The median home value in Penn Yan, NY is $317,500.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $239,300.
The national median home value is $338,100.
The average price of homes sold in Penn Yan, NY is $317,500.
Approximately 50.71% of Penn Yan homes are owned,
compared to 34.74% rented, while
14.55% are vacant.
Penn Yan real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Penn Yan real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
Great opportunity to buy an established, well known, local business w over 30 years of customer service in the Penn Yan area. Business comes w building and land, all equipment, and all supplies needed for your success. When you walk in the door everything that you see is what you get, plus extra inventory. Located in a high traffic area right on route 14A just north of Penn Yan makes this property valuable for any business. Showings are by appointment only as this is a daily running business.
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
Situated in the Heart of Penn Yan Village on a dead-end street this 3 Bed and 1 Full bath home sits on a large lot with a detached 2 car garage. This home is awaiting a new lease on life and is a perfect home to grow into. The country kitchen leads into a large living and dining room with a possible downstairs bedroom or office and adjacent sunroom. Upstairs are 3 nicely sized bedrooms and a large Full Bath just waiting for updates. The Full basement provides plenty of storage and is currently the location of the washer and dryer, along with the mechanicals and the newer boiler that runs the hot water baseboard heating system, all this along with an exterior walkout to the backyard. Bring your ideas and make this house your home. This home is being sold AS IS.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
Penn Yan Village ranch home. Ready to sell. 2 bedrooms 1 full bath home with a large open living space to furnish as you see fit. Enjoy this QUIET village side street that is easy to walk on and close to the Main St business district for shopping and restaurants. High Speed internet services available and the PY Village low municipal electric rates. Covered front porch with front and rear entrances to the house. Washer Dryer hook ups off the kitchen. Brand new refrigerator. Recent updates include flooring and a new roof on the back of the house. Large level lot has level off street parking and an undeveloped wooded lot that wraps around behind the neighbors. Come for a tour and visit Wager Cider Mill on the top of East Main Street on your way home. Or take a hike down the Keuka Lake Outlet Trail just around the corner !
Courtesy: Curbeau Realty Inc.
315-536-9404
EXCELLENT OPPORTUNITY for commercial, industrial, educational or residential opportunities near Indian Pines Park on Keuka Lake! Most recent use has been a Real Estate office with 6 office areas, common rooms, kitchen and 1 1/2 baths. In the past it has been a grocery store, computer offices for Penn Yan Express and a private residence with single office! Walking distance to Seneca Farms Ice Cream Restaurant! Property is located just outside of the Village but with the benefit of Penn Yan Electric and no Village taxes! Public water & Sewer! Use your imagination and create something special to add to our growing Penn Yan/Keuka Lake community! What about AIR B&B Private Offices for those working remotely and looking for privacy out of the home???? This parcel is right next to vacant commercial lot also for sale! MLS#R1583195. Can be purchased separately or together! Owners and listing agent are NYS Licensed Real Estate Brokers.
Courtesy: Curbeau Realty Inc.
315-536-9404
Excellent potential for commercial or residential development just beyond Penn Yan Village limits. No Village taxes but public water, public sewer and Village Electric. 1 acre of development open land - 27,000 sq ft of blacktop with grassy area behind and view of Keuka Lake Outlet! Can be purchased separately or together with office building on South end of parking area MLS#R1583195. Consider the many commercial options for developing this desirable parcel of land just outside the Village of Penn Yan and around the corner from Indian Pines Park on Keuka Lake! Formerly in years gone by it was the site of Perry's Hot Dog Stand and Doug's Meaner Wiener!!! Use your imagination and invest in our growing Finger Lakes Keuka Lake Community! Listing agent and owners are NYS Licensed Real Estate Brokers
Courtesy: Wine Trail Properties, LLC
315-536-8004
Welcome to this appealing 4-bedroom, 1 full bath, and 2 half bath home located in the Village of Penn Yan, New York. With a brand new roof installed in October 2024, this property offers a great blend of comfort and convenience. The modern kitchen features granite countertops and a kitchen island, perfect for meal prep and entertaining. The open floor plan flows easily from the kitchen into the inviting living and dining areas, providing a warm and welcoming space for everyday living. Step outside to your own private space! The fully fenced-in backyard is ideal for kids, pets, or simply relaxing. Enjoy the above-ground pool, complete with a wrap-around deck—perfect for lounging or hosting gatherings. The 2-car garage is a standout feature, offering both ample parking and additional storage with an attached workshop on one side and a shed on the other. Whether you're working on a project or need extra space for gardening tools, this setup has you covered. Enjoy the convenience of being within walking distance to downtown Penn Yan's shops, restaurants, and the Outlet Trail, offering a perfect mix of small-town fun and outdoor recreation. Delay Negotiations to begin 1/14 at 5p
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
Start the new year off in a new home! Great home blocks away from downtown Penn Yan! Traditional layout with a big kitchen, formal dining room, living room, foyer and half bath on the first floor. On the second floor are 3 bedrooms, (one with a nice southern facing sunroom!,) with hardwood floors, LED fan/lights and a full bath. A full walk up attic is ready for ideas; game space, craft room or use for storage. Full basement houses the utilities and laundry with extra storage too! Full enclosed front and back porches. Out back is an open garage storage and low maintenance village lot. New roof 2 years ago and new vinyl windows throughout. Call your agent today to view! Listing agent related to seller.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
IMMACULATE COMMERCIAL OPPORTUNITY IN THE VILLAGE OF PENN YAN. THIS GC General Commercial zoned property allows for many authorized commercial uses. Up to date interior features updated wiring, and energy efficient modern split heating and central air units. Enjoy the benefits of the Penn Yan Village Utilites Board low cost electric rates. Level on site parking and room to expand on the level lot. ADA compliant no step entry makes access for you and your business ideal. The interior of the building allows for easy re configuration if desired for your uses. THE GC General Commercial zoned property allows for: Non-Profits, Schools, Group Home, Nursery school, Day Care, Place of worship, Veterinary, Manufacturing, Showrooms, Warehouse, Terminal, Shop, Vehicle Repair, Electronic repair, General business office, Professional Services Office, AND MORE ... bring your ideas & come check it out ! Let's see how this space can work for you. Ideal office space. Current business is an operating nail tech salon with furniture fixture and equipment supporting the business for pedicures, cosmetology, facials, and tanning beds. The current Nail Salon and related business and inventory can be purchase and included with the sale of the real property. Clean, well maintained premises, everything is neat and tidy. All public utilities are available and hooked up. Tow high speed internet service providers include Empire Fiber Optic service and Spectrum High Speed Internet. The seller will review owner finance offers, bring your offer terms today.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
KEUKA LAKE LIVING at The Moorings on Keuka! This impressive condominium community offers the perfect blend of elegance and ease. Presenting the ‘Reef 2’ model: approximately 1,440 square feet of thoughtfully designed luxury, featuring two en-suite bedrooms, an open-concept great room and kitchen, a partially covered paver patio with serene lake views, and an attached garage. Boat slip included! This is lakeside living at its finest, without all the maintenance of a lake home. Nestled at the head of Keuka Lake, The Moorings on Keuka is an exclusive, private community of custom-designed condos and single-family homes. Here, luxury meets style. With impeccable high-end finishes and panoramic low-country lake views, every detail has been curated to offer tranquility and sophistication. The construction’s meticulous craftsmanship ensures the privacy of a single-family home with the carefree benefits of maintenance-free living. Whether boating, kayaking, or strolling along scenic trails, every moment here is an opportunity to unwind. Enjoy the convenience of low taxes and municipal utilities, plus the added amenities of condominium living. The HOA includes lawn mowing, landscaping, snow plowing, insurance, exterior maintenance, and trash removal. Also included: access to a STATE-OF-THE-ART-CLUBHOUSE and gym—perfect for gatherings and fitness—and your very own 30-foot boat slip. A peaceful escape, close to everything. Though secluded and serene, The Moorings is perfectly situated near all the conveniences you desire. A short walk in the Village of Penn Yan brings you to great shopping, restaurants and one very cool coffee shop! Ready to elevate your lifestyle and “Connect to What Matters”? Visit today and see what makes this community truly extraordinary.
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
Situated in the Heart of Penn Yan Village, this 2-Bedroom 2 Full Bath home features an Open Floor plan concept with a nice flow between the Kitchen, dining and living room. This well-maintained home has a Master Suite bedroom and 2 large decks one covered porch area off the front and a nicely sized deck off the side for Family Gatherings. Outside has plenty of parking and a cute patio area with 2 good sized sheds for additional storage.
Courtesy: Finger Lakes Realty
315-536-7285
Charming new build 3-Bedroom, 2.5-Bath House on Beautiful Keuka Lake Welcome to your dream lakefront retreat! This gorgeous 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home on the shores of Keuka Lake offers fantastic water views, exceptional living spaces, and the perfect blend of modern amenities and lake lifecharm. Whether you're looking for a year-round residence or a seasonal getaway, this property provides a serene environment for relaxation and enjoyment. Key Features: 3 Spacious Bedrooms: Generously sized rooms with large windows offering stunning lake views. Master suite includes a private bathroom. Open Concept Living: Expansive open floor plan perfect for entertaining. Enjoy lake views through the many windows. Gourmet Kitchen: Fully equipped with stainless steel appliances, custom quartz countertops, custom cabinetry, and a center island. Cozy Family Room: Living area is perfect for movie nights or enjoying the cozy feel of the electric fireplace. Lakefront: Step right out into your backyard for direct access to 64' of frontage. Enjoy the pristine waters of Keuka Lake, ideal for boating, swimming, and fishing. Outdoor Living: Patio for entertaining, along with a lawn leading to the water’s edge. Enjoy stunning sunsets and lakefront dining in your own backyard. 40 ft Dock: Included for easy access to Keuka Lake, whether you’re boating, kayaking, or simply soaking in the serene surroundings. Water is deep enough for most boats at the end of the dock. Storage Garage: Ample storage space for your toys and outdoor equipment. Lot: Parking for 3 cars, walk down access, patio, alcove, with town water and sewer. Additional Features: Energy-efficient heating and cooling systems to keep the home comfortable year-round. Low-maintenance landscaping, giving you more time to enjoy the lake. Located near Penn Yan, wineries, and restaurants, providing endless opportunities for exploration and relaxation.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
10 TOTAL ACRES lots of possibilities. MOTIVATED SELLERS. This lovely ranch home, second owner since construction, showcases the original owner’s craftsmanship with unique character features like curved entryways. A veneer stone wall with a wood stove efficiently heats the house. It boasts all-new appliances, updated flooring in the kitchen, and solid oak cabinets. The newly remodeled bathroom and living area are filled with natural light from numerous brand-new windows. The property includes a whole-house water treatment system with RO at the sink and offers stunning views of the town and the Finger Lakes hills. With three spacious bedrooms, a huge, clean basement featuring a woodworking shop (tools included), and affordable heating via baseboard heat and Village electric, this home is ideal for comfortable living. The exterior features fruit trees and outbuildings, including a chicken coop. Complemented by a large barn with a new 8” concrete floor and 50-amp service and Husqvarna zero turn mower included in sale. The drainage around the barn could easily be transformed into a small pond.
Courtesy: Finger Lakes Realty
315-536-7285
Affordable two bedroom home on corner lot with a fantastic location close to schools, downtown and the Outlet Trail! Home features living room, dining room, eat-in kitchen and downstairs office/bedroom too!
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
New home, 3 bedrooms 2 full bath, w front porch and back deck. Home is in the Village of Penn Yan, w all village utilities. Municipal water, sewer, and total municipal electric for inexpensive utility bills. Neighborhood setting. Taxes to be determined.
Courtesy: Finger Lakes Realty
315-536-7285
Business opportunity of a lifetime! Automotive building, ranch home and 2 other parcels (1.19 acres) on well traveled state road. Corner lot is perfect for commercial or retail business. Own a piece of the Town of Benton!
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
OPPORTUNITY!! This property has wonderful POTENTIAL to bring your business to the Outlet Trail in beautiful, thriving, downtown Penn Yan! Be a part of the renaissance in this fantastic Village location, across the water from the iconic Birkett Mills. Over eight thousand square feet of usable space, including a ground-level, one-bedroom, vacation rental guest apartment. Currently housing the Napa Auto Parts store, this building has been an office/ commercial use property since the 1960’s. Over 155' of road frontage with a parking lot for 20 cars, in addition to free on-street parking. Triangular-shaped lot measures roughly 260 x 243 x 155. Low-cost Penn Yan Village Municipal Electric. What vision will you bring to this wonderful location?
Courtesy: RE/MAX Plus
585-279-8200
This lovely 3 bedroom Ranch boasts an inviting open front porch, an attached garage, and a convenient sliding glass door from the dining area to the partially fenced backyard. Freshly painted walls and new laminate flooring gives the interior a fresh modern look. The spacious basement offers plenty of potential for additional rooms. This well-maintained home is perfect for those looking for comfort and the opportunity to customize. Don’t miss out on this gem!
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
Handyman Special. This home is over 50percent completed so come put your final touches on it and make it a home. Public water is piped into garage ready for hook up. existing septic system and a new 200-amp electric service. located on a private Rd.
Courtesy: Wine Trail Properties, LLC
315-536-8004
Keuka Lake! This classic original Keuka Lake Victorian 2 story home has large modern addition giving just over 3000 square feet of living space (appraiser measured, tax records inaccurate.) Drive to the door where you have plentiful parking and an easy way to access formal entry through covered front porch. Two large living rooms overlook the lake. Brand new new modern kitchen with quartz counters, tons of cabinet space and brand new stainless steel appliances. Dining area is just off side entry door with mudroom. Huge first floor primary with walk in closet and ensuite bath. First floor also has half bath and laundry. Upstairs are another 3 incredibly sized bedrooms and full bath with bonus office space. Many new improvements throughout including roof, new exterior and interior paint, modern half bath and new kitchen. In the newer constructed two level addition, modern radiant floor heat for both large bedrooms. 56 feet of lake frontage is accessed through sloping grassy yard to beach deck and removable dock. All situated on lower East Lake Road for walking, biking, and a true neighborhood feel- only 7 miles from Penn Yan!
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
Village of Penn Yan at the north end of Keuka Lake: One level living with all the perks of a no maintenance condo. Come see the progress on Water St in Penn Yan! This new 2024 development is progressing nicely, all the exterior doors and windows have been installed and the mechanical installations have started on the interiors. This ground level unit features a no step entry, 2 bedrooms with 2 full baths and plenty of storage space. LOW UTILITY COSTS with an all electric unit on Penn Yan's Municipal electric rates. Central Air to keep you comfortable. Appliances included with a washer and dryer. This turn key unit will be move in ready. Enjoy the CONDOS LOW TAX BASIS - no worries about escalating assessments. Insurance included. Off street parking. An easy walk to Penn Yan's downtown restaurants, shopping, and Keuka Lake's Outlet Trail right across the street. A unique option that hasn't been available in the Penn Yan limits before. One unit under contract and we are looking for 3 more ! Choose your unit and desired floorplan today, "pre construction" pricing in effect, don't wait too long.
Courtesy: FLR Partners, LLC
315-685-9755
Welcome to a 4200 sq/ft custom-built home/business nestled above Keuka Lake. Zoned for commercial + residential use, this property is a testament to modern luxury and sustainable living. The finished basement complete with garage door access, floor drains, sink, and bath, make for an ideal space for beer, cider or small batch wine production. The exterior boasts White Pine sourced locally and milled onsite, while the interior features White Pine accents throughout. Step inside and discover comfort and convenience. The living spaces are thoughtfully designed for both relaxation and functionality. Fujitsu Heat Pumps ensure optimal comfort year-round. The main level features a gourmet/industrial kitchen equipped with stainless steel appliances, including a Bertazzoni Stove from Italy and commercial-grade amenities. The central area boasts soaring ceilings, lakeview windows, and a custom concrete bar ideal for tastings. The loft offers a retreat with a spa-like bath, family room, office space, and private deck with a gas fire pit. Experience sustainable and timeless design in this extraordinary property, where every detail reflects a commitment to quality and environmental stewardship.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
Embrace a piece of history with this iconic gem at the northern end of Main Street. The majestic "Arcade Building" stands as a beacon of opportunity, featuring at least three retail spaces with the potential for more if expanded down the grand hall. Whether you're envisioning a boutique hotel, stylish apartments, or a unique destination venue, this multi-use property offers endless possibilities. The building's grandeur is accentuated by its sweeping staircase leading to a spacious second floor, perfect for hosting special events. A stunning skylight lights both floors, enhancing the high ceilings and expansive rooms throughout. The third floor offers two huge spaces – perfect for loft living with views over the surrounding village. Sold as-is, this property requires some TLC but comes with the added benefit of DRI grant funding availability and includes comprehensive hotel plans. Don’t miss your chance to transform this historic landmark into a vibrant new chapter for Penn Yan!
Courtesy: Century 21 Steve Davoli RE
315-789-4569
Village of Penn Yan office, and mixed use building on the main artery-north & south (NYS Rte 54). A former Real Estate office building on the main floor, with a currently leased apartment upstairs, and a chiropractic office on the north side of building. Large parking lot in the back of the building, together with a separate parcel fronting Monell St, which could be for even more parking, or an additional building. 4600 sq. ft. of finished area, newer roof, updated heating and air conditioning system, and OWNER FINANCING maybe available to a qualified buyer. Whether looking for an office building of your own with tenants to offset your investment, or just office space to lease to others....here's your opportunity.
Courtesy: Century 21 Steve Davoli RE
315-789-4569
Seneca Lake-300+ ft. of natural lake frontage, and 3+ acres of land together with a 2022 newly constructed, year-round lake home with unrivaled privacy. 2-3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, quartz counter tops, radiant heat, central AC, open porch, 2-car attached & heated garage, and a 3000 sq. ft. pole barn to store all your toys. Heated/finished area above garage equates to 1400 sq. ft. of finished area. Property taxes are over-stated, as this reflects total parcel before sub-division. This is as amazing as it sounds, and all ready for you to enjoy this summer.
Courtesy: FLR Partners, LLC
315-685-9755
Welcome to a 4200 sq/ft custom-built home nestled above Keuka Lake. Zoned for commercial and residential use, this property is a testament to modern luxury and sustainable living. Powered entirely by solar energy from the nearby Wallace Farms Community Solar Farm, this eco-friendly home is designed to harmonize with its environment. The exterior boasts White Pine sourced locally and milled onsite, while the interior features White Pine accents throughout. Step inside and discover comfort and convenience. The living spaces are thoughtfully designed for both relaxation and functionality. Fujitsu Heat Pumps ensure optimal comfort year-round. The main level features a gourmet kitchen equipped with stainless steel appliances, including a Bertazzoni Stove from Italy and commercial-grade amenities. The central area boasts soaring ceilings, lakeview windows, and a custom concrete bar ideal for entertaining. The loft offers a retreat with a spa-like bath, family room, office space, and private deck with a gas fire pit. Experience sustainable and timeless design in this extraordinary property, where every detail reflects a commitment to quality and environmental stewardship.
