The median home value in Cincinnatus, NY is $221,500.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $168,500.
The national median home value is $338,100.
The average price of homes sold in Cincinnatus, NY is $221,500.
Approximately 60.04% of Cincinnatus homes are owned,
compared to 20.08% rented, while
19.89% are vacant.
Cincinnatus real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Cincinnatus real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Courtesy: SVR Realty LLC
607-753-6556
A fine residential / small farm property located at the corner of Maricle and School House Roads in the Cortland County Town Of Freetown. It offers a well-maintained, year 1980, 1,280 s/f, cottage style house, a 26-foot by 32-foot pole barn, and a pond on two tax parcels in a rural setting. The house occupies a 1.0-acre, 100-foot (road frontage) by 418-foot lot. It also has a storage shed. The barn and pond are on a 7.65-acre, 556-foot by 616-foot lot that is contiguous with the house lot. The lot’s dimensions are, respectively, its frontages on Maricle Road and School House Road. Located between Cortland City and the Village Of Marathon, both of which have I-81 exchanges, it is well connected to the world. The house provides on its 1st floor a large living room plus a laundry room with a washer, dryer, and ½ bathroom, and a utility room with a well water tank and a water heater. Also, there is a large family room that is designed as a media room with special lighting and many electric outlets. 2nd floor: A large bedroom, kitchen with a range, refrigerator, and dish washer, large dining room, full bathroom, and an elevated deck that provides a magnificent view across a river valley. 3rd floor: 2 bedrooms plus much storage along the edges due to its A-frame style. A closet at the head of the stairs could, perhaps, be converted into a ½ bathroom. Primary heat is provided by a compact coal burning stove in the living room which can heat the entire house. Secondary heat is from baseboard electric heaters. A radon mitigation system has been installed. The barn has water and electricity. It provides ample storage space for vehicles and farm animals. Outside there are animal pens (the sellers currently have sheep, pigs, and chickens). The 0.15-acre, 15-foot-deep pond is stocked with bass, blue gills, and bullheads, and comes with a pond shed. A 1.25-acre hay field can provide hay or pasture for animals. Note: The 7.65-acre lot is large enough to be subdivided into three residential lots that meet the County’s minimum standard of 2.4 acres per lot. That fact and its substantial frontage on two roads opens the possibility for profitable residential development.
Courtesy: Canaan Realty
315-682-4500
White tail habitat! This spacious 42-acre site offers an ideal option for a seasonal getaway or an excellent hunting experience. With frontage on two roads, rolling topography, and a mostly wooded setting, this location will provide years of outdoor enjoyment or a wonderful site for a new year-round (or seasonal) home. Located across the road from over 1,200 acres of State Lands in the Baker School House State Forest. Come experience what this tranquil country property in lower Central NY has to offer!
Courtesy: Yaman Real Estate
607-753-9644
Welcome to this quaint ranch with 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bath located in the hamlet of Cincinnatus. Great starter home and with some love can become your dream home. 2 car attached garage, carport for extra vehicles, plenty of lawn and a shed/workshop out back. So much to offer, make your appt. today. This property can also be sold with S1575959.
Courtesy: Yaman Real Estate
607-753-9644
Looking for your next commercial project? Welcome to this amazing barn, with so many unique uses for this space. At least 5000+ sq. feet of amazing space. Last use was Stonehedges gift barn! 2-3 floors of useable space. Options are warehouse, mechanical, office space, rentals or even apartment rentals, and so much more. The start of a rental on main floor, work shop in basement, plenty of parking. Make your apt. today to see this incredible commercial space. This property can also be sold with S1575951
Courtesy: Ted Leader Real Estate
315-255-1214
Welcome to your country paradise! Nestled in the serene hills of Chenango County, this enchanting farmhouse offers a peaceful escape from city life. The current owners found their sanctuary here in 2006, lovingly transforming the spacious 2,700 sq. ft. home into a blend of modern comfort and country charm. With five bedrooms and three full baths, it’s perfect for families seeking space and privacy. Outside 213 acres of woods, pastures, and hay fields await, offering prime deer and turkey hunting with enclosed deer blinds and expansive food plots. A 12-stall stable is ready for horses, inviting you to enjoy riding or the peace of nature. The property connects to the Five Stream State Forrest which encompasses over 6000 acres. Plenty of room for hiking, snow shoeing and cross-country skiing, a true outdoorsman paradise. Located minutes from Binghamton, Cortland and Greek Peak Ski resort and one hour from Tioga and Vernon Downs this property offers both tranquility and accessibility. With potential for a bed and breakfast, veterinary facility or income from horse stalls, this property has endless possibilities. Discover the warmth and beauty of a home where dreams truly come true.
Courtesy: Ted Leader Real Estate
315-255-1214
Welcome to your country paradise! Nestled in the serene hills of Chenango County, this enchanting farmhouse offers a peaceful escape from city life. The current owners found their sanctuary here in 2006, lovingly transforming the spacious 2,700 sq. ft. home into a blend of modern comfort and country charm. With five bedrooms and three full baths, it’s perfect for families seeking space and privacy. Outside 213 acres of woods, pastures, and hay fields await, offering prime deer and turkey hunting with enclosed deer blinds and expansive food plots. A 12-stall stable is ready for horses, inviting you to enjoy riding or the peace of nature. The property connects to the Five Stream State Forrest which encompasses over 6000 acres. Plenty of room for hiking, snow shoeing and cross-country skiing, a true outdoorsman paradise. Located minutes from Binghamton, Cortland and Greek Peak Ski resort and one hour from Tioga and Vernon Downs this property offers both tranquility and accessibility. With potential for a bed and breakfast, veterinary facility or income from horse stalls, this property has endless possibilities. Discover the warmth and beauty of a home where dreams truly come true.
Courtesy: Hartnett Realty Solutions
Welcome to this 1,288 sq ft totally renovated, move in ready home offering a generous private lot in a family friendly neighborhood close to school. This 3 bedroom has a totally renovated full bathroom and lower-level family room with fireplace which adds flair to this home, while extra unfinished areas provide opportunities for additional living space. The upper living room has an open concept to dining area with a new patio door opening to the deck and provides views of the private backyard and beautiful pasture. The large kitchen has plenty of counter/cabinet space and Whirlpool stainless steel appliances. This home offers a 2-car garage and storage shed/workshop and additional storage space in the basement and above the garage. Renovation include quality professional craftmanship, making this home move in ready. 300 sq ft have been added to what is on real property, at the time it was built the lower-level family room was not completed, so real property had not included it in their square footage. Call today, this is a gem.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Real Estate
315-682-9500
This 101-acre property is a nature lover's dream, perfect for family vacations or a hunting retreat. Surrounded by farmland, trees, and meadows, the 2-bedroom camp features a modern eat-in kitchen, 1.5 baths, a living room, family room with a bar and a cozy three-season Adirondack-style porch. The camp is finished with luxury wood-look vinyl flooring and knotty pine walls, and includes an open deck with seating and a covered deck. In addition to the camp, the property offers two tool sheds, a bunkhouse for extra lodging and a small chapel that can be repurposed. Outdoor enthusiasts will enjoy the abundant wildlife, with opportunities for deer and turkey hunting and tree stands, hiking and ATV trails. Located on a private, all-season road, this tranquil, seasonal property has year-round potential. It's the perfect escape for those looking to enjoy the peacefulness of nature, just in time for autumn and hunting season. Corresponding MLS#:1572907
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Real Estate
315-682-9500
This 101-acre property is a nature lover's dream, perfect for family vacations or a hunting retreat. Surrounded by farmland, trees, and meadows, the 2-bedroom camp features a modern eat-in kitchen, 1.5 baths, a living room, family room with a bar and a cozy three-season Adirondack-style porch. The camp is finished with luxury wood-look vinyl flooring and knotty pine walls, and includes an open deck with seating and a covered deck. In addition to the camp, the property offers two tool sheds, a bunkhouse for extra lodging and a small chapel that can be repurposed. Outdoor enthusiasts will enjoy the abundant wildlife, with opportunities for deer and turkey hunting and tree stands, hiking and ATV trails. Located on a private, all-season road, this tranquil, seasonal property has year-round potential. It's the perfect escape for those looking to enjoy the peacefulness of nature, just in time for autumn and hunting season. Corresponding MLS# 1572977
Courtesy: Yaman Real Estate
607-753-9644
Unlock a lucrative investment opportunity with this move-in ready multi-family property in the heart of Cincinnatus, 2,328 square feet of versatile living space. Featuring 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, this owner-occupied gem is perfect for those looking to generate rental income while enjoying the comforts of home. The heated workshop adds an extra layer of functionality, making it ideal for hobbyists, while ample tenant parking ensures convenience for all residents. Don’t miss your chance to invest in a property that offers both immediate occupancy and long-term potential—schedule your viewing today and start reaping the rewards!
Courtesy: Hage Real Estate
607-753-6766
Discover this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath ranch that perfectly blends comfort and versatility. With a semi-open floor plan, the inviting space features a cozy eat-in kitchen, beautiful hardwood floors throughout, and a freshly painted interior that feels modern and welcoming. Whether you're looking for a primary residence, a hunting lodge with a workshop, or a potential Airbnb, the possibilities are endless with this property. Don’t miss out on this opportunity—schedule a showing today to explore all that this lovely home has to offer!
Prime hunting land in Chenango County! This property offers 105 acres of wildlife to watch, use for recreation or build your dream house here! Plenty of hardwood and softwood timber, tranquility of a stream that runs through the property, ride your quads and relax! Close to State Land and owner financing available.
Courtesy: Yaman Real Estate
607-753-9644
53.86 acres of level land with road frontage on two roads. Two parcels identify the full acreage of land, tax ID #082800-140-000-0001-005-100-0000 goes with this sale. 23.86 acres goes with the manufactured double wide. This parcel is mainly flat with an amazing pond stocked with bass. The manufactured home has been all remodeled inside and is ready for your family to enjoy. The second parcel is mostly wooded with 948 feet of road frontage on Benson Road. Benson Rd is a seasonal maintained Rd. Come and enjoy the beautiful nature with lots of land to do as you please. New just installed heat pump with cold climate heat pump technology with back up fossil. Outdoor Mini Split and a 20 seer plus raided heat pump. Has a WIFI communicating thermostat with back up propane emergency heat. Central AC and heating included.
Courtesy: Yaman Real Estate
607-753-9644
Great opportunities for an apartment complex, mix-use property or business. Interior will need your vision as it is open mostly to the studs. Walk-in cooler and a commercial kitchen. This building was a retirement community last, but it can be anything you can imagine with the large footprint, ample parking and location.
The epitome of privacy and serenity. Pull off a quiet country road onto a dead end street, maintained by the town but owned on all sides entirely by you. The picturesque driveway flanked by rolling hills and wildflowers leads to the house, barns, and silos. Sun sets out front beyond the firepit. Inside is plenty of space, sunshine, and Amish hardwood floors with a huge kitchen that walks out onto the wrap around deck. Relax here overlooking the swimming pond with a storybook tree trunk bridge to its own island. On the main level is the primary room with en suite bathroom, 2 more bedrooms, and a full bathroom and downstairs is more living space with 2 bedrooms and a bathroom. Three main barns with water and electric, an indoor dirt riding arena, heated workshop, dairy cow set up, livestock quarters, and more. High speed fiber optic internet. Less than an hour from Syracuse and Binghamton with a hardware store, groceries, pizzeria, and golf course a few minutes away. More land available.
Welcome to this stately farmhouse colonial situated on just under 18 acres! The land has been cultivated and can be certified organic for those interested in a hobby farm. The outbuildings are well maintained and include a newer construction 2 car detached garage with a heated workshop and a second level for additional storage and an office. The original barn structure is still in good repair and would be perfect for horses. You'll see the well manicured garden space with potting shed and an additional outbuilding that is perfect for lawn equipment. The acreage has trails, fruit trees, wooded area, and fields. You'll love the view of the rolling hills and valley that surround you.
