The median home value in Monticello, NY is $324,500.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $254,500.
The national median home value is $338,100.
The average price of homes sold in Monticello, NY is $324,500.
Approximately 25.18% of Monticello homes are owned,
compared to 55.12% rented, while
19.7% are vacant.
Monticello real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Monticello real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
31 Summit Avenue in Monticello, NY, is a stunning property that truly embodies the essence of comfortable living! This beautifully renovated 1,900 sq ft Cape Cod home radiates charm and warmth from the moment you step inside. As you enter, you are greeted by a meticulously updated kitchen, boasting gleaming white cabinetry, two convenient sinks, and ample counter space for culinary creations. The kitchen seamlessly flows into a delightful dining room, which is awash with natural light pouring in through large windows, creating an inviting atmosphere for family meals or entertaining guests. The spacious living room is designed for relaxation, featuring elegant tiled floors and an adjacent half bath for added convenience. It serves as the perfect gathering spot for friends and family, whether it's a cozy night in or a lively get-together. Venture to the upper level, where you'll find four thoughtfully designed bedrooms, each providing a serene retreat with plenty of space for rest and privacy. Two full baths on this level ensure that everyone has their own space for morning routines or unwinding after a long day. Step outside to the gated backyard, a wonderful oasis for children to run, play, and explore safely. The large shed offers a perfect solution for additional storage or workspace, making it ideal for gardening tools or hobbies. This home is an absolute gem that combines comfort, style, and practicality. Don’t let this incredible opportunity slip away before it’s gone!
16 Washington Street in Monticello presents an exceptional opportunity to own a beautifully renovated Cape Cod home, offering a spacious 2,100 square feet of luxurious living. Nestled in a delightful neighborhood, this property is conveniently located just steps from a variety of shops, making everyday errands easy and enjoyable. With five generously sized bedrooms and four well-appointed bathrooms, this home ensures ample space for both relaxation and privacy. The thoughtfully designed kitchen and inviting dining room create the perfect environment for hosting gatherings or enjoying daily meals with family and friends. This property truly combines style, comfort, and convenience, making it a remarkable choice for anyone seeking a high-quality home with endless potential. Don't let this incredible opportunity pass you by!
Pleasant ranch home beautifully set on 2.2 Acres at the end of a cul-de-sac. This is a 3 Bedroom - 2 bath home with hardwood floors - primary suite - warm and cozy living room with fireplace and Eat in kitchen/Dining Room - with a full unfinished basement with 9' high ceilincs. Radiant heated floors in the main level and the basement floors. Relax on your covered rocking chair front porch which offers privacy and quiet. Shingled roof is almost new. So many features including gererac generator, Garden irregation system, paved driveway and two storage sheds. For the handy person there is a very nice workshop with electric to get lost in for hours with plenty of tool storage. The property is just beautiful at the end of a culdesac giving you so much privacy surrounded by stone walls and beautiful open fields. For the RV enthusiast, there is a RV hookup with water and electric and an RV dump station.
Welcome to 16 Sunset Dr, a relatively new construction, turnkey bi-level home on a 1.27-acre lot in a quiet neighborhood. This property features a gorgeous, bright, airy kitchen with stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and an abundance of cabinetry complimented by warm ambient lighting. The open-floor concept has soaring vaulted ceilings with recessed lighting (throughout) and combines the formal dining and living area with a fireplace to set a cozy atmosphere. The primary bedroom has a full contemporary bathroom with his and her closets, each full bath stylish with trendy touches. Great for commuters, this property is only 5 minutes from Highway 17, roughly 90 minutes north of NYC, and close to many local amenities like Kartrite Indoor Water Park, Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, and Resorts World Casino. Call today for a private showing!
YOUR MONTICELLO RETREAT IS HERE! This beautiful country home offers the perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Nestled on a park-like half acre lot, you will have peace and privacy. Enter the home to a huge formal dining room, complete with beautiful picture windows and fireplace. Next, you’ll find the beautiful open concept living room and kitchen area. The modern kitchen has timeless white shaker cabinets, sleek quartz countertops, and offers 3 sinks a stove and a 2nd cooktop . Off the kitchen you’ll find a powder room with laundry area, a second laundry station with closet, and an attractive wash sink. From the kitchen, there are multiple French doors to access the beautiful back porch or open to offer a cool summer breeze. The porch spans the length of the house, perfect for large gatherings. This is an ideal space to host your next sukkot. You also have access to a screened-in sunroom, a bonus area that can be used as a den, reading room, or more. This room leads to the expansive two-car garage. The first floor also offers a large primary bedroom with dual closets and a generous private bath. This space is connected to a second bedroom, ideal for a nursery or office. A lovely wooden staircase, accented by attractive skylights, leads you to the 2nd floor. This level has 4 beautiful bedrooms, ranging in size from massive to cozy, offering sleep options for a variety of guests. You will also find a spacious and modern full bath with a linen closet and a wash sink in the hallway. Completing the home’s interior is a large basement. This property is found in the perfect Catskills location, with quick access to nature as well as the convenience of highways, restaurants, and shops nearby. Take advantage of low taxes. A seller financing may be available for qualified buyers. Sale is as-is. With so much to offer, it's time to book your showing and plan your next escape!
Introducing an exceptional investment opportunity at 39-41 Hillside Ave in Monticello, designed for savvy investors and forward-thinking developers alike! This remarkable property boasts 7 units, with 6 of these units undergoing extensive and stylish renovations in 2024, ensuring they meet the contemporary demands of today's renters. These upgraded units are currently generating a robust annual rental income of $82,764, showcasing not only the property's immediate profitability but also its potential for future growth. In addition to the impressive rental income and value-add opportunity, there’s an exciting option to acquire the neighboring lot for just $350,000! This parcel holds the potential for constructing 7 condos on these lots, paving the way for substantial future returns in a growing area. Monticello is on an upward trajectory, making this the perfect moment to invest in a property with both immediate cash flow and long-term appreciation potential. The combination of a strong rental market, strategic location, and the possibility of expansion makes this property a standout choice for those looking to make a meaningful impact in the Monticello real estate landscape. Don't miss out on this lucrative opportunity—seize the chance to invest in your future today!
Presenting a fantastic opportunity at 43 Hillside Ave, Monticello! This remarkable property features four newly renovated units, completed in 2024, offering modern living spaces that are ready to generate income. With a projected rental income of $46,800, this is a turn-key investment that you won't want to miss. Additionally, one of the units will be delivered vacant, presenting a perfect opportunity for owner-occupancy or for a targeted rental strategy. The potential doesn’t stop there! This property can be purchased together with MLS# 811928, giving you the chance to expand your investment portfolio further by building 7 condos. Don’t miss out on this prime development opportunity in a thriving area. Act now to secure your place in Monticello's growing real estate market!
Welcome to the perfect lakeside haven, nestled in a quiet neighborhood at the end of a dead-end road on the stunning shores of Swinging Bridge Reservoir—the largest motorboat lake in the Sullivan Catskills. This spacious 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom home offers a serene escape with expansive indoor and outdoor spaces designed for gatherings, entertaining, or peaceful relaxation. Step inside to find cathedral ceilings, two cozy indoor fireplaces, and two levels of inviting living areas that seamlessly blend comfort and style. The well-appointed kitchen, dining area, and upper and lower living rooms flow effortlessly into breathtaking outdoor spaces. A highlight of the property is the impressive three-level deck that stretches from the house to the private dock, offering unparalleled views and easy access to the lake. Outside, soak in the hot tub as you take in the tranquility of the lake’s natural beauty, or gather with friends and family in ample outdoor entertaining areas. For an added touch of fun and versatility, the property includes a detached cabin complete with two bunk beds (each with a trundle), a pool table, and an arcade game—perfect as a guest retreat, party cave, or your very own lakeside clubhouse. Situated near the top attractions of the Sullivan Catskills, this home offers the ultimate combination of privacy and convenience, all with the freedom to personalize and enjoy—no HOA fees required. With approximately 3,126 sq. ft. of finished living space (including the basement and cabin), this property is more than just a home; it’s a destination. Bonus: This property boasts an impressive short-term rental history, making it an exceptional investment opportunity.Don’t miss the chance to own this extraordinary lakefront property. Schedule your private tour today and experience the ultimate lakeside lifestyle!
Charming Colonial Home in Sckett Lake Estates Welcome to your dream home in the picturesque Sckett Lake Estates! This beautifully maintained colonial residence boasts 4 spacious bedrooms and 2.5 baths, making it perfect for families or those who love to entertain. This is the larger unit and 3376 sq. ft. As you enter the home, you'll be greeted by a warm and inviting living space that features a well-appointed kitchen. The kitchen seamlessly flows into the dining room, creating an open and airy atmosphere perfect for gatherings and dinner parties. Adjacent to the dining area is a cozy entertainment room where you can relax after a long day or enjoy movie nights with loved ones. On the main floor, you'll also find an office space—perfect for remote work or study sessions—along with easy access to the 1-car garage for added convenience. Also a formal living room. Upstairs, retreat to your serene primary bedroom suite featuring ample closet space and en-suite bathroom amenities. The additional bedrooms are generously sized, providing comfort and privacy for family members or guests. Enjoy exclusive lake rights to this stunning motor boat lake a short away from your door; whether it's fishing, swimming, or boating activities you're after, this location has it all! With its blend of classic charm and modern amenities, along with ample living spaces both inside and out, this colonial home offers everything you need. Don’t miss your chance to make it yours! This would make a great primary or vacation home. Close to shopping, casino, bethel performing arts center, forestburgh playhouse.
Duplex Renovated Bungalow in a gated colony for Sale! Located in a beautiful community, this fully renovated duplex bungalow offers access to a range of fantastic amenities. Enjoy a spacious, well-maintained home surrounded by lush grounds and exceptional communal facilities. Community Features: - Pool - Community house - Day camp - Sauna - Expansive grounds and more This is a rare opportunity to own in a vibrant, family-friendly community with everything you need for comfortable living.
Prime Retail Opportunity in Desirable Location! Presenting 141 NY-17B, a charming retail space nestled in the heart of Monticello, NY. This former storefront boasts excellent visibility and accessibility, making it an ideal location for a variety of retail or service-based businesses. - Ideal for retail, office, or service-based businesses - Ample parking and easy accessibility - Prime location near Monticello Casino and surrounding shopping and dining options Don't miss this exceptional opportunity to establish your business in a thriving commercial corridor. Contact us today to schedule a viewing!
Exceptional Commercial Restaurant Opportunity Presenting 145 State Route 17B, a remarkable commercial restaurant property nestled in the heart of Monticello, NY. This outstanding offering boasts an expansive 4,000 sq. ft. first floor, complemented by a spacious 3,000 sq. ft. basement, ideal for ballrooms, kitchens, and various entertainment options. The property's crowning glory is its substantial 5,000 sq. ft. parking area, providing ample space for patrons and staff. Strategically situated on a bustling main road, this prime location offers unparalleled visibility, accessibility, and foot traffic. The renowned Monticello Casino is mere moments away, while a plethora of shopping and dining options surrounds the property. With its exceptional size, prime location, and surrounding amenities, this property presents a unique opportunity for savvy investors, restaurateurs, and entrepreneurs to capitalize on the thriving local economy. While some renovations are necessary to unlock its full potential, the possibilities for this phenomenal property are endless. Key Features: - 4,000 sq. ft. first floor - 3,000 sq. ft. basement - 5,000 sq. ft. parking area - Prime main road location - Close proximity to Monticello Casino - Surrounding shopping and dining options Don't miss this rare chance to acquire a exceptional commercial restaurant property in a prime location. Contact us today to schedule a viewing and unlock the full potential of 145 State Route 17B! Adjacent property also available for purchase. Buying both properties together may qualify for a discounted price. Ask for details.
Welcome to this stunning new construction colonial at 35 Woodcliff Avenue in Monticello! Nestled in a beautiful neighborhood, this impressive property boasts a generous 3,156 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space. The oversized patio invites you to enjoy outdoor gatherings and relaxation in your own backyard sanctuary. Step inside to discover a beautifully appointed kitchen that’s perfect for culinary enthusiasts and entertaining. The home is adorned with multiple spotlights, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere throughout. The dining room, with its soaring 12 ft ceilings, adds a touch of elegance to your dining experiences. With 5 spacious bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms, there’s plenty of room for family and guests to feel comfortable and at home. This residence is a perfect blend of style, space, and modern comfort in a picturesque setting. Don’t miss the opportunity to make this exceptional property your own!
Welcome to 3 Madeline Ln, Monticello, NY 12701—a newly renovated, spacious home designed for modern living and perfect for getaways or year-round comfort! Step into this inviting home through a bright foyer that opens into a warm and welcoming open-concept living and dining area. Highlighted by stunning bay windows, this space is bathed in natural light, creating a cozy and relaxing atmosphere perfect for gatherings or everyday living. The kitchen is a standout feature, beautifully updated with modern finishes, sleek countertops, and ample cabinetry. Whether you’re preparing a casual family dinner or hosting friends, this kitchen combines functionality with style. This home offers four comfortable bedrooms, including a serene master suite with its own private bathroom and walk-in closet. The additional bedrooms are well-sized and share a full, recently renovated bathroom. Just three steps down from the main level, you’ll find the fourth bedroom, conveniently located near an additional full bathroom, making it ideal for guests or added privacy. Adding to the charm is the versatile lower-level space, featuring a large family room perfect for lounging, movie nights, or entertaining. This level also includes a convenient laundry room, ensuring that daily tasks are effortless and accessible. A hidden gem of this property is the impressive 2,000 sq ft full walkout basement with high ceilings and windows, offering immense potential for additional living space, a home gym, or anything your imagination desires. The outdoor space is equally impressive. A generously sized porch offers the perfect spot to relax with your morning coffee, host barbecues, or simply take in the tranquil surroundings. The expansive yard provides endless possibilities for outdoor activities, gardening, or creating cherished memories. Situated on a quiet street in Monticello, this home is in mint condition, having been recently updated throughout. Offering the perfect combination of modern updates, thoughtful design, and a peaceful location, it’s ideal whether you’re seeking a retreat or a full-time residence. Don’t miss this incredible opportunity—schedule your showing today and make this charming home yours!
Lake Access Corner Lot in Sackett Lake. This 3 bed 3 bath bi-level is immaculately maintained. Bedrooms, living space, kitchen, and 2 bathrooms centrally located on the first floor. Additional areas for entertainment include a full finished basement, spacious back deck and inground pool area. Complete with a two-car attached garage with entry through the full basement.
This highly visible property is seen off Route 17 just before Exit 107 going west bound. There are two parcels involved with the sale. One is 2.22 acres and is Zoned Commercial Industrial and is used for an impound and storage lot. The second lot is 1.23 acres and is Zoned Highway Commercial. On this lot there are two buildings a four bay garage that is rented for $1,500/month plus utilities and is approved for Motor Vehicle repairs, towing and storage. The second building is a two bedroom house which is rented for $1,000/month plus utilities. Seller owns a sign on the highway which is rented for $600/month. Great property for an investor. Come take a look.
Unleash your creativity on this exceptional real estate offering! This unique listing features two properties sold together, with plans to be divided into four spacious lots. Envision building three luxurious homes, each with a generous footprint of 10,000 sq ft per floor, ideal for families seeking elegance and comfort. Additionally, the opportunity exists to construct a magnificent 20,000 sq ft home per floor, providing unmatched space for those desiring an extraordinary lifestyle. Situated in the desirable Monticello area, this land offers a harmonious blend of privacy and accessibility. Enjoy the tranquility of the surroundings while remaining close to local amenities and recreational activities. This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to create a thriving neighborhood or your dream estate in a location that is sure to appreciate in value. Don’t miss out—contact us today to explore the incredible possibilities that await you on Rock Ridge Drive!
Unleash your creativity on this exceptional real estate offering! This unique listing features two properties sold together, with plans to be divided into four spacious lots. Envision building three luxurious homes, each with a generous footprint of 10,000 sq ft per floor, ideal for families seeking elegance and comfort. Additionally, the opportunity exists to construct a magnificent 20,000 sq ft home per floor, providing unmatched space for those desiring an extraordinary lifestyle. Situated in the desirable Monticello area, this land offers a harmonious blend of privacy and accessibility. Enjoy the tranquility of the surroundings while remaining close to local amenities and recreational activities. This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to create a thriving neighborhood or your dream estate in a location that is sure to appreciate in value. Don’t miss out—contact us today to explore the incredible possibilities that await you on Rock Ridge Drive!
Sackett Lake Estates is a build ready community. This listing is for 1 of 80 available lots that are build ready. The subdivision is only 4 miles from Monticello. The community roads have been dedicated. Water, Sewer, Electric and Phone services have been brought to each lot. Build your own dream home. Here is the perfect opportunity to build a community of single family homes and community structures. Seller will consider bulk sales. Access to Sackett Lake is deeded to each lot.
Amazing fix and flip opportunity. Surrounded by 6 acres of towering trees and luscious greenery, this home comes with a poured concrete in-ground pool, perfect for cooling off during the summer. Close to all Sullivan county has to offer like The Monticello Motor Club, Resorts World Catskills Casino, Holiday Mountain Ski Area & Fun Park, Kartrite Indoor Water Park, Swinging Bridge Reservoir and White Lake. Only 90 miles from the GWB.
Sackett Lake Estates is a build ready community. This listing is for 1 of 80 available lots that are build ready. The subdivision is only 4 miles from Monticello. The community roads have been dedicated. Water, Sewer, Electric and Phone service has been brought to each lot. Build your own dream home. Here is the perfect opportunity to build a community of single family homes and community structures. Seller will consider bulk sales. Access to Sackett Lake is deeded to each lot.
Grab the opportunity to own this sprawling 5 acre property In this prime Catskills location with services year-round, just 2 miles from exit 107 off Rt 17 across the HCS Resort (formally Raleigh hotel) next to Venetian Villas. Restore the Mountain Pine Motel to it’s former charm, 3,700 sq. ft. per floor, 1st floor has small indoor pool, library and 9 bathrooms. Also has a commercial kitchen, 3 large rooms app. 16' X 22' and 3 regular rooms. 2nd floor has 14 rooms each room includes a full bath and small kitchenette, with outdoor pool. Property backs up to Kiamesha Creek with a beautiful relaxing waterfall. Was approved for an extension of additional 14 suites in the past. Currently owned by a congregation, most recently used as a school. Perfect for camps/motel. Create your own dream haven or possibly subdivide/develop.. currently tax exempt.
Brand-New Construction in Monticello, NY! Step into your dream home, where contemporary design seamlessly blends with practical living. As you step inside, you’re greeted by an open-concept kitchen and living room, perfect for entertaining family and friends. The chef’s kitchen boasts an oversized island, premium finishes, and hardwood floors that flow seamlessly throughout the home. The first floor includes a versatile home office that can double as a guest room, offering the flexibility you need. Upstairs, you’ll find 3 spacious bedrooms and 3 full baths, including a luxurious primary suite with an en suite bath and a large walk-in closet. This home is equipped with central heat and AC for year-round comfort. Plus, the full walkout basement offers endless possibilities—a potential mother-in-law suite, recreation space, or additional storage. Step outside to the oversized deck, your private oasis for summer barbecues, stargazing, and making lasting memories. Don’t miss this incredible opportunity! Schedule your private tour today and make this house your forever home. Call now!
This property is a spacious, partially constructed house located in a desirable neighborhood. The initial construction phase has been initiated by the seller, laying the groundwork for a beautiful home. However, it's still a work in progress and requires additional construction to complete. This presents a unique opportunity for the new owner to customize and finish the house according to their personal taste and preferences. In addition, this can be a great fix-and-flip opportunity! Don't miss this one!
Commercial - Retail Building located in the heart of the Village in Monticello. This Retail building is in great condition, with a great location - lots of parking and great visibility!! BUILDING FOR SALE ONLY . . . 100% occupied.