The median home value in Fillmore, NY is $190,000.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $107,000.
The national median home value is $338,100.
The average price of homes sold in Fillmore, NY is $190,000.
Approximately 63.53% of Fillmore homes are owned,
compared to 17.62% rented, while
18.85% are vacant.
Fillmore real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Fillmore real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Courtesy: Howard Hanna WNY Inc.
585-496-5230
This Large village home sits on the corner of two quite streets in the village of Fillmore. There is a wood burning stone fireplace (have serviced before use) and some beautiful woodwork in this 4 bedroom 1.5 bath home. The four season room has a small gas stove and an abundance of natural light that looks out over the large backyard.
Courtesy: NORCHAR, LLC
585-244-4444
Welcome to a one-of-a-kind 59-Acre recreational retreat in scenic Fillmore, NY. This property is a haven for outdoor enthusiasts, featuring miles of ATV and hiking trails, exceptional hunting and fishing opportunities, and endless possibilities for year-round recreation and adventure. Current lodging offered onsite includes a seasonal 24’x24’ 2-bedroom loft style cabin featuring an open-concept layout with thoughtful amenities including laundry, full kitchen & appliances, cathedral ceilings, and a 16’x24’ deck with sliding glass doors in the front. A heat source could be added for year round enjoyment. There is a 100Amp service with a 20Gal hot water tank along with a septic system. Utilities connected onsite are Electric & Internet/Cable, with Fiber Internet available at the road for upgrade. The Pond is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bluegill, Catfish, and Minnows. Personal property can include an existing 2011 Greystone 33’ camper with double bunk rooms and two restrooms. Additionally, a 2009 Hampton Crossroads 38’ camper featuring 2 beds and 1 bathroom. In past years this site has produced the owners income from AirBnb rentals and could offer 5-10x the income in coming seasons. The property is located only 15min from Letchworth State Park, 20min from the Swain Ski Resort, and 22min from Rushford Lake to name a few nearby attractions. The property is unencumbered by zoning codes leaving a new owner with the ability to dream up and build just about anything on site. Whether you’re seeking a family getaway, income producing short-term rental campsite, or a private paradise to get in touch with nature, this property is packed with possibilities.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna WNY Inc.
585-496-5230
For Sale: 36 Acres of Diverse Land - Ideal for Your Next Venture! Discover the perfect balance of nature and opportunity with this expansive 36-acre property. Featuring a mix of wooded areas, flat terrain, and rolling hills, this land offers endless potential for a variety of uses—whether you're looking to build your dream home, develop a private retreat, or start a recreational business. Key Features: 37 Acres of versatile land—perfect for building, hunting, farming, or recreation. Wooded Areas provide privacy, shade, and a habitat for wildlife. Flat Land ideal for farming, gardening, or building your perfect home. Rolling Hills add a scenic touch and offer beautiful views. Abundant outdoor activities such as hiking, hunting, or horseback riding. Peaceful, rural setting, yet close to Fillmore and Nunda. Property is only 13 miles from Letchworth State Park, the Grand Canyon of the east! This property is a rare find! ***Property is part of a larger parcel that includes a home. The residence is not for sale, a new survey will be available. Taxes listed reflect entire property including the house and the additional 2 acres. Lot will be reassessed.
Courtesy: NextHome Brixwood
585-204-0612
Two bedroom one bathroom house for sale in Fillmore. Located near school on primary road. Property is being sold as-is.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna WNY Inc.
585-496-5230
Located on 1.50 acres this 3 bedroom, 1 bath ranch is being offered with 2 additional parcels for a total of approx.4.05 acres. The home has been proudly maintained over the years. The large 26'X 14' living room features a blue stone fireplace. The kitchen and dining rooms boost hardwood floors. Enter the home through the '8'x17' breezeway which will take you to either the 2-car attached garage or directly into the dining. You'll find plenty of storage room in either the full basement or large attic. Entertain or just relax on the large open deck. The property is supplied water via a deeded easement with the neighbor.
Courtesy: High Falls Sotheby's International
585-623-1500
This 33+ acre farmhouse on the Genesee River offers a blend of modern updates and timeless charm. The 4-bedroom, 1.5-bath home was completely gutted and redone down to the studs in 2005, while preserving its original character. Situated on 4 acres, this property provides greenery and wooded areas—ideal for hunters or trail riders. The river is perfect for fishing, kayaking, canoeing, paddle boating, and swimming. This home, held by the same family for generations, is now ready for a new owner to cherish and care for it. It can serve as a great seasonal getaway or be transformed into your full-time residence. The screened-in porch off the living room offers scenic views of the surrounding wildlife and trees. The updated kitchen features a vintage 1940s-style refrigerator, a butler's pantry, and a farmhouse sink. Two spacious living areas provide plenty of room for entertaining. With 2 bedrooms and 1.5 baths downstairs and 2 additional bedrooms upstairs, this property offers plenty of space for family and guests. Close to Letchworth State Park, Houghton College, and other amenities. The updated 2,200 sqft includes the renovated upstairs. Delayed negotiations on 9/23/24 at 12:00 PM.
Courtesy: Brixwood LLC
585-204-2182
This unique and versatile property offers an exceptional investment opportunity. Situated on Route 19 entering Fillmore, the property includes a motel, single-family residence, and restaurant building situated above the banks of the Genesee River. The motel offers 11 units, comprising eight double rooms and three single rooms, primarily accommodating short—to medium-term tenants. Units 1 through 6 could be renovated to include kitchenettes, enabling a seamless transition into longer-term rentals for increased income opportunities. The single-family residence is perfect for an owner-operator or as an additional rental unit. The restaurant could be converted into an office space, retail shop, medical office, or additional housing unit, providing flexibility for various business or residential ventures. Ample on-site parking accommodates both guests and customers. With its strategic location on Route 19, diverse usage options, and riverfront charm, this property is a rare find for investors seeking to capitalize on mixed-use potential. Don’t miss this incredible opportunity to own a multi-faceted property in a prime location!
Courtesy: Landquest Inc.
607.844.9690
Welcome to this new constructed country home with barn on 8 acres located in Centerville NY, Allegany County. The home includes a large washroom and mudroom that leads to a bright open-concept kitchen and dining area complete with ample cupboard space and a large pantry. The gorgeous family room is adorned with several windows allowing natural light to flood in. The main level also includes a full bath, a sizable bedroom, and propane lighting throughout. Upstairs you will find a large area suitable for additional bedrooms, and water and sewage lines already in place for a bathroom. The walk-up attic offers storage or office potential. The basement features Fox poured and insulated walls making it easy to finish, and there is a large root cellar. The home includes water and septic, and is primed for solar power. Enjoy the spacious wrap-around porch with Gorilla Composite decking. The acreage includes wooded areas, fenced pastures, and a hay field. This property is conveniently located near state land, Houghton College, and Rushford Lake. Motivated seller.
Courtesy: Landquest Inc.
607.844.9690
This 20.7 acres is a rare investment property located in Centerville NY, Allegany County. The acreage consists of approximately 15 acres of pure gravel. Several test holes have been dug at approximately 12 feet deep. This is an ideal property for a construction company to mine gravel for many years. The remaining acreage is currently a horse pasture. A crystal clear spring flows 24 hours a day. Build your new home and enjoy the gorgeous valley views! Motivated seller.
