Bay Shore NY Real Estate & Homes for Rent

178 Properties Found

Sort Results:
26–50 of 178 properties displayed
Refine Property Search
Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 of 8    Prev | Next
Beds:
5
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
2,317
Status:
Active
MLS#:
804693
Type:
Single Family
Lot size:
0.19 Acres
Year built:
1965
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Island Advantage Realty LLC 631-351-6000
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Expanded Style Home. This Home Features 5 Bedrooms, 2 Full Baths, Eat In Kitchen, Living Room w/fplc & 1 Car Garage. Centrally Located To All. Don't Miss This Opportunity!

Beds:
3
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
1,248
Status:
Active
MLS#:
3593476
Type:
Single Family
Lot size:
0.17 Acres
Year built:
1952
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Realty Connect USA L I Inc 631-881-5160
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Great home offering state of the art Contemporary flair. Beautiful 75 by 100 Fenced Lot with privacy. Easy access circular driveway, very convenient. 1 Year Old Roof . Near Main highways ,shopping parks and schools. Prime location just south of Sunrise Hwy. Bay Shore Schools District #001. Low Taxes, Full basement with private out side entry. Utility, Laundry Room, Family room or extended play room. Work out Gym area . Added Sub Panel with sump pump. 1 zone heating control, electric fireplace, sliding doors off the den area , garage with attic stairs, great for storage. Formal Dining room, Eat in Kitchen, 3 Bedrooms and a full bathroom.

Beds:
4
Baths:
3.00
Sq.Ft.:
2,424
Status:
Active
MLS#:
L3593381
Type:
Single Family
Year built:
1998
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Keller Williams Realty Greater 516-873-7100
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Step into a world of refined living at 1432a E. Forks Road. This stunning 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom Bay Shore residence offers a serene escape, perfect for those seeking luxury and tranquility. Indulge your senses with modern interiors featuring sleek natural stone countertops, high-end appliances, and spa-like bathrooms. The open-concept living area is ideal for entertaining, while spacious bedrooms provide peaceful retreats. Outside, a park-like yard beckons, complete with a cozy fire pit and soothing hot tub. Primely located in Bay Shore, you'll have easy access to a wealth of amenities. Don't miss this opportunity to own a piece of paradise., Additional information: Interior Features:Lr/Dr

Beds:
4
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
1,817
Status:
Active
MLS#:
L3593160
Type:
Single Family
Year built:
1962
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Island Advantage Realty LLC 631-351-6000
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Exceptional wide-line raised-ranch style home with excellent, large corner parcel. For spacious rooms, versatile layout and tremendous potential and wonderful opportunity, look no further!

Beds:
4
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
3593160
Type:
Single Family
Lot size:
0.25 Acres
Year built:
1962
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Island Advantage Realty LLC 631-351-6000
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Exceptional wide-line raised-ranch style home with excellent, large corner parcel. For spacious rooms, versatile layout and tremendous potential and wonderful opportunity, look no further!

Beds:
3
Baths:
3.00
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
3593133
Type:
Single Family
Lot size:
0.17 Acres
Year built:
1951
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Howard Hanna Coach 631-581-7979
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Welcome to 23 Benjamin this Move in ready colonial is located close to LIrr This home features a large updated Eik, All redone hard wood floors, 3 nice size bedrooms,2.5 updated baths, finished basement with ose ,New roof , New boiler, Fenced in yard , Do not miss out

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
1,425
Status:
Active
MLS#:
LP1439426
Type:
Retail
Lot size:
0.09 Acres
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Netter Real Estate Inc 631-661-5100
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Discover a fantastic business opportunity with this beautifully renovated restaurant space in the heart of Bay Shore! Perfectly positioned in a bustling, year-round community, this prime location offers excellent visibility and a steady flow of local patrons. With its new design and inviting atmosphere, this space is ready to bring your vision to life. Don’t miss your chance to thrive in one of Long Island's most vibrant neighborhoods!

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
3593255
Type:
Land
Lot size:
0.07 Acres
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Realty Connect USA L I Inc 631-881-5160
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Beds:
6
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
3592745
Type:
Single Family
Lot size:
0.25 Acres
Year built:
1955
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Netter Real Estate Inc 631-661-5100
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Bring your contractor and the vision of your dream home!!

Beds:
4
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
3592496
Type:
Single Family
Lot size:
0.3 Acres
Year built:
1967
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Douglas Elliman Real Estate 631-422-7510
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Welcome to 1400 Boston Avenue, Bay Shore, nestled within the sought-after Islip School District. This freshly painted, spacious 4-bedroom Hi-Ranch offers a perfect blend of modern updates and functional living spaces. At the heart of the home is the beautifully renovated Eat-In Kitchen featuring Granite Countertops, Energy Star Stainless Steel Appliances, and a 6-foot Center Island which provides ample space for meal prep, while also serving as the ideal gathering spot for friends and family. A wall of extra cabinets and countertops offers a versatile space that functions perfectly as a bar or buffet serving area. If you need a breath of fresh air, then step through the 8-foot sliding glass doors onto a large Trex deck where you can sit and enjoy the sunset or host a barbecue. The main level also includes a sunlit Living Room with a large bay window, 3 bedrooms and a full bathroom. The lower level offers a Primary En-Suite, Family Room with wood burning stove, and laundry. Additional highlights include: Hardwood Floors, Gas Cooking and Heating, New Front Stone Paver Patio, New Shed, Hot Tub, Outdoor Shower, Enclosed Entertainment Area with Bar, Above-Ground Pool, Newly Pointed Chimney, PVC Fully Fenced Yard, Full Attic, Garbage Disposal, Updated Electric, New Living Room and Kitchen Windows. Conveniently located in close proximity to all Major Parkways, Restaurants, Shopping, Parks, Beaches, Fire Island Ferries and LIRR.

Beds:
4
Baths:
3.00
Sq.Ft.:
2,160
Status:
Active
MLS#:
L3592186
Type:
Single Family
Subdivision:
Mystic Oaks
Year built:
2001
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty 631-647-7013
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Welcome to this exceptional 2-story Colonial, perfectly situated on a corner lot in Mystic Oaks Development. With an open floor plan, expansive finished basement, and lavish primary suite with jacuzzi tub and W.I.C., this 23-year-young gem provides the ultimate blend of comfort and style. Enjoy the added conveniences of central air, gas heat, and a 2-car garage, making this home the perfect place to create lasting memories., Additional information: Appearance:MINT,Interior Features:Lr/Dr,Separate Hotwater Heater:2

Beds:
5
Baths:
5.00
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
L3592288
Type:
Fourplex
Year built:
1950
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY 631-824-8484
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Welcome to 46 Park Ave, a prime investment opportunity in the heart of Bay Shore. This rare, legal 4-family property by C of O offers exceptional potential for both investors and owner-occupiers seeking rental income. This property is zoned in the Business District (BD). Each unit is thoughtfully designed to provide comfort and convenience, with layouts that maximize space and light. Situated in a desirable neighborhood, 46 Park Ave is close to local amenities, parks, shopping, dining, and Bay Shore's vibrant downtown scene. With easy access to major highways and public transportation, this property ensures convenience for residents. Don't miss this chance to own a multi-family property with great earning potential in Bay Shore., Additional information: Separate Hotwater Heater:Y

Beds:
3
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
3592278
Type:
Single Family
Lot size:
0.28 Acres
Year built:
1960
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Howard Hanna Coach 631-581-7979
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Spectacular Updated California Ranch with Parklike Grounds ! Street to Street property. Hardwood Floors throughout Main level, Updated Full Bath with Jacuzzi Tub, Central Air Conditioning full House including Basement Crown molding in Living Room & 1 Bedroom, One Bedroom has access to Back Yard with Pool & Jungle Gym area, Decking & Patio. Mostly PVC fencing. Unique Basement with Bar- Billiard Room, Soundproof Recording Room, Storage and 1/2 Bathroom

Beds:
5
Baths:
5.00
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
3592288
Type:
Other
Year built:
1950
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY 631-824-8484
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Welcome to 46 Park Ave, a prime investment opportunity in the heart of Bay Shore. This rare, legal 4-family property by C of O offers exceptional potential for both investors and owner-occupiers seeking rental income. This property is zoned in the Business District (BD). Each unit is thoughtfully designed to provide comfort and convenience, with layouts that maximize space and light. Situated in a desirable neighborhood, 46 Park Ave is close to local amenities, parks, shopping, dining, and Bay Shore's vibrant downtown scene. With easy access to major highways and public transportation, this property ensures convenience for residents. Don't miss this chance to own a multi-family property with great earning potential in Bay Shore.

Beds:
4
Baths:
3.00
Sq.Ft.:
2,160
Status:
Active
MLS#:
3592186
Type:
Single Family
Subdivision:
Mystic Oaks
Lot size:
0.11 Acres
Year built:
2001
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty 631-647-7013
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Welcome to this exceptional 2-story Colonial, perfectly situated on a corner lot in Mystic Oaks Development. With an open floor plan, expansive finished basement, and lavish primary suite with jacuzzi tub and W.I.C., this 23-year-young gem provides the ultimate blend of comfort and style. Enjoy the added conveniences of central air, gas heat, and a 2-car garage, making this home the perfect place to create lasting memories.

Beds:
4
Baths:
3.00
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
3591967
Type:
Condo
Subdivision:
Windemere
Lot size:
0.05 Acres
Year built:
1986
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC 631-665-1500
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Beautiful Belmont Unit available for sale in the Windermere. This unit features four bedrooms, three bathrooms, a one car garage, eat in kitchen, living room with fireplace, first floor master bedroom with master bathroom, den, two large bedrooms upstairs and great storage space. The Windemere Community is a 24 hr Gated Community w/ Tennis, Heated Inground Pool, Dog Run, Clubhouse, Gym & Sauna. Taxes of 13558.45.

Beds:
4
Baths:
3.00
Sq.Ft.:
2,731
Status:
Active
MLS#:
800792
Type:
Single Family
Year built:
1860
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: REALHome Services & Solutions 678-201-0475
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Looking for a great opportunity? Look no more! This property has tons of potential and is average in living space size for the neighborhood. It is located close to main roads with easy access to local amenities, such as shopping, banking, schools, and various eateries. Per our Appraisal describe the property as a SFR (colonial) built in 1860. It has a GLA of approx. 2731 and has 4 bedroom and 3 Baths, full/unfinished basement and 2-Det Garage. The property is on 11,326 sq ft *** Seller cannot guarantee access at any given time. Offers may be made sight unseen nor does seller guarantee accuracy whether property is on public sewer or private septic. ***

Beds:
4
Baths:
3.00
Sq.Ft.:
2,731
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H800792
Type:
Single Family
Year built:
1860
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: REALHome Services & Solutions 678-201-0475
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Looking for a great opportunity? Look no more! This property has tons of potential and is average in living space size for the neighborhood. It is located close to main roads with easy access to local amenities, such as shopping, banking, schools, and various eateries. Per our Appraisal describe the property as a SFR (colonial) built in 1860. It has a GLA of approx. 2731 and has 4 bedroom and 3 Baths, full/unfinished basement and 2-Det Garage. The property is on 11,326 sq ft *** Seller cannot guarantee access at any given time. Offers may be made sight unseen nor does seller guarantee accuracy whether property is on public sewer or private septic. *** BuildingAreaSource: Appraiser,

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
L3590958
Type:
Fourplex
Year built:
1920
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Compass Greater NY LLC 718-423-7700
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Opportunity awaits! Incredible, income-producing investment property located in the heart of Bay Shore - this legal four-family unit boasts four 2-bedroom units. Apartments are spacious and were recently updated. This home also features two full-car garages, which can garner further monthly income. Proximally located near the LIRR Bay Shore stop and minutes away from newly developed downtown Bay Shore, which features trendy restaurants, shopping, bars, nightlife and access to the Fire Island ferries. Please see attached for current rent roll and expenses.

Beds:
8
Baths:
4.00
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
3590958
Type:
Other
Year built:
1920
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Compass Greater NY LLC 718-423-7700
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Opportunity awaits! Incredible, income-producing investment property located in the heart of Bay Shore - this legal four-family unit boasts four 2-bedroom units. Apartments are spacious and were recently updated. This home also features two full-car garages, which can garner further monthly income. Proximally located near the LIRR Bay Shore stop and minutes away from newly developed downtown Bay Shore, which features trendy restaurants, shopping, bars, nightlife and access to the Fire Island ferries. Please see attached for current rent roll and expenses.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
L3590813
Type:
Retail
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Prime Estates Realty Inc 718-819-8200
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

This is a fantastic opportunity to acquire a well-established dry cleaning business with a steady income stream and a loyal customer base. The current owners are retiring after years of successful operation, providing a seamless transition for the new owner.

Beds:
4
Baths:
3.00
Sq.Ft.:
2,472
Status:
Active
MLS#:
L3590456
Type:
Single Family
Year built:
1937
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Coldwell Banker American Homes 516-864-8100
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Beautifully Maintained Colonial with 4 Bedrooms, 1.55 Baths, Welcoming Front Porch with Carport, Entry Foyer, Formal Living & Dining, Parlor with Fireplace, Eat In Kitchen, 4 Bedrooms, and Office. Hardwood Floors & Custom Moldings Throughout, Full Basement with Utilities. Huge Paver Driveway and Paver Patio with Plenty of Yard Space., Additional information: Appearance:Excellent

Beds:
4
Baths:
3.00
Sq.Ft.:
2,472
Status:
Active
MLS#:
3590456
Type:
Single Family
Lot size:
0.43 Acres
Year built:
1937
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Coldwell Banker American Homes 516-864-8100
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Beautifully Maintained Colonial with 4 Bedrooms, 1.55 Baths, Welcoming Front Porch with Carport, Entry Foyer, Formal Living & Dining, Parlor with Fireplace, Eat In Kitchen, 4 Bedrooms, and Office. Hardwood Floors & Custom Moldings Throughout, Full Basement with Utilities. Huge Paver Driveway and Paver Patio with Plenty of Yard Space.

Beds:
3
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
L3590392
Type:
Single Family
Year built:
1935
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Realty Connect USA L I Inc 631-881-5160
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

WELCOME TO 135 PENATAQUIT AVENUE, BAY SHORE ***HOME IS TOTALLY RENOVATED IN THE LAST 3 MONTHS!!! This Vintage Colonial offers a lovely entrance foyer, Warm Welcoming Center Hall leading into a beautiful Formal Living Room, Eat in Kitchen with White Shaker Cabinetry, Quartz Counter tops, Stainless Steel Appliances. Formal Dining Room. Main level full bathroom, along with rear mudroom and laundry area. 2nd Level: 3 bedrooms, full baths. Hardwood flooring on both levels. Home has updated electric, new windows, full basement with walk out. New asphalt driveway, with Belgian Block Trim. Close to Shopping, Bay Shore Village Restaurants for fine Dining. Close to Ferries to Fire Island, Bay Shore Schools. A TRUE SUN FILLED BEAUTY!!! MAKE THIS FINE HOME YOURS!!!, Additional information: Appearance:mint

Beds:
3
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
3590392
Type:
Single Family
Lot size:
0.17 Acres
Year built:
1935
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Realty Connect USA L I Inc 631-881-5160
View additional info

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

WELCOME TO 135 PENATAQUIT AVENUE, BAY SHORE ***HOME IS TOTALLY RENOVATED IN THE LAST 3 MONTHS!!! This Vintage Colonial offers a lovely entrance foyer, Warm Welcoming Center Hall leading into a beautiful Formal Living Room, Eat in Kitchen with White Shaker Cabinetry, Quartz Counter tops, Stainless Steel Appliances. Formal Dining Room. Main level full bathroom, along with rear mudroom and laundry area. 2nd Level: 3 bedrooms, full baths. Hardwood flooring on both levels. Home has updated electric, new windows, full basement with walk out. New asphalt driveway, with Belgian Block Trim. Close to Shopping, Bay Shore Village Restaurants for fine Dining. Close to Ferries to Fire Island, Bay Shore Schools. A TRUE SUN FILLED BEAUTY!!! MAKE THIS FINE HOME YOURS!!!

Refine Property Search
Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 of 8    Prev | Next
26–50 of 178 properties displayed
Andrea D. Conner, License 10311208085, Xome Inc., License 10991227159, [email protected], 844-400-XOME (9663), 750 Highway 121 Bypass, Suite 100, Lewisville, Texas 75067

Listings courtesy of One Key MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 11/13/2024. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS. Per New York legal requirement, click here for the Standard Operating Procedures. Copyright 2025, OneKey MLS, Inc. All Rights Reserved.



Bay Shore Real Estate

Bay Shore is located in New York. Bay Shore, New York has a population of 31,488. Bay Shore is more family-centric than the surrounding county with 35.3% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 32.94%.

The median household income in Bay Shore, New York is $97,783. The median household income for the surrounding county is $111,660 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Bay Shore is 35.6 years.

Bay Shore Weather

The average high temperature in July is 82.1 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 23.5 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 46.2 inches per year, with 25.5 inches of snow per year.

Bay Shore Map

Bay Shore Real Estate Market Conditions

  • Median sales price

    $615,000
    13.1%
    change since last quarter
  • # Active listings

    178
    30-day change

Bay Shore Schools and Demographics

Education near Bay Shore, NY

City County
High School Graduates 86.96 90.39
College Degree - 2 year 10.9 9.66
College Degree - 4 year 33.61 38.31
Graduate Degree 11.42 12.89
Expenditures per Student 30,219 30,219
Students per Teacher 12.3 12.3

Elementary Schools near Bay Shore, NY

Grades Students P/T Ratio ZIP
Bayview Elementary School KG - 05 459 14.3 11795
Brook Avenue Elementary School KG - 02 405 14.2 11706
Commack Road Elementary School 02 - 05 483 16.1 11751
East Elementary School PK - 01 642 15.3 11717
Fifth Avenue School KG - 02 341 16.2 11706
Gardiner Manor School 03 - 05 743 15.2 11706
Hemlock Elementary School 01 - 05 774 24.2 11706
Laurel Park Elementary School 01 - 05 633 18.3 11717
Loretta Park Elementary School 01 - 05 747 20.2 11717
Manetuck Elementary School KG - 05 520 14.8 11795
Marion G Vedder Elementary School KG - 05 401 14.3 11703
Mary G Clarkson School KG - 02 524 13.6 11706
Maud S Sherwood Elementary School 02 - 05 350 15.6 11751
North Elementary School 01 - 05 850 20.5 11717
Northeast Elementary School 01 - 05 1,048 19.8 11717
Oak Park Elementary School 01 - 05 787 17.1 11706
Oquenock Elementary School KG - 05 475 14.8 11795
Parliament Place School KG - 05 451 18 11703
Paul J Bellew Elementary School KG - 05 493 17 11795
Pine Park Elementary School KG - 02 634 17.1 11717
South Country School 03 - 06 585 14.3 11706
Southeast Elementary School 01 - 05 701 24.3 11717
Southwest Elementary School PK - 05 1,217 18.2 11706
Twin Pines Elementary School 01 - 05 921 20.9 11717
William E Deluca Junior Elementary School KG - 05 456 19 11703
Wing Elementary School KG - 01 362 17.2 11751
Woodhull School PK - 06 36 5.1 11706
Woods Road Elementary School KG - 05 405 18.4 11703

Middle Schools near Bay Shore, NY

Grades Students P/T Ratio ZIP
Bay Shore Middle School 06 - 08 1,446 14.9 11706
Beach Street Middle School 06 - 08 553 14.6 11795
East Middle School 06 - 08 1,030 17 11717
Islip Middle School 06 - 08 708 12 11751
North Middle School 06 - 08 1,100 17.5 11717
Robert Moses Middle School 06 - 08 1,077 15.3 11703
South Middle School 06 - 08 892 17.5 11717
Udall Road Middle School 06 - 08 578 16.5 11795
West Middle School 06 - 08 938 15.4 11706

High Schools near Bay Shore, NY

Grades Students P/T Ratio ZIP
Bay Shore Senior High School 09 - 12 1,916 14.4 11706
Brentwood High School 09 - 12 4,289 19.3 11717
Islip High School 09 - 12 1,022 12.2 11751
North Babylon High School 09 - 12 1,551 15.3 11703
West Islip Senior High School 09 - 12 1,549 13.1 11795

Ungraded Schools near Bay Shore, NY

Grades Students P/T Ratio ZIP
Freshman Center 09 - 09 1,209 17.6 11717

Demographics near Bay Shore, NY

City County
Neighborhood Type Suburban
Population 31,488 1,522,998
Population Density 5,830 1,670
Median Age 35.6 41.7
People per Household 3.3 3
Median Household Income 97,783 111,660
Average Income per Capita 40,688 49,404

Real estate near Bay Shore