The median home value in Oneonta, NY is $197,500.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $132,500.
The national median home value is $219,700.
The average price of homes sold in Oneonta, NY is $197,500.
Approximately 38.84% of Oneonta homes are owned,
compared to 45.51% rented, while
15.66% are vacant.
Oneonta real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Oneonta real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Courtesy: Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties
607-431-2540
DIAMOND IN THE ROUGH! This is the time to transform this architecturally appealing three-family home, ideally situated between SUNY Oneonta, Hartwick College, and vibrant downtown Oneonta, into the showplace it deserves to be! Exterior features include a wrap-around porch with sweeping views, vinyl siding, asphalt shingle roof, replacement windows, a detached garage, and a metal exterior fire escape. Currently, the interior has three separate three-bedroom apartments. The first and second floors have been gutted to the studs, providing a blank canvas for customization. The third-floor apartment has the potential for owner-occupancy during renovation. All renovation plans must be code-compliant. The full basement is solid with a natural gas boiler, three newer gas hot water heaters, and separate electric meters. This property offers endless possibilities for investors, contractors, and visionaries! It enjoys a prime location with easy access to amenities, transportation, and educational institutions.
Courtesy: Oneonta Realty, LLC
607-441-7312
Newly renovated building offers great commercial space on first floor and four apartments up. Two 1-bedroom apartments and two 2-bedroom apartments. All units have laundry, some off-street parking behind building. Great rental history.
Courtesy: eXp Realty, LLC
631-926-7909
Welcome to 834 Southside Dr...an immaculately updated & maintained, Ranch-style home, on 1/2 an acre, in the Oneonta School District. This home is move-in ready & very conveniently located (5 minutes from I-88 & seconds from all State Route 23 has to offer). Outside is a multi-car driveway leading to an extended (43' x 19') garage, beautifully landscaped & open backyard and a recently (2023) remodeled, oversized (25' x 16') deck. Inside, all on the first floor, you'll find a completely updated eat-in kitchen with granite countertops, new cabinets and stainless steel appliances. Beyond that is an inviting living room with a wood burning fireplace, all three bedrooms and a full bathroom. The basement is partially finished and open for redefinition. This property and the home are beautiful and ready for new memories to be made. Schedule a showing today.
Courtesy: Coldwell Banker Timberland Properties
607-746-7400
This Could Be Your Storybook Cottage on 14+ Beautiful Acres With A Pond The home welcomes you with a charming stone garage and an updated eat-in-kitchen, complete with rich custom built hickory cabinets and a large hickory bench perfect for casual dining at the countertop peninsula. The laundry is conveniently located in the kitchen for ease of living. Both first-floor bedrooms feature private baths, offering comfort and privacy. Large living room with floor to ceiling stone fireplace and vaulted ceilings is a great place to cozy up and watch a movie! Upstairs, the flexible space could serve as your third bedroom or a cozy office with direct access to a private deck, where you can sit and enjoy your surroundings. The land is a true oasis, with a tranquil pond, a fenced-in garden area for your green thumb, a horse barn with 2 stalls and a paddock ready for your horses or even a donkey or two. The land is comprised of two parcels and has a beautiful upper meadow! Come walk the land, see the cottage and fall in love
Courtesy: Revolution Real Estate
585-653-7700
Morningside heights neighborhood 3 bedroom 2 bath ranch available!!This home is set well back from the street and has large half acre parcel. Enter the home through large mudroom with access to attached 2 car garage and back yard. From there you enter the home to a large inviting sun room/ family room with gas stove, tongue and groove pine walls and vaulted ceiling. Kitchen is wide open with passthrough to sunroom, island with chairs and large opening connecting it to dining room. Large formal living room is connected to dinning room and kitchen giving it a very open feel. Laundry is on first floor and master bedroom has en suite bathroom. Full basement has 2 additional finished bonus/rec rooms adding roughly 225 Sf not included in taxable sf. The backyard has entertaining spaces off the sunroom and through breezeway, a storage shed and large playset.
Courtesy: Benson Agency Real Estate LLC
607-432-4391
Business block opportunity! Positioned nicely across the street from the center square of downtown known as Muller Plaza. Six figure cash-flow can be yours at this versatile downtown building! Long-time first floor eatery anchors the address, and four upscale three bedroom apartments on second and third floors provide an additional 12 beds of income! Easy care building- just manage your income opportunity! On-site laundry is provided for residential tenants. Do not miss this opportunity to grow your net income steadily year by year!
Courtesy: Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties
607-431-2540
Step into this spacious four+ bedroom, three-bathroom home, perfectly positioned in one of Oneonta’s most desirable neighborhoods. With stunning views and a prime location just minutes from SUNY Oneonta and Hartwick Colleges, this residence offers both convenience and tranquility. The home features hardwood floors throughout, wood-burning fireplace, a newer roof, and many thoughtful upgrades. The fully finished lower level offers bonus rooms perfect for additional bedrooms, offices, or game rooms. There is also a large laundry room, an attached two-car garage, and a basement workshop area. Outside, you will find a covered patio which is ideal for entertaining, a large, private back yard, and a newly paved driveway. Located close to countless amenities, including restaurants, shopping, and entertainment, this home offers convenience and comfort in one ideal package. Whether you're looking for nearby dining options, local shops, or a night out, everything you need is just minutes away Don’t miss the opportunity to call this beautiful property your home!
Courtesy: Bliss Realty LLC
607-547-2510
Very Nice +/-1.34 ac building lot well off the road. Remainder wooded. Easy commute to Oneonta or Cooperstown
Courtesy: Benson Agency Real Estate LLC
607-432-4391
PRIME LOCATION!!! Sitting just minutes from Oneonta High School, SUNY Oneonta, Hartwick College, & Downtown Oneonta - exterior features include an exterior two car garage w/electric & private back area on just under a half acre. Inside you will find a kitchen w/updated appliances, formal dining room, large living room, full bath, two good sized bedrooms, and a family room w/woodstove. To top it all off there is a RADON SYSTEM, A/C, NEW OIL TANK, UPDATED ELECTRIC, & NEWER ROOF!!! Come make this house your own at an affordable price ... This is one you won't want to miss! Don't hesitate!!!
Courtesy: Coldwell Banker Timberland Properties
607-604-4394
Welcome to 2854 Rathbun Hill Rd, offering a picturesque country setting, serene privacy and beautiful surroundings; perfect for those seeking a tranquil lifestyle without sacrificing convenience. Property Highlights: • Spacious Living: Featuring 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, this home offers ample space for relaxation and entertaining. • Cozy Atmosphere: Enjoy the warmth of 2 wood-burning stoves as well as a pellet stove in the living room, ideal for those chilly upstate evenings. • Outdoor Beauty: Situated on a generous lot, the property boasts lush greenery, trees, and ample room for gardening or outdoor activities. • Additional Features: A large barn, spacious upstairs bedroom studio, and a porch overlooking the peaceful landscape. • Location: Conveniently located just 10 minutes Oneonta, where you’ll find shopping, dining, and entertainment, yet far enough to enjoy the quiet of country living. Whether you’re looking for a full-time residence or a weekend getaway, this property is the perfect blend of comfort, charm, and convenience. Schedule your private showing today!
Courtesy: Oneonta Realty LLC
607-433-2873
This fully rented two-unit home with solid rental history could be the investment property of your dreams! Both apartments are large with completely separate utilities. Two gas furnaces, two water heaters, two electric meters. Downstairs has 3 spacious bedrooms, 1 bath with an eat-in kitchen and large living room. Upstairs is 2 bedrooms, 1 bath with a separate dining area and mudroom entrance. Both apartments are bright with plenty of natural light. There is a good amount of off-street parking behind the house. Close to schools, the bus line, and downtown. Start making money right away with this investment! Don't miss out!
Courtesy: The Greene Realty Group
860-560-1006
Just minutes away from Cooperstown Baseball All-Star Village and a short drive to the Baseball Hall of Fame, Soccer Hall of Fame and Cooperstown Dream Park. Your chance to own a very unique/special, subdivided, scalable, BASEBALL RENTAL/residential one of a kind property is now available! First time on the market in over 30 years, this multi-structure dual lot property includes a 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath home that has been extensively remodeled over the last few years. This property offers a 2 story, 2 car garage with basement storage and potential office/bunk house above. Recently added a new drainage, updated electrical, new interior and exterior paint and roof replaced 2014. The barn also boasts a new roof, new foundation, drainage system, updated electrical, ramp, and exterior paint. Looking for a business opportunity? The adjacent second lot includes an updated well, electricity access, and enough space to add multiple structures, cabins, or SFR. Property was upgraded for rental purposes. Projected Annual Rental Income $70,000+ COMES WITH FULL BASEBALL RENTAL CAMP BUSINESS PLAN/DECK. Taxes and Assessment include the additional lot.
Courtesy: Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties
607-431-2540
Must-See Gem in Oneonta, NY! Discover this stunning 3-bedroom, 2 full bath home in Oneonta, NY, where comfort meets convenience! This property checks all the boxes, offering everything you need for easy, enjoyable living. Featuring a single-level layout, this home provides the perfect blend of space and functionality. Each of the three generously sized bedrooms ensures plenty of room for family, guests, or a home office. The open and airy living spaces are designed to flow seamlessly, making both daily life and entertaining a breeze. With a one-car attached garage, a two-car detached garage and a storage shed, you have plenty of storage and workshop space. Recent upgrades, including a new roof (2023) and new electric panel (2024), provide peace of mind and ensure this home is move-in ready. Step outside to your own private, park-like oasis! The property sits on over an acre of flat land, offering a serene and secluded setting. The beautifully designed rear deck is perfect for hosting gatherings, while the above-ground pool adds a splash of fun for those warm summer days. Come see all that this home has to offer and schedule your private showing today!
Courtesy: Oneonta Realty, LLC
607-441-7312
This RANCH home is located in a desirable development in the TOWN OF ONEONTA. BUILT IN 2019 this home sits on almost .25 ACRES featuring and OPEN FLOOR PLAN with a beautiful kitchen, KITCHEN ISLAND and a BREAKFAST BAR. Dining room is open to the kitchen and living room. Living room is spacious with plenty of natural light. The primary bedroom has a private, spacious bathroom and a large WALK IN CLOSET. The other two bedrooms are spacious with nice closets as well. LAUNDRY ROOM is on the FIRST FLOOR with a slop sink and storage. The full basement could be finished into a huge rec room or home theatre. Outside you will find a nice size DECK to relax and take in the mountain VIEWS. There is a private YARD as well. The TWO CAR ATTACHED GARAGE has ELECTRIC DOOR OPENERS and there is a PAVED DRIVEWAY. RADON SYSTEM has been installed. There is CENTRAL AIR CONDITIONING as well and natural gas heating. Greater Plains Elementary school is close by and its a short drive to downtown Oneonta, and Interstate 88 for commuting. This home is MOVE IN READY with a great layout. Don't hesitate, schedule your private showing today. This one won't last long!
Courtesy: Dudley Realty Inc
607-431-8181
This charming single-family house offers more than just a place to live! The main house contains 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms with wood flooring and tile throughout. One bedroom, bathroom, living room and eat in kitchen downstairs, two bedrooms and a bathroom upstairs. Design your own kitchen! No appliances, but the house is wide open to create your perfect space. Need a dedicated office space? The property includes a small versatile office building perfect for remote work, a creative studio, or a home business. This space has a cozy cabin feel, with a half bath and has plumbing and electrical to create a small kitchen and/or full bath. The two story garage offers ample room for your vehicles or a workshop in the two bays, with a spacious upper level. Owner is willing to be flexible on subdividing the parcel with neighboring property if the buyer only wants the house, office, more parking, and/or garage. Don’t miss out on this unique opportunity—schedule a tour today and see how you can turn this property into your new sanctuary! Seller is a licensed real estate agent.
Courtesy: Oneonta Realty LLC
607-433-2873
Stunning home combining quintessential coziness with modern luxury. Set in a bright clearing on a 2+ acre wooded plot, this vibrant home has kept its historic charm while enjoying a staggering number of high-end renovations & updates. Including: NEW Roof & Windows, NEW exterior & interior paint, NEW appliances, Renovated Kitchen & Baths, Re-engineered Driveway, NEW Deck & Patio, plus breathtaking landscaping. The expanded kitchen flows into an open space perfect for gathering with family & friends. Sunlight streams in though large paneled windows. A cozy den or “Snug” is framed by beams & hardwood floors. Enjoy built in bookshelves with a brick hearth & Woodstove. A formal dining room sits opposite & a new 1st floor full bath. Upstairs are 4 good sized bedrooms with idyllic views & another full bath. The basement is on its way to being finished: boxed stairs, high ceilings, & sealed concrete floors. Speaking of extra space see the large attached garage. The heating system is definitely an added value point. Unlike traditional electric heaters, Steffes Electric Thermal Storage units convert electricity to heat in off-peak hours, when the demand /price of electricity is lower. Nice!
Courtesy: Benson Agency Real Estate LLC
607-432-4391
Discover this charming Cape Cod nestled in a lovely neighborhood in the Town of Oneonta. This cozy home offers 3 bedrooms and 1 bath, complemented by a covered back patio and a screened-in porch connected to a one-car detached garage. Enjoy the convenience of being within walking distance to West End Oneonta’s eateries, the Town pool, tennis courts, and the Elementary School. With a touch of TLC, this delightful house has the potential to become a truly wonderful home!
Courtesy: Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties
607-431-2540
FIRST TIME OFFERED! Timeless charm meets modern convenience in this striking 4 bedroom 3 bath almost 3000 sf Oneonta Cape set on a lovely 0.44 acre landscaped lot with private rear yard & large detached garage/workshop. The heart of the home is a beautiful, sun-drenched eat-in island kitchen with maple cabinets, Corian counters, stainless steel appliances, and a breakfast bar. The kitchen, adjoining a dining room & living room, is the perfect gathering place for friends & family. Thoughtful details are found throughout the home, including tray ceilings, curved walls, upgraded light fixtures, a gas fireplace, large closets, and ample storage. The first-floor primary suite offers one-floor living. An additional bedroom on the first floor can be a guest room, office, or den. The two upstairs generously-sized bedrooms are serviced by a full bath. A walk-out family room with loads of storage completes the package. The heated 2-car garage is perfect for hobbies or car repairs. This lovingly cared-for home in the friendly neighborhood of West Oneonta is a welcoming space ideal for both casual living & entertaining. Don’t miss the opportunity to make this exceptional property your own!
Courtesy: Revolution Real Estate
585-653-7700
Self Storage facility for sale in Oneonta NY. This amazing business opportunity sits on .67 acres and currently has 8,330 square feet of storage with 70 units. Currently has 95.7% physical occupancy. Purchase today and start off making almost 9% on your money from day 1. In addition to the current building another 15 unit building can be added (up to 30ft per unit) and is already paved. Recent Indoor expansion (all units filled within 2 weeks). This one is a true money maker!
Courtesy: BlueSky Properties
607-287-8965
When opportunity knocks, will you answer? This property is brimming with intrigue and possibilities. A single family residence, tucked away on 3.46 acres comprised of 3 parcels. Partially wooded and private, located on the St. Hwy 28 corridor between Cooperstown and Oneonta - just a stone's throw from Goodyear Lake. Residential and commercially zoned. What is your vision? Already a homesteader's dream, complete with garden beds and a greenhouse. Unique established plants and natural healing herbs surround the greenhouse and attract bees and butterflies. Or does your vision include an investment opportunity for a mini rental compound or private business? Maybe you just want to enjoy the convenience of living 10 minutes from the nearest grocery store while enjoying all of the best features of living the country life. Appreciate one floor living with 2 BR, 2 full bathrooms, laundry, an updated kitchen with stainless appliances, spacious dining and living room that make way to a terrific enclosed front porch. Enjoy plenty of bonus space w/a full dry basement. What are you waiting for? Opportunity knocked...time to answer!
Courtesy: Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties
607-431-2540
**OPEN HOUSE LAUNCH Sunday 8/25 - 1PM to 3PM** Step into this charming residence where historical character meets spacious & modern convenience. The first floor boasts beautiful wood floors and a lovely foyer leading to a retro kitchen with custom wood cabinets and a farmhouse sink. Upstairs, three bedrooms await (with plenty of closet space!), along with a full bathroom with a tub with shower and more custom cabinets. Need extra space? The full attic, accessible via stairs, offers storage & other creative possibilities with windows that allow natural light to filter in. The full dry basement is set up to be used as a home office with a custom wood desk and drafting station to match the kitchen and upstairs bathroom cabinets. The basement also hosts the second bathroom/laundry room and an additional work room. The bonus room off the kitchen is perfectly suited as a large walk-in pantry or could be converted into another bathroom. Outside, a stone patio overlooks the large fenced yard shaded by majestic oak and pine trees. A well maintained one-car detached garage completes the property. This freshly painted and professionally cleaned home is ready for you to make it your own!
Courtesy: Benson Agency Real Estate LLC
607-432-4391
IMMACULATELY UPDATED & WELL-MAINTAINED ONEONTA HOME!!! Perfectly located just minutes from downtown, both Colleges, the hospital, and around the corner from price chopper & I-88 access; exterior highlights include a partially enclosed front porch, large driveway space in the back for ample parking, large backyard, & a TWO STORY 2-CAR DETACHED GARAGE WITH ELECTRIC! Inside on the first floor features include a bonus room/enclosed back porch, kitchen, formal dining room, large living room, full bath and two first floor bedrooms. Upstairs you will find a large bedroom w/walk-in closet and a MASTER SUITE W/LARGE ATTACHED UPDATED FULL BATH! To top everything off, major highlights include - RADON MITIGATION SYSTEM, UV WATER FILTRATION SYSTEM, NEWER ON DEMAND HOT WATER (2015), NEWER BAXI BOILER (2015), NEWER ROOF (2016), & ALL NEW PLUMBING (2019)!!! This is certainly one you won't want to miss ... Don't hesitate!
Courtesy: New York Trophy Properties
607-435-1530
AMAZING Lakefront Fully Furnished Cottage on .69 acre lot conveniently located on Goodyear Lake offers far more than your average lakefront property! This cozy, seasonal 2 bedroom / 1 bath cottage has been loved and well-cared for by the same family and their loved ones for almost 30 years. The main cottage offers a spacious bedroom, breakfast bar, enclosed porch, vaulted ceiling with a light/fan combo, sliding glass doors and a gorgeous view of Goodyear Lake. In addition to the main cottage, you will find a screened-in shed with heat providing a great place to socialize and take in the beauty of the water. There is a large 2-car garage with plenty of storage and workshop area as well as an Adirondack-themed bedroom with sink. A large shed with ample storage area and small shed containing washer/dryer and shower adorns this property! For those with visiting friends and family, a spacious 2018 Cougar 368 MBI booking at $31,800 (J.D. Power) which easily sleeps 6, has a large-screen t.v. and electric fireplace. A jet ski dock and riding lawn mower are included in the sale. Don't miss out on your chance to enjoy lake life at its best and call for your private showing today!!!
Courtesy: Benson Agency Real Estate LLC
607-432-4391
Discover a gem in the heart of Oneonta's historic district! This beautifully maintained brick home, built in 1910, showcases original features such as a grand wrap-around porch, a slate roof, and stunning wood moldings that highlight the spacious tall windows. You'll also appreciate the chestnut pocket doors and beautiful hardwood floors throughout. The classic floor plan includes a formal dining room, a front living room, a parlor, and two staircases—one in the foyer and another conveniently located off the kitchen. Upstairs you will find four bedrooms and two updated bathrooms. The kitchen boasts granite counter tops, a cooking island, a breakfast bar, and stainless steel appliances. Next to the kitchen, there's a comfy family room or eat-in kitchen, along with a convenient half bathroom. For those who work or study from home, the finished basement office space has its own exterior entry at the back of the house. Thoughtful modern updates blend seamlessly with the home's character, offering all the conveniences you desire. Interior painted, most fixtures replaced, exterior decks and ceilings painted 3 years ago.
Courtesy: Benson Agency Real Estate LLC
607-432-4391
IMMACULATE TOWN OF ONEONTA RANCH! What a well maintained property! This 3 bedroom is just outside of town making it easy to get wherever you need to be. Sun-filled rooms, great kitchen with lots of cabinets, renovated bath, gorgeous hardwood floors, a large 3 season room off the kitchen, rec space in the basement, a private deck, a newer 2 car garage and 2 lots are just some of this home's many features. 321 Pony Farm Road needs to be on the top of your list, there's nothing to do beyond moving in!
