The median home value in Penn Yan, NY is $302,500.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $239,300.
The national median home value is $338,100.
The average price of homes sold in Penn Yan, NY is $302,500.
Approximately 50.71% of Penn Yan homes are owned,
compared to 34.74% rented, while
14.55% are vacant.
Penn Yan real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Penn Yan real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Courtesy: Finger Lakes Realty
315-536-7285
Affordable two bedroom home on corner lot with a fantastic location close to schools, downtown and the Outlet Trail! Home features living room, dining room, eat-in kitchen and downstairs office/bedroom too!
Courtesy: Keller Williams Southern Tier
607-795-2900
Welcome to 497 East Lake Road, a beautiful Keuka Lake retreat in Penn Yan, NY, designed for year-round enjoyment. This spacious 5-bedroom home offers the perfect blend of lakefront living and modern comfort. With 98 feet of pristine lakefrontage, the property features two boat lifts and a well-maintained dock, making it a breeze to enjoy water activities. Inside, this move-in-ready home is ideal for relaxing summers by the lake or cozy winters with family and friends. The expansive windows bring in stunning lake views, filling each room with natural light. Whether you're looking for a summer escape or a full-time residence, 497 East Lake Road offers the ultimate Keuka Lake lifestyle. Come and take a look. Note: Homes Square Footage by Agent; see more floor plans in the document file, including the beach accessory building.
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
New home, 3 bedrooms 2 full bath, w front porch and back deck. Home is in the Village of Penn Yan, w all village utilities. Municipal water, sewer, and total municipal electric for inexpensive utility bills. Neighborhood setting. Taxes to be determined.
Courtesy: Finger Lakes Realty
315-536-7285
Business opportunity of a lifetime! Automotive building, ranch home and 2 other parcels (1.19 acres) on well traveled state road. Corner lot is perfect for commercial or retail business. Own a piece of the Town of Benton!
Courtesy: Wine Trail Properties, LLC
315-536-8004
Here's your opportunity for a slice of Keuka Lake on East Bluff Drive! 83' of lake front that feels private and expansive down at the water. This property comes with more land and additional parking on the other side of E Bluff Drive. Available to be connected to public water & sewer. Structure is in need of major rehab so bring your ideas. Do NOT enter the property at will. Stairs & structure are unsafe. Property will be sold "as-is" "where-is."
Courtesy: Hunt Real Estate ERA/Columbus
585-394-8888
****NEW UPDATED PRICE****ON THIS BEAUTY - LOCATED CENTRALLY IN THE VILLAGE OF PENN YAN. A Charming Home for Sale in the Heart of Penn Yan Village - This home offers the perfect blend of comfort, convenience and style. Key Features: - Prime location in the heart of the village of Penn Yan - Well-maintained and move-in ready - Smaller kitchen with ample space to work - Second floor offers four large bedrooms w/great closet space. - Second Floor full bathroom -First floor two half baths - Spacious living areas filled with natural light - Beautifully landscaped yard, mature trees with nearly a half-acre lot. - Relaxing outdoor deck for entertaining or unwinding - Close to local amenities, shops, and dining options - Detached two car garage with Huge storage and shop area. This property is Zoned Residential Transition and allows multi-family and some business uses. It's an amazing opportunity to put a new twist on "working from home." Don't miss out on this wonderful opportunity to own a home in this desirable location. The property is on delayed showings and negotiations. Showings begin Saturday 10/26/2024 at 10 AM. Offers due Wednesday 10/30/24 at noon.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
The best view on Northview! This stunning classic colonial has been tastefully updated and requires nothing but your personal touch. A welcoming circular driveway, recently redone, invites you in, offering ample parking for family and friends. The expansive backyard is perfect for outdoor activities, featuring a deck, pool, and gazebo—ideal for entertaining and relaxation. Inside, the spacious and updated kitchen serves as a bright and inviting gathering spot. The dining room seamlessly connects to a grand entry foyer and an expansive living room, featuring a cozy gas fireplace and a cleverly concealed TV. Upstairs, you'll find four generously sized bedrooms, each equipped with custom closets to maximize storage. The full clean and dry basement finishes it off. Spacious, immaculate, and bright - Every detail has been thoughtfully addressed and is ready to welcome you home (including the attached two-car garage!)
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
Cozy year round cottage with 60 years of labor and love! This Seneca Lake gem boasts a private 100 feet sprawling shale beach buffered either side by woods, panoramic views, permanent dock, expansive outdoor decks for family entertainment, and plenty of parking. This property features a heated and insulated garage on a wooded lot. Gentle steps lead to the lakefront home or take an easy ride on the state of the art covered tram system. Inside the home you'll find 2 bedrooms and 1 full bath, a wood burning fireplace, and updated custom oak kitchen with granite countertops. Walkout basement with washer, dryer, wash tub, refrigerator, freezer and cedar closet is ideal to use as a bar area or to store your water skis and lifejackets. Family selling do to changes in their health. Selling mostly furnished minus some personal possessions. Do not sleep on this Seneca Lake once in a lifetime opportunity.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
This lovely ranch home, second owner since construction, showcases the original owner’s craftsmanship with unique character features like curved entryways. A veneer stone wall with a wood stove efficiently heats the house. It boasts all-new appliances, updated flooring in the kitchen, and solid oak cabinets. The newly remodeled bathroom and living area are filled with natural light from numerous brand-new windows. The property includes a whole-house water treatment system with RO at the sink and offers stunning views of the town and the Finger Lakes hills. With three spacious bedrooms, a huge, clean basement featuring a woodworking shop (tools included), and affordable heating via baseboard heat and Village electric, this home is ideal for comfortable living .The exterior features fruit trees and outbuildings, including a chicken coop. Complemented by a large barn with a new 8” concrete floor and 50-amp service. The drainage around the barn could easily be transformed into a small pond. Two separate building lots for sale. See MLS #R1571234 and R1571235 Sub-division of 3 lots PENDING TOWN APPROVAL (expected on 11/7) House MUST sell first.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
Perfect flat building lot with views of Penn Yan and the surrounding hills. 1.5 miles from all that downtown has to offer. Yet, zoned agriculture for more opportunities. Nestled on a quiet road. Lots pending town approval on 11/7. Final Tax ID # and assessed value will be assigned after closing. Assessment and tax estimated. Second lot for sale, see MLS # R1571234 House and 3.73 acres also for sale. House MUST sell first. See MLS # R1571212
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
Perfect flat building lot with views of Penn Yan and the surrounding hills. 1.5 miles from all that downtown has to offer. Yet, zoned agriculture for more opportunities. Nestled on a quiet road. Lots pending town approval on 11/7. Final Tax ID # and assessed value will be assigned after closing. Assessment and tax estimated. Second lot for sale, see MLS # R1571235 House and 3.73 acres also for sale. House MUST sell first. See MLS # R1571212
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
OPPORTUNITY!! This property has wonderful POTENTIAL to bring your business to the Outlet Trail in beautiful, thriving, downtown Penn Yan! Be a part of the renaissance in this fantastic Village location, across the water from the iconic Birkett Mills. Over eight thousand square feet of usable space, including a ground-level, one-bedroom, vacation rental guest apartment. Currently housing the Napa Auto Parts store, this building has been an office/ commercial use property since the 1960’s. Over 155' of road frontage with a parking lot for 20 cars, in addition to free on-street parking. Triangular-shaped lot measures roughly 260 x 243 x 155. Low-cost Penn Yan Village Municipal Electric. What vision will you bring to this wonderful location?
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
This spacious Victorian lakeview home blends classic charm with modern updates. It features six large bedrooms (one first floor bed and bath) and three full baths, including a guest suite with a separate entrance. The newly renovated eat-in kitchen offers ample space and modern comforts, highlighted by solid wood beams. The bright foyer and living room boast high ceilings and large windows that fill the space with light, while built-in California Closets provide ample storage. A massive wrap-around porch and a stone patio with a fire pit offer stunning views of Keuka Lake. A paved driveway with plenty of parking leads to a newer 2 car garage. This property is perfect for short-term rentals or as a large family home, with endless potential. Furnishings are negotiable. Located on Lower West Lake Road, just minutes from Penn Yan and all the Finger Lakes has to offer. Connected to public water and sewer for hassle-free living. Let the lighted cupola guide you home!!
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
Handyman Special. This home is over 50percent completed so come put your final touches on it and make it a home. Public water is piped into garage ready for hook up. existing septic system and a new 200-amp electric service. located on a private Rd.
Courtesy: Wine Trail Properties, LLC
315-536-8004
Keuka Lake! This classic original Keuka Lake Victorian 2 story home has large modern addition giving just over 3000 square feet of living space (appraiser measured, tax records inaccurate.) Drive to the door where you have plentiful parking and an easy way to access formal entry through covered front porch. Two large living rooms overlook the lake. Brand new new modern kitchen with quartz counters, tons of cabinet space and brand new stainless steel appliances. Dining area is just off side entry door with mudroom. Huge first floor primary with walk in closet and ensuite bath. First floor also has half bath and laundry. Upstairs are another 3 incredibly sized bedrooms and full bath with bonus office space. Many new improvements throughout including roof, new exterior and interior paint, modern half bath and new kitchen. In the newer constructed two level addition, modern radiant floor heat for both large bedrooms. 56 feet of lake frontage is accessed through sloping grassy yard to beach deck and removable dock. All situated on lower East Lake Road for walking, biking, and a true neighborhood feel- only 7 miles from Penn Yan!
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
This 3 bedroom, 2 bath log home offers a private 1 acre setting with 100 ft of Seneca Lake frontage on a quiet dead end road. The 1994 built log home has cathedral ceilings, wood stove, lofted master bedroom with covered balcony. Outside enjoy your morning coffee on the covered porch facing the lake on your wooded lot. Lakeside features shale beach with permanent dock and bonus lakefront cabin ready to be fixed up as your party or bunk house.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
Start your homeownership here! You will enjoy this lovely village home located in a quiet neighborhood near shopping, schools and hospital. The lot is easy to maintain. Warm nights spent on the screened in front porch will be so much fun. The eastern exposure morning room is a great place to start your day. The formal dining room is ideally positioned between the kitchen and the generous sized living room. Full baths are located on both floors. The 1st floor laundry room is oversized. 3 bedrooms are located on the 2nd floor; 2 are ready for immediate use and the 3rd bedroom needs to be finished. A super-sized hall closet on the 2nd floor is awesome. Come take a look. The home is super easy to show.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
Village of Penn Yan at the north end of Keuka Lake: One level living with all the perks of a no maintenance condo. Come see the progress on Water St in Penn Yan! This new 2024 development is progressing nicely, all the exterior doors and windows have been installed and the mechanical installations have started on the interiors. This ground level unit features a no step entry, 2 bedrooms with 2 full baths and plenty of storage space. LOW UTILITY COSTS with an all electric unit on Penn Yan's Municipal electric rates. Central Air to keep you comfortable. Appliances included with a washer and dryer. This turn key unit will be move in ready. Enjoy the CONDOS LOW TAX BASIS - no worries about escalating assessments. Insurance included. Off street parking. An easy walk to Penn Yan's downtown restaurants, shopping, and Keuka Lake's Outlet Trail right across the street. A unique option that hasn't been available in the Penn Yan limits before. One unit under contract and we are looking for 3 more ! Choose your unit and desired floorplan today, "pre construction" pricing in effect, don't wait too long.
Courtesy: Howard Hanna
585-473-1320
SPECTACULAR KEUKA LAKE! RARE LOCATION....THE "GOLD COAST" OF KEUKA LAKE WITH DRAMATIC NORTHERN VIEWS OF PENN YAN! 52' LAKE LEVEL WITH A SHALE BEACH & DOCK! SITUATED ON A PRIVATE ROAD OFF WEST LAKE ROAD FOR ADDED PRIVACY & PUBLIC UTILITIES. ARCHITECT DESIGNED LINDAL CEDAR CONTEMPORARY - CLEAN LINES MAKE A STRONG ARCHITECTURAL STATEMENT WITH FLEXIBLE & HIGHLY-FUNCTIONAL LIGHT-FILLED INTERIOR SPACES! THE HALLMARK OF THIS IMPRESSIVE LAKE RESIDENCE IS THE TWO STORY WOOD CATHEDRAL BEAMED CEILING GREAT ROOM WITH A WALL OF WINDOWS TO TAKE IN THOSE PANORAMIC LAKE VIEWS - FEATURING LIVING, DINING & KITCHEN OPEN TO AN ENTERTAINMENT SIZE WRAPAROUND DECK! 1ST FLOOR FEATURES FOYER ENTRANCE TWO BEDROOMS, BATH, & LAUNDRY. UPSTAIRS FEATURES A VERY SPACIOUS OWNER'S SUITE WITH A BATH, TWO WALK IN CLOSETS, PLUS ULTIMATE ELEVATED LAKE VIEWS! THIS ONE OF A KIND MINT LAKE PROPERTY HAS IT ALL, TOTALLY TURN KEY! THE VIEWS ARE AMAZING! ENJOY THE EVENING WITH THE GLITTER OF LIGHTS FROM PENN YAN! SHORT DISTANCE TO PENN YAN WITH GREAT RESTAURANTS & SHOPS & EASY ACCESS TO ALL AREAS IN THE FINGER LAKES REGION. AMAZING VALUE! FIRST SHOWINGS SATURDAY, 9-28-24 @ 11AM . SQ FT FROM FLOOR PLAN
Courtesy: Howard Hanna Lake Group
315-536-2700
KEUKA LAKE! The Moorings on Keuka Condominium development is looking downright GORGEOUS as this piece of magic unfolds. Several new owners could not be happier with the quality of construction, the luxurious finishes, full waterfront accessibility! INCLUDING A 30' BOAT SLIP...all set in the backdrop of Keuka Lake and the peaceful, quiet, Outlet to Seneca. This Clove Model features 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. No step living! Work with the designer to pick your finishes for your $120,000. allowance. Low property taxes, municipal electric, blanket condo insurance coverage and maintenance free living at its best. Elegant and impressive high-end finishes give you the quality you seek while the low-country views keep things calm and refreshed! Extraordinary, attentive details in the construction process and finished product. State of the art, high efficiency heat pump & air conditioning keep you comfortable all year long. Swimming, boating, kayaking, fishing, walking trails, and wine tasting in the heart of The Finger Lakes. All this, set in the charm of the Village of Penn Yan. What will happen when you ‘Connect to what Matters’? Come find out!
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
Ideal country setting 3.18 acre building lot on Old Bath Rd near to corner of Sisson Road. Don't miss this awesome chance to build you dream home close to Penn Yan and Keuka Lake.
Courtesy: FLR Partners, LLC
315-685-9755
Welcome to a 4200 sq/ft custom-built home/business nestled above Keuka Lake. Zoned for commercial + residential use, this property is a testament to modern luxury and sustainable living. The finished basement complete with garage door access, floor drains, sink, and bath, make for an ideal space for beer, cider or small batch wine production. The exterior boasts White Pine sourced locally and milled onsite, while the interior features White Pine accents throughout. Step inside and discover comfort and convenience. The living spaces are thoughtfully designed for both relaxation and functionality. Fujitsu Heat Pumps ensure optimal comfort year-round. The main level features a gourmet/industrial kitchen equipped with stainless steel appliances, including a Bertazzoni Stove from Italy and commercial-grade amenities. The central area boasts soaring ceilings, lakeview windows, and a custom concrete bar ideal for tastings. The loft offers a retreat with a spa-like bath, family room, office space, and private deck with a gas fire pit. Experience sustainable and timeless design in this extraordinary property, where every detail reflects a commitment to quality and environmental stewardship.
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
This picturesque 1-acre lot with a large barn and a creek at the rear of the property is awaiting your ideas to finish it. The property has been partially finished with a living room, kitchen, and bathroom all of which need to be hooked up to water and electric, along with this it has a new roof in 2017. Electric service is available across the road which would need to be brought in from their and it has two drilled wells that sit in the front yard. This is a perfect spot to enjoy the outdoors and finish off the property to a residence or just store your boat or toys in the winter. Opportunity awaits to turn this into what you desire. A septic system is on site that needs to be hooked into. This property is a blank canvas, bring your ideas. This property is being sold AS IS.
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
Country living with this 2bedroom 1.5 bath home with room to add extra bedroom and finish half bath into a full bath. Home is situated on 2.3 acres some open and some wooded. Offers awesome outdoor space w a great deck and patio. 2 story garage w finished room above for parties, extra living space or an in-law apartment. 5.6-acre lot also listed next door.
Courtesy: Keuka Lake & Land Realty
315-536-7446
Welcome to this charming 2-unit apartment in the heart of Penn Yan! The first unit offers a cozy 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom setup, perfect for singles or couples looking for a comfortable space. The second unit boasts 2 spacious bedrooms and 1 bathroom, making it ideal for a small family or roommates. This property is a fantastic opportunity for those looking to buy and live in one unit while generating rental income from the other. Alternatively, it's a great investment property with strong rental potential in a desirable location. Don't miss out on this opportunity in Penn Yan!
