The median home value in Milmay, NJ is $460,000.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $301,600.
The national median home value is $338,100.
The average price of homes sold in Milmay, NJ is $460,000.
Approximately 78.62% of Milmay homes are owned,
compared to 21.38% rented, while
0% are vacant.
Milmay real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Milmay real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
*HIGHEST AND BEST due Thursday 1/23 at 7pm!!!* A TRUE WOODLAND TREASURE! This rare, almost 8 acre beauty is beautifully remodeled for the start of 2025. This impressive 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom family home offers stunning custom staircase, granite countertops & stainless steel appliances, beautiful oak cabinets, hardwood flooring, fresh carpet, and so much more. This property comes with a large shed, PLUS an additional shed with water and electric. Another unique perk to this property is a CHICKEN COUP with a run! In the back, a blueprint remains for the potential of a possible POLE BARN. Nestled among serene woods with close proximity to our shore points, it provides a peaceful retreat where you can relax and recharge. Experience the best of both worlds & make it yours!
FORMER GAS STATION / TIRE STORE in RDR1 zone, currently allowing for residential use. This corner property offers 243 feet of road frontage on Tuckahoe Rd and almost 400 feet down Millville Avenue. The building has not been used for decades, and it would be the responsibility of the buyer to perform their due diligence to ascertain potential uses of the property. There is no information available nor are there any documents on record with the DEP to ascertain the presence or condition of any potential underground storage tanks. Fabulous visibility along this well-traveled road, so the potential is there for an enterprising entrepreneur. Please check with the Township so inquiry, it could be returned to its previous use.
Discover this exceptional opportunity: 38.86 acres of beautiful, wooded land over three lots! One lot is buildable, offering the potential to construct your dream home with the necessary approvals from both Pinelands and Wetlands authorities. Buyers are advised to perform their due diligence regarding permissions. This stunning property is perfect for hunting enthusiasts, with an abundance of deer, turkey, and wildlife—making it a true haven for nature lovers. The land has frontage on Locust Ave and Highland Ave (a paper street), allowing easy access for hunting and loading. Don’t miss this unique opportunity to own your own piece of outdoor paradise! Bring all offers!!
**Stunning Home in Milmay, NJ - A Nature Lover's Paradise!** Welcome to your dream retreat! Nestled in a serene wooded area, this expansive 2,760 sq ft home sits on a generous 5.3 acres, offering the perfect blend of tranquility and modern living. Step inside to discover a spacious layout featuring four beautifully appointed bedrooms, ideal for family and guests. The two large family rooms on the main level provide ample space for relaxation and entertaining, with large windows that invite natural light and breathtaking views of the surrounding nature. The home boasts two full baths and a convenient half bath, ensuring comfort for everyone. For those who love DIY projects or additional storage, the partially finished basement offers endless possibilities. Car enthusiasts will appreciate the impressive four-car heated garage, providing both functionality and convenience. Experience the beauty of nature right outside your door, with plenty of space for outdoor activities, gardening, or simply enjoying the peace and quiet. Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own a slice of paradise in Milmay, NJ! Schedule your showing today and make this beautiful property your new home. *** Prospective Buyers***** This is an Estate Sale Seller is adding a well water treatment system Massive Reduction - AS IS Sale
Price Reduced by $50,000! Welcome to this charming New England-style log cabin, now available with an expanded 10.68 acres, including Block 108 Lot 5 (4.82 acres). This home, nestled in a tranquil, private setting, offers a perfect blend of rustic charm and modern comfort, awaiting your personal touch and updates. Upon entering, you'll be greeted by the inviting warmth of this log cabin, where traditional rustic elements meet contemporary design. The spacious living room boasts a soaring ceiling and a striking floor-to-ceiling double-sided fireplace, creating a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. From the great room you will see the open concept kitchen with dining area and ample cabinet space. Adjacent to the great room is a versatile bonus space, currently used as an office but easily adaptable to a cozy den, beautiful dining room, or anything that suits your needs. Each room features at least one log accent wall, adding to the home’s unique character. The master bedroom includes a built-in doggie door leading to an outdoor pen and dog house, perfect for your furry friends. The home offers three bedrooms and two full bathrooms, providing ample space for family and guests. The expansive basement, with its 9-foot ceilings and wood-burning stove, presents endless possibilities. Whether you envision a movie room, craft space, gym, or game room, this area is ready for your imagination. A Bilco door provides convenient access to the backyard. Step outside to the HUGE deck with a covered area—ideal for hosting gatherings or enjoying serene moments with your morning coffee or the sunset at dusk with a glass of wine. The picturesque views and expansive yard offer plenty of space for gardening and outdoor activities. For those with hobbies or needs for extra storage, the property includes a well-built 30x40x10 pole barn with electric and water, complete with insulation, concrete flooring, built-in shelves, and workbenches. Attached is a 30x60 carport with three bays. This versatile space is perfect for contractors, craftsmen, mechanics, or horse enthusiasts. The backyard also features a garden shed with a covered porch, providing ample storage for gardening tools, and a 5-bay storage building for additional needs. Enjoy the picturesque landscaping with fruit trees, berry bushes, and trails through the wooded area—ideal for outdoor enthusiasts and hunters alike. This home is being sold "as is," offering a unique opportunity to create your dream retreat in a peaceful and scenic setting. Don’t miss out on making this serene log cabin your own!
Welcome to 1290 Tuckahoe Rd, Milmay, NJ—an exceptional opportunity to own a horse farm with incredible potential! Set on over 19 acres of beautiful rolling countryside, this property offers a perfect canvas for equestrian enthusiasts and nature lovers to create their dream retreat. As you approach, you'll be drawn in by the picturesque landscape and the charm of this property. The farmhouse features 3 bedrooms, a versatile bonus room, and 2 bathrooms—one conveniently located on the main level of the home and the second in the detached garage, adding flexibility for outdoor activities and projects. While the home does require some TLC, it boasts recent updates like a new roof and newer HVAC system, ensuring that key aspects are already in place. The living room, filled with natural light, has a cozy wood-burning stove, perfect for creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The kitchen is a highlight, featuring newer appliances, a tile floor, and plenty of counters and cabinets, providing ample space for cooking and storage. Each bedroom offers comfort, while the bonus room on the main floor provides flexibility for use as an office, playroom, or creative space. Outside, the potential is endless. The large barn with 9 stables is a horse lover’s dream, and the expansive pastures, wooded areas, and meandering stream offer ample space for riding and exploration. The 40'x40' detached brick garage with electricity and multiple outbuildings add valuable storage and utility space. Located in the peaceful town of Milmay, NJ, this property provides a rare chance to create your ideal rural escape, while still being close to shopping, dining, and entertainment. For those with vision and a passion for country living, this horse farm offers a unique opportunity to turn potential into reality. Don’t miss out—schedule your showing today and start imagining the possibilities!
ATTENTION BUILDERS OR NEW HOME BUYERS!!! We offer 3.75 +/- beautiful acres that have been pine lands approved. This pretty lot is waiting for new construction; the building site area has already been cleared and is ready for your new home build. This lot is bordered by trees on the sides and in the rear and offers much privacy. Bring your horses (with Township approvals)! This property comes with an existing garage/workshop - store your building supplies while you work!! We are set back off the road to offer privacy, plenty of space and a country vibe, while we are a convenient driving distance to Vineland's shopping, groceries and restaurants - it's the best of both worlds! There are many premium homes in the vicinity, making this property a good investment!! If you are a builder, OR your dream is to build a home of your own, put us on your viewing list to see what we have to offer YOU!!!
