The median home value in Bay Shore, NY is $615,000.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $565,700.
The national median home value is $338,100.
The average price of homes sold in Bay Shore, NY is $615,000.
Approximately 62.89% of Bay Shore homes are owned,
compared to 32.04% rented, while
5.08% are vacant.
Bay Shore real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Bay Shore real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Courtesy: Power Team Realty Corp
631-231-8000
Prime commercial property in the heart of Bay Shore! Strategically located for maximum visibility and foot traffic, this space offers endless potential for businesses seeking to thrive in a bustling and growing community. Surrounded by local amenities, shops, and transportation hubs, it’s an ideal opportunity to establish your presence in a sought-after location. Don’t miss out on this exceptional investment!
Courtesy: Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
631-665-1500
Waterfront 2 family home, 105 feet of bulkhead 5-6 boat slips, 2 car attached garage with second floor storage, full basement, nice waterfront location.
Courtesy: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
631-589-8500
New To Market! 2 Bedroom, 2.5 Bath Condo in Windemere Pond. 2,192 sq feet of Living Space. This Gated Development is Located South of Montauk in Bay Shore. Amenities include 24hr Guarded Gate, Heated Outdoor Pool, Clubhouse w/Kitchen, Gym, Library, Baths, & Changing room also A Tennis Court & A Dog Run. Close to LIRR, Beaches & Restaurants. One Car Attached Garage. Primary Bedroom Ensuite. Living Room, Dining Room, Den and Eat In Kitchen. Very Spacious. Priced To Sell! Too Good Too Miss!
Courtesy: Century 21 AA Realty
631-226-5995
Mint condition Hi Ranch on 1/3rd of an acre - Low Taxes! Hardwood Floors, 4 Bedrooms, 2 Baths. Unlimited potential. In proximity to schools, parking, and transportation. On a quiet dead end street. A must see that will not last!!
Courtesy: Century 21 Parisi Realty
631-669-3900
This spacious 8-room home has a 2-car garage, 2 full baths, a huge unfinished basement, a den with a fireplace, a formal dining room, and a heated sunroom. It is located in West Bay Shore, 2 blocks away from Montauk Highway. The home, sold as is needs many renovations, so it is priced thousands of dollars below market. The location makes this an excellent opportunity for "sweat equity" for those with the resources. Call your broker today to arrange a showing.
Courtesy: Century 21 AA Realty
631-226-5995
Welcome to this stunning, fully updated ranch home in the heart of Brightwaters. This property has recently been meticulously renovated down to the studs, blending modern luxury with cozy comfort. The bright, airy white kitchen features smart appliances and a beautiful island making cooking and entertaining both convenient and stylish. The home offers a brand-new bathroom and a striking new fireplace, adding warmth and ambiance for relaxing evenings at home. Spacious rooms throughout leave plenty of room to live, work, and entertain. The full, finished basement is a true highlight, offering a newly updated bathroom, separate entrance and endless possibilities—perfect for a home office, gym, or guest space. For added value, the property also includes a legal studio apartment, providing a fantastic opportunity for rental income or multi-generation accommodations. Located on a desirable corner lot, this home offers the perfect balance of quiet residential living with easy access to all that Brightwaters has to offer. A true combination of luxury, comfort, and endless potential—this home is ready to welcome its next owner.
Courtesy: Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
631-665-1500
Stunning Home In Daniel’s Way...Discover your dream home in a sought-after 55+ community! This beautifully updated property offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and functionality. Modern Kitchen: Updated with sleek finishes and ample storage for all your culinary needs, Elegant Dining: A formal dining room perfect for hosting gatherings and special occasions, Cozy Living Room: Relax by the charming fireplace in the spacious living area. Dual Primary Suites: Enjoy ultimate convenience with two master suites—one on the main floor and one upstairs—ideal for privacy and flexibility. Premium Amenities: Central air for year-round comfort and a central vacuum system for easy maintenance, Gleaming wood floors throughout add warmth and character. Located in a peaceful and friendly 55+ community, this home combines modern upgrades with timeless appeal. Don’t miss your chance to enjoy a serene and sophisticated lifestyle in this exceptional property!
Courtesy: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
516-354-6500
Welcome to 1137 Reilly St., a charming Cape Cod home in the heart of Bay Shore! This beautiful, maintained property offers 4 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, perfect for growing families or hosting guests. Step into the updated kitchen, complete with granite countertops and stainless-steel appliances. the home features modern ductless units ensuring efficient heating and cooling year-round. the walk-out basement provides endless potential for additional living space or home office. Step outside to enjoy the large backyard featuring an above-ground pool, perfect for summer fun and relaxation. Whether you're entertaining, gardening, or unwinding by the pool, this outdoor space has it all. Conveniently located near schools, parks, shopping, and dining, this home offers both comfort and convenience. Don't miss the chance to make this Cape Cod gem your own! Schedule a showing today! *Seller's sale is contingent upon securing a new home. All offers must allow the seller time to find a suitable housing. Please ensure buyers are aware and flexible with this arrangement before submitting an offer*
Courtesy: Signature Premier Properties
631-585-8400
Welcome to this stunning 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Colonial home in the private Community of Mystic Oaks in Bayshore, perfectly situated on the largest lot in the development and a desirable corner property. Designed with an open floor plan, this home seamlessly blends modern comfort and functionality, offering spacious living and dining areas that are perfect for both everyday life and entertaining. Each of the four bedrooms is generously sized, while the two full baths and convenient half bath provide ample convenience for family and guests. Central air conditioning, The expansive outdoor space offers endless possibilities for activities, gardening, or future enhancements, this home is close to schools, shopping, dining, transportation and all the amenities you need. Don’t miss the chance to make this exceptional property your own!
Courtesy: Signature Premier Properties
631-647-4880
Welcome to this beautiful 3 bedroom, 2 bath Colonial Situated on a 100 x 100 property with a totally fenced backyard perfect for entertaining. This home boasts a Living Room and Formal Dining Room with Hardwood Floors, Beautiful Eat in Kitchen with Stainless Steel Appliances and Granite Countertops and 2 Updated Full Bathrooms. A Finished Basement with outdoor access is a plus. Your New home is Located on a quiet dead-end street close to shopping, transportation and major roadways.
Courtesy: Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
631-665-1500
Amazing land Opportunity in Bayshore/Brightwaters. Zoned Industrial 1 with over one acre of property and 3 Large Buildings this is a piece that can work for many uses. Mini Storage , Recycling / Transfer Station, Supply House /wholesale Establishment, Manufacturing, Agriculture or Nursery including retail sale of Products. Property is Fully Fenced and well kept .
Courtesy: DAC Properties Corp
516-378-8888
This beautifully expanded Cape-style home offers over 1,200 square feet of living space and sits on a generous quarter-acre lot, providing the perfect balance of indoor and outdoor living. The home features hardwood floors throughout, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The spacious layout is perfect for both everyday living and entertaining. Outside, you'll find your own private oasis with a 32 x 16 inground saltwater pool, ideal for relaxation and summer gatherings. A finished basement with a separate outside entrance. The property is equipped with leased solar panels, offering energy efficiency and savings on utility bills. Conveniently located just minutes from schools, shopping centers, parks, and public transportation, this home provides easy access to everything Bay Shore has to offer. With a spacious driveway for ample parking, this charming home combines comfort, convenience, and sustainability, making it a true gem in the area. Do not miss out on this one!
Courtesy: Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
631-665-1500
Discover this 1,234-square-foot ranch-style home situated on a peaceful dead-end street in Bay Shore. This property offers the perfect blend of comfort and functionality, with a thoughtful layout and desirable features throughout. The home includes a spacious living room, an eat-in kitchen, a bright four-seasons room, and a formal dining room. The master bedroom boasts its own private bathroom, while two additional bedrooms provide ample space for family or guests. The property also features a large two-car garage and a fully finished basement with a private entrance, offering potential for additional living space or an in-law suite. Outside, enjoy the semi in-ground pool, perfect for summer gatherings. Energy efficiency is a highlight, with leased solar panels keeping electric bills low. This home is a must-see for those seeking a serene location with plenty of amenities.
Courtesy: Sir Winston Realty Inc
631-968-8881
Totally Renovated From to Bottom. Beautiful Mother & Daughter Colonial style home on Quiet Cul-de-sac. This home has all the trimmings. Possibly 6Br 2.5 Bath with full finish basement private entrance & a 1car attached Garage. It Boast a open floor plan No interior walls on 1st floor, Beautiful polished Oak floors Throughout. Hi Hats Galore, Kitchen features Full length Oakwood Cabinets with self closing doors. Granite Counters, Stainless steel appliances, Den with Wood burning fireplace, 4 levels of living space. Master Bedroom with cathedral ceilings & walk in closet. Everything is New Inground sprinkler system, garage with electric opener, New Cement Patio, New Double wide driveway. Located within walking distance to Westfield Mall, Bus, & trains & schools. Your Dream home awaits you.
Courtesy: Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
631-665-1500
Welcome to this recently updated two-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bathroom townhome in the sought-after South Sunscape Condo Complex. Spanning approximately 2,429 square feet, this home boasts a two-car attached garage and thoughtful updates throughout. Step into the stunning foyer featuring high ceilings and a skylight, creating a bright and inviting entrance. The first floor offers an open-concept living room with a cozy fireplace, a spacious eat-in kitchen, and a convenient half bathroom. Upstairs, the master suite impresses with an oversized walk-in closet (with laundry) and a newly renovated spa-like master bathroom, complete with a sauna. The second floor also includes a secondary bedroom, an additional full bathroom, and a versatile loft-style living area. Residents of the Sunscape Complex enjoy access to premium amenities, including a tennis court, swimming pool, and marina. Don’t miss this opportunity to enjoy comfortable living in a vibrant, amenity-rich community!
Courtesy: Netter Real Estate Inc
631-661-5100
An updated 4 bedroom, 2.5 bathroom Atlantis unit with a prime location in the beautiful Admiralty! The largest model in the complex with stunning views of the pond and island. This 24 hour guard gated community offers extensive amenities and sits on 100 acres of incredibly manicured grounds of the former Thorne Estate, and borders an additional 100 acres of nature preserve. A community pool, beautiful clubhouse, tennis and pickleball courts, and a fantastic marina contribute to a resort lifestyle that cant be beat! And with all exterior maintenance included, it truly is a vacation at home!
Courtesy: Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
631-665-1500
Introducing an exceptional investment opportunity: a fully occupied legal four-family home featuring 12 bedrooms with market-rate rents, delivering a strong net operating income of $105,416 and an impressive 7.58% cap rate. Property Highlights: Size: 5,024 sq. ft. building on a spacious 17,859 sq. ft. lot. Units: Four market-rate rental units with consistent tenant demand. Prime Location: Downtown Access: Just 0.1 miles from Main Street. Healthcare Proximity: Only 0.4 miles from South Shore University Hospital. Transportation: 0.4 miles from Bay Shore Train Station for easy commuting. Tenants enjoy walkable access to dining, shopping, healthcare, and public transportation, ensuring strong occupancy and future growth potential. This property offers investors a rare chance to own a turnkey asset in a highly sought-after area. Don’t miss out on this opportunity to expand your portfolio. For more information or to schedule a showing, contact us today!
Courtesy: Keller Williams Realty Empire
718-954-8400
Great Space For Investors, Developers & End-Users Alike! This property has a fully detached one story mixed-use building on one side and huge lot on the other side with limitless potential for the end user or investor. The lot is very spacious at 14,810 Sqft. The property enjoys phenomenal exposure sure to highlight any signage. There are 2 bays w/ 58 parking spaces, The Zoning is Industrial 2. the property has 3 phase power and updated LED lighting as well as a fenced lot and paved parking lot. The property is located close to the Deer Park LIRR Station. Once the location of a successful auto body business this location has great neighbors which include FedEx, M & T Bank, The Home Depot, Puma, Chipotle, Texas Roadhouse, Kohl's, Polo Ralph Lauren, Adidas, Saks Off 5th, Old Navy, Ann Taylor, Crocs, Vans, J. Crew, Miller's Ale House, Regal Cinemas, Nike, Tommy Hilfiger, Coach, Kate Spade, Crocs, Dick's Sporting Goods, American Eagle, Saf-T-Swim, Mosquito Joe, Red Lobster and many more.
Courtesy: ARVY Realty
631-617-5135
Pride in ownership! Move in condition Cape with hardwood floors, eat-in kitchen with NEW appliances and a laundry room on a fully fenced corner lot with a 1.5 car garage. Simply paint and refinish the hardwood floors and enjoy this home! Many updates! Roof, vinyl windows, AC units, separate HW heater, 150 amp electric, inground sprinklers, and more!! Excellent location.. just a 1.5 mile drive to Bay Shore's Main St for local shopping & restaurants in addition to the Fire Island Ferry, near highways for easy commuting & close to schools. Additional features: Complete reverse osmosis water system
Courtesy: Century 21 Realty Specialists
631-418-8222
Short Sale Pending Third Party Approval. Needs TLC, Seller has previously entered into a purchase option agreement for the property which is unexpired. The optionee has not exercised its rights under the agreement. The optionee may require financial consideration to release its rights and fulfill the terms of the agreement. The agreement provides for the optionor to receive an option fee
Courtesy: Michael J Watts & Assoc Inc
631-650-9933
Welcome to this lovely 2-bedroom, 1-bath mobile home in a convenient & friendly community. The spacious living area is perfect for relaxing after a long day. The
Courtesy: Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
631-665-1500
Newbrook gardens, first floor 1 bedroom unit totally renovated, heat and gas included, 922 monthly maintenance fee, includes taxes,
Courtesy: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
516-759-0400
Welcome To This Stunning 6 Bedroom, 3 Full Bath, 2 Half Bath Colonial With Over 3800 Sq. Ft. of Living Space. Lg Living Room, Den w/Fireplace, Formal Dining Room, EIK w/Center Island, Granite and Stainless Appliances, Primary Suite w/Full Bath and WIC. 2-Car Attached Garage Lovely Tree-Lined Property, Paver Patio, Stone Firepit & In-Ground Pool for Relaxing and Entertaining!, Additional information: Appearance: Diamond Complete interior renovation in 2022, complete exterior renovation in 2024!
Courtesy: Voro LLC
877-943-8676
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Coach
631-587-1700
Beautifully renovated Expanded Ranch in Beautiful Bay Shore! Completely remodeled with attention to detail in every space. Bright and airy kitchen, gorgeous bathrooms and gleaming hardwood floors. Fabulous house!
