stunning shores of The Long Island Sound. Embrace the tranquility and convenience of this family-friendly enclave, boasting gated streets, seasonal security, and amenities like kayak/canoe/paddle board racks. This highly sought-after location offers unparalleled access to the beach, carousel, bustling bars, savory restaurants, and eclectic retail destinations, all within walking distance. Seize the opportunity to own a piece of this unique paradise, featuring a spacious layout with 3 large bedrooms and one cozy Bedroom. Relish in the ultimate relaxation with a private enclosed outdoor shower and a large outdoor shed for essential storage of beach, garden, and recreational gear. The yard is a serene haven, sheltered for privacy on three sides, perfect for outdoor gatherings and cherished moments. Entertain with ease on the expansive outdoor deck, complete with a large dining table, umbrella, and grill, ideal for savoring coastal breezes and creating lasting memories. Property is being sold as is, offering endless potential to customize and make this beach retreat your own. Don't miss this rare opportunity to have OLD COLONY BEACH as your summer home!
Welcome to Captainâs Watch. This direct waterfront property offers unobstructed views of the Connecticut River, Long Island Sound and the North Fork. Set well above the waterline, relish tranquil sunrises, peaceful sunsets and marvel at the ever-changing palette before you. Original stone walls bound the drive leading to this private 2.7-acre shingle contemporary and a gracious sweeping lawn leads gently to 200â of direct frontage. Inside, find an open floorplan bathed in light. All rooms afford exceptional views. The graceful repetitive arch detail and barrel vaulting offer an architectural nod to ships navigating rough seas. The property is located steps from hidden gem Ferry Landing and a stoneâs throw to historic Old Lyme village shops, galleries and schools. Evening village and boardwalk strolls are a staple! Nearby, find white sand beaches, championship golf, farmersâ markets, dining and shopping. This property is the best combination of bucolic and shoreline living. Captainâs Watch is centrally located two hours between New York/Boston with easy rail access from Saybrook or New London. Views of a lifetime.
Marvel at this exquisite waterfront sanctuary nestled in Old Lyme! A stone-paved driveway welcomes you to meticulously landscaped grounds merging seamlessly with Duck Bay. This neighborhood offers access to Watch Rock Preserve, Duck Bay canoe launch, and Katherine Road's water access. Whether indoors or out, soak in the serene vistas from every angle. Step onto the expansive deck, ideal for basking in the sun, hosting lively gatherings, or sizzling up a storm on the grill. Inside, the open-concept layout exudes charm and sophistication. Windows flood the space with endless natural light and captivating views. Retreat to the first-floor master suite or accommodate guests in the equally inviting guest bedroom. A versatile full heated loft space and finished room above the detached garage offer additional flexibility for various needs. Embrace unobstructed views year-round, thanks to underground utilities, while a separate office/studio with its own entrance provides a serene workspace. Settle onto the vast deck and drink in the panoramic sights of the Connecticut River, Fenwick, and Long Island Sound on the horizon. Conveniently located near tennis courts, golf courses, marinas, farmers' markets, art galleries, restaurants and every day presents endless opportunities for exploration and enjoyment. And with New York and Boston just a two-hour drive away, this waterfront haven offers both seclusion and accessibility in equal measure.
Don't miss the opportunity to acquire this extraordinary 32-acre parcel of land in Old Lyme, CT. With its vast size, stunning surroundings, convenient location, and development potential, this property offers a truly exceptional canvas for your aspirations. Embrace the chance to shape your own private oasis or embark on a visionary development project. With an expansive size spanning an impressive 32 acres, this parcel of land provides ample space for your vision to unfold. Whether you envision a grand estate, a private retreat, or a development project, this vast canvas offers the room you need to bring your dreams to life. me to explore this remarkable land and make your dreams a reality. Old Lyme is situated between Boston and New York.
Welcome to Old Lyme Shores Beach Community, a private beach community offering one of the most desirable private beach's in Old Lyme. This stunning to- be- built bungalow is your dream home, in your dream location. Year round or your weekend and summer family retreat, this modified Build-to Suit is on the last approved building lot in the Community. This new construction home will be breaking ground soon and awaiting your customizable opinion on the details, to call your own. This home offers outstanding craftsmanship and meticulous detail will be shown through the property. The first floor living space features a state-of the art kitchen that is equally as stunning as the main level great room. The master bedroom offers an ensuite bathroom and an additional loft space upstairs. Three floors of windows provide for a calm serene living area to come home to. Whether it is vibrant colors of the changing seasons, the tranquil waves of high and low tides, or the magnificent sunsets that paint the sky, this home has it all. This modern bungalow style home boasts two levels of decks, master suite on the first level, two spacious bedrooms upstairs and an additional loft space for family or guests. Private Beach rights in this association, just a few houses the beach! Grab your chair and walk down to this little slice of heaven!
Introducing Premier living near Black Hall Golf Course, to be built, in Old Lyme by Reagan Homes. Meticulously designed with attention to detail, this Colonial farm style home boasts contemporary architecture, spacious interiors, and an abundance of natural light. There is a builders allowance for kitchen appliances. The convenient open floor plan allows an easy flow throughout the home. The primary en-suite has a soaking tub and full sized shower. There are three more large guest bedrooms with en suite bathrooms. Working from home is simplified with your in home office space!! Enjoy the allure of a home where front and rear porches serve as fantastic spaces for entertaining. Close to Old Lyme Beaches, Old Lyme Country Club and across the street from Horseneck Creek Landing. Come enjoy all Old Lyme has to offer!!
