The median home value in Brooktondale, NY is $296,411.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $205,200.
The national median home value is $219,700.
The average price of homes sold in Brooktondale, NY is $296,411.
Approximately 56.19% of Brooktondale homes are owned,
compared to 39.3% rented, while
4.51% are vacant.
Brooktondale real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Brooktondale real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Courtesy: Howard Hanna S Tier Inc
607-257-0800
Incredible, newly updated modular ranch with first impressions of attention to detail, spaciousness, practicality, and charm! This 3-bedroom, 2-full bathroom home in Brooktondale, NY/Ithaca School District, has an inviting single-story layout designed for easy accessibility and comfort. High ceilings, large windows, and an open floor plan seamlessly connect the living room with the kitchen. Interior has been painted in soothing tones, creating a cohesive and inviting atmosphere that complements any style of décor. Washer and dryer are located on the main level with additional hook ups in the full unfinished basement which offers significant space and a variety of uses. Located on almost ¾ of an acre, the rear deck is an amazing place to gather and the shed and chicken coop offer additional storage and opportunities. Wide gravel driveway offers plenty of parking and a new well was drilled in 2024. Conveniently located near the Goetchius Preserve for nature enthusiasts and centrally located near Ithaca and Dryden.
Courtesy: Keller Williams Realty
607-275-5600
Wonderfully maintained home nestled in a quiet country setting on the market for the first time ever. Set on a flat open lot surrounded by goldenrod fields while minutes away from amenities. A sweeping front porch welcomes you in. A floorplan designed with efficiency and storage space in mind. Warm hardwood floors and picture windows with peaceful views. Single floor living with two ensuite bedrooms on the main floor. The dining room features doors out to the back deck with awning, surrounded by a well loved and designed fenced in garden area. Finished basement for extra space. Attached garage plus a separate, larger detached garage. All move in ready.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna S Tier Inc
607-257-0800
Charming cottage style home in the heart of Brooktondale with a large wrap around porch, back deck and sunsational 3 season room that could easily be made into year round living space. Fantastic, private back yard with some perennial gardens and a shed to store the gardening tools. Amish built garage has a walk up studio space great for hobbies, workshop or storage. The home offers a spacious kitchen, formal dining room, large living room and full bath on the main level. Upstairs you will find two bedrooms and another full bath.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna S Tier Inc
607-257-0800
Well maintained and efficient 2 bed 1 1/2 bath home in nice country setting. Nice open floor plan with comfortably sized rooms with great light. Single level living. Electric heat. Private lane off the main road. This is a great starter home that won't break the bank.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna S Tier Inc
607-257-0800
Country Classic Farmhouse, close to amenities!! Situated on almost an acre of land, with a fenced in yard and a small orchard of fruit trees, this home is minutes away from Shindegan Hollow State Forest and Brookton's Market in the heart of Brooktondale. The orchard includes apples and pear trees, with blueberry and currant bushes along the fence. The vegetable garden features onions and copious amounts of mint. Take in sunrises and sunsets on the deck or in the hot tub in this peaceful parcel of beauty. Exposed reclaimed ceiling beams and a cherry hardwood floor in the living room add to the charm of this country home. A walk-in pantry, formal dining room, and spacious kitchen will make entertaining a joy! Enter through the backyard gate on Central Chapel Rd.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna S Tier Inc
607-257-0800
This expansive 4-bedroom, 2 full bathroom manufactured home is nestled on a sprawling 4.68-acre lot within the Ithaca City School District. Be welcomed by cathedral ceilings, immense natural light throughout, and an open living concept that has two bedrooms located on each wing of the home. The primary en-suite is primed for rest and relaxation and includes a massive soaking tub and shower in addition to an expansive closet. The large eat-in kitchen and nearby laundry room offer convenience and easy accessibility with single level living. Unwind in these serene surroundings and have the ability to build an oversized garage or other structure by using the established gravel pad with electricity already in place. 46 Light is located directly next door and also for sale. Properties can be purchased separately or together. Owner financing may be possible.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna S Tier Inc
607-257-0800
Discover this inviting 3-bedroom, 2-full bathroom manufactured home nestled on a 2-acre lot within the Ithaca City School District. Built in 2014, this property boasts desirable single level living and many modern amenities! The kitchen includes newer appliances and a large kitchen island, perfect for both everyday living and entertaining guests. En-suite master bathroom adds additional convenience while offering another full bathroom for guests on the opposite wing of the home. Many large windows, high ceilings, and a naturally open and flowing floorplan help enhance feelings of spaciousness and easy accessibility. Step outside to enjoy the expansive outdoor amenities including a flourishing garden with a variety of vegetables, separate patch dedicated to corn, 4-car carport providing ample parking and protection from the elements, and a shed for additional storage. Whether you're hosting gatherings or simply enjoying your surroundings, this property offers versatile outdoor spaces and will cater to your needs. 48 Light is located directly next door and also for sale. Properties can be purchased separately or together.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna S Tier Inc
607-257-0800
Truly a nature lovers paradise! Minutes to Shindagin Hollow State forest with world class trail system for all of your outdoor activities including biking, hiking, snowshoeing and cross country skiing. Located just east of Ithaca in Brooktondale- this pristine home has been meticulously completed with high end finishes. An inviting open floorplan with luxury plank flooring throughout the main level. An open cherry kitchen boasts quartz countertops, large island with cook-top, double oven and a lovely office area. Two large bedrooms share a full bath. Upstairs is ready for you to complete into a HUGE primary suite or multiple bedrooms. Rough plumbing already in place for a full bath up! Downstairs features a ready to finish lower level with large windows on the west side. Fully insulated and powered with high efficiency mini split system that offers both heating and cooling. Everything is new, from the well, septic, siding, windows heating/cooling and more! Ample parking, new 4BR septic, new gutters and fresh landscaping. Complete with a lovely back yard and firepit. A truly special home that exudes privacy, easy living and a sense of natural beauty throughout.
Courtesy: Hage Real Estate
607-753-6766
Just off State Route 79 past Slaterville, turn onto Speed Hill Road and discover a serene 5.34-acre wooded parcel, perfectly positioned before the road becomes seasonal. This property offers seclusion and privacy, ideal for various uses such as a recreational retreat or the site of your dream home. Located within close proximity to Ithaca and Route 79, this parcel provides both convenience and a peaceful natural setting. A grass driveway leads to a small cleared section, while the majority of the land is densely wooded, ensuring a sense of natural beauty and privacy. Whether you seek a quiet campsite, a private getaway, or a future home nestled in the woods, this versatile property invites exploration and imagination. Embrace the opportunity to create your own sanctuary amidst the beauty of nature, with easy access to nearby amenities and the potential for a variety of uses.
Courtesy: Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc.
607-257-0666
Move-in-ready 2 bedroom, 1 bath manufactured home (2015) in Brooktondale, NY. Bright interiors with natural light, eat-in kitchen, newer appliances, gas stove. Cozy front porch perfect for morning coffee. Scenic back deck in a wooded setting overlooking an enchanting creek. Minutes from Ithaca and Cornell. Features AC, storage shed, and access to Ithaca Schools.
Spacious 3 -4 bedroom Home with many updates. Open floor plan in living room, kitchen, dining area. All new flooring throughout. Kitchen features hickory cabinets, plenty of counter space, pantry. Living room with plenty of natural light. Wood fireplace with built in shelving. Large Primary bedroom and bath with double sink vanity and walk in closet. Office could be the 4th bedroom. Enclosed porch with hot tub. Plenty of decking to enjoy the peaceful surroundings. Deck wraps around the inground pool. One car garage with breezeway connecting to the house. Mud room to drop your shoes. Home has a metal roof, heated with either coal stove or oil forced hot air so you have options. Property is located only 15 minutes from Cornell University, downtown Ithaca and a short drive to Owego
One-level living awaits you in this cheerful, turnkey 3-bedroom, 2-bath home located just outside the heart of Brooktondale. Step inside & relish the welcoming open layout, complete w/ a spacious kitchen featuring a central island & a cozy dining nook. The expansive two-level living room creates two distinct spaces, one boasting built-in bookshelves & the other hosting a wood-burning stove, a perfect spot to cozy up. Ample windows allow natural light to flood the space, offering picturesque views of the grassy, level 1.7-acre lot bordering 6 Mile Creek. The main level boasts a spectacular primary bedroom with an en-suite bathroom featuring a double vanity & double closets. High ceilings & numerous windows make this a serene retreat. Additionally, discover 2 more bedrooms, each w/ its own closet, and an updated shared hallway bathroom on this level. The lower level includes unfinished space, home gym area, and a finished private bar room. Open House on Saturday from 10-12.
Spacious 3BR & 1BA home with 2 offices, an oversized attached 2 car garage with a bonus area above and an additional building out back that provides even more space to work and play! The original cape cod was built in 1865 and the interior and exterior were completely gutted/redone with with a back addition added in 1984. The family room with cathedral ceiling and sliding glass door leading out to an expansive deck overlooking the backyard was constructed in 1994. Enjoy the convenience of having two first floor bedrooms, an eat-in kitchen that opens up to the dining/living room area and two front decks with built-in seating perfect for entertaining guests inside or out! Have all this on a 2.10 acre parcel in Town Caroline only 12 miles to Cornell University.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna S Tier Inc
607-257-0800
Amazing location! This peaceful wooded 0.44 acre lot is waiting for you to fall in love with its tranquility & gorgeous views of Brooktondale's rolling hills. Imagine your dream home surrounded by woods or use as a private nature retreat along the seasonal stream! Historic hamlet of Brooktondale is just 3 minutes away, offering a quintessential small-town feel. Brookton's Market is a great place to grab organic groceries, a legendary sandwich or choose from a variety of craft beers, ciders & Finger Lakes wines & enjoy live music! Explore the farmer's market or take part in the activities that the Brooktondale Community Center offers. Ithaca City school district & South Hill elementary. Less than 10 minutes to Ithaca College & Cornell, 5 minutes to closest daycare center & just over 10 minutes to downtown Ithaca. Cottage on property is most likely a teardown. Call your agent or contact listing agent to schedule a showing today!
