The median home value in Shirley, NY is $520,000.
This is
lower than
the county median home value of $565,700.
The national median home value is $338,100.
The average price of homes sold in Shirley, NY is $520,000.
Approximately 83.97% of Shirley homes are owned,
compared to 9.55% rented, while
6.48% are vacant.
Shirley real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Shirley real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Courtesy: Signature Premier Properties
631-642-2300
Welcome Home! Brand New Energy Star Home w/ 1st floor Primary Bdrm Suite in Beach Community. Thoughtfully Designed & Beautifully Crafted, this 3 Bdrm, 2.5 Bath Home, Retirement House or Vacation Retreat is just 1 mi to Smith Point Park & less than 2 mi to Smith Point Beach. Bright & Sunny Open Floorplan w/ Soaring Ceilings in Great Room, Beautiful Modern Kitchen w/ Quartz Counters & SS Appliances, Hardwood Floors on 1st Floor, Primary Bdrm w/ Walk-in Closet & Full Bath w/ Double Vanity, High Efficiency 2 Zone Heat Pump, CAC, Full Bsmnt w/ 8 Ft Ceilings & Egress w/ Huge Possibilites for Expanded Living Spaces, 40 Yr Roof, 200 Amp Elec, Hydro Action Septic System (to be installed when ground thaws), 1 Car Garage & much more! Conveniently located near Shopping, Restaurants, Transportation, Beaches, Ferries & Marinas. Access to major highways just minutes away. **Exterior photos are virtually enhanced to show grass and driveway (to be installed after septic).**Est. taxes to be around $12,000
Courtesy: Century 21 KR Realty
631-736-5200
Welcome to this spacious 4-bedroom, 1-bath Ranch home. The open-concept design seamlessly blends the living room, dining room, and eat-in kitchen, creating a perfect space for gatherings and entertaining. The kitchen boasts vaulted ceilings with a skylight, filling the space with natural light, and a bay window adds character to the living room. Enjoy the outdoors on the inviting front porch, or step out into the fully fenced yard for privacy and security.
Courtesy: LW 21 LLC
516-376-2524
Welcome to this stunning 2025 new construction luxury energy star colonial home, featuring a seamless blend of modern design, energy efficiency, and an unbeatable location near Smith Point Beach. This home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and an open layout designed for comfortable living and entertainment. *** First Floor: 1) Bright and spacious living room with a fire place and abundant natural light. 2) Elegant dining room seamlessly flowing into the modern kitchen, ideal for entertaining. 3) Contemporary full bathroom. 4) One bedroom, perfect for a main bedroom or a home office. *** Second Floor: 1) Two large bedrooms with ample closet space. 2) Stylish full bathroom with modern finishes. 3) Convenient washer and dryer included. *** Energy Efficiency: This home is equipped with Anderson windows and foam insulation, providing optimal comfort and reducing energy costs. *** Convenience: Located just a 2-minute drive to CVS and a 4-minute drive to Home Depot, it offers quick access to everyday essentials. *** Transportation: Enjoy the ease of a 10-minute walk to the nearest bus stop and an 8-minute drive to the LIRR for effortless commuting. *** Proximity to Smith Point Beach: Just a 4-minute drive away, enjoy pristine white sands, swimming, surfing, and scenic trails at Smith Point Beach and Fire Island National Seashore. All the features of this house make it the perfect choice for your next home.
Courtesy: Stanzoni Realty Corp
631-399-4000
young home, needs some TLC, easy location to major highways, schools, shopping and beaches
Courtesy: Exit Realty Edge
631-730-5100
Welcome to Your New Home! This Tastefully Renovated 3 Bedroom, 1 Full Bath Residence Offers Perfect Blend of Modern Amenities and Classic Charm, Ideal For 1st Time Homebuyers, Downsizers, or Anyone Looking to Enjoy Cozy Living. The Home Has Been Freshly Painted Throughout, New Kitchen With Granite Tops, Shaker Soft Close Cabinets, New Bathroom, New Flooring, and Highhats. Priced to Sell... Don't Miss Your Opportunity to Make This Charming Renovated Home Yours!
Courtesy: Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life
631-399-5300
Courtesy: Exit Realty Edge
631-730-5100
Welcome to this 3-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom home, perfectly situated near shopping centers. This property offers a wonderful blend of convenience and opportunity. Inside, you’ll find a functional layout with spacious bedrooms and a cozy living area, ready to be transformed into your dream space. it’s bursting with potential to become a true gem. Imagine customizing it to your taste and enjoying the satisfaction of making it uniquely yours! Whether you're a first-time homebuyer or an investor this home is an incredible opportunity. Don't miss out on the chance to make this house your perfect home. Schedule a viewing and envision the possibilities!
Courtesy: Exit Realty Edge
631-730-5100
This delightful Cape-style home offers 4 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, perfectly blending classic charm with modern convenience. The updated bathrooms add a touch of luxury, featuring contemporary fixtures and stylish tile work. A large backyard provides plenty of space for outdoor gatherings. Don't miss the opportunity to make this house your forever home.
Courtesy: Hampton Estates Realty LLC
631-288-6333
AREAS BEST VALUE - TRIPLE NET ASSET (NNN) * Prime STNL ~ 2,600 Sq. ft. Restaurant/Q.S.R. Building situated on one of LONG ISLANDS' BUSIEST COMMUTER & TOURISM COORIDORS. Location to a multitude of Nationally Branded Q.S.R. /RETAIL & FAST FOOD establishments. Consistently high V.P.D/ Daily traffic counts on a fifteen mile corridor that feeds directly to Long Islands SMITH POINT BEACHES & SEASONAL EVENTS (OVER 300,000 VISITORS SEASONALLY). Prime Downtown Business Generator location servicing BOTH local Residents and Seasonal visitors. Brand new Interior & Exterior renovation in- progress, including: New Kitchen; Ansul; HVAC; Flooring; Dining Areas; Roofing; Parking; Landscaping; Facade' etc.. for Zero (0) deferred maintenance to new Owner. Easy access location with TWO (2) Crosswalks leading directly to Building and Full Sidewalks for 24Hr. Pedestrian Traffic. Lighted Intersection location. Full Lighted BUILDING & PYLON Signage from (3) directions. Unobstructed sight lines from BOTH North & South William Floyd Parkway. Stabilized Food Service Tenant in place on ten (10) year Lease. Annual C.P.I Increases. Prime Q.S.R. Long Term Asset., Additional information: Building Size:2556,Business Located At:440 William Floyd Pkwy,Rental Income:Y,vac_perc:0
Courtesy: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
516-354-6500
Land for sale in Shirley. Perfect opportunity to build your dream home. Land sits on a 50x125 lot.
Courtesy: Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life
631-929-3700
Welcome to the Bedford model condo in the highly sought-after Colonial Manors, a gated 55+ community offering a lifestyle of comfort and leisure! This ground-level 2-bedroom, 2-full bath home features a well-thought-out layout perfect for easy living. The spacious primary bedroom boasts two walk-in closets, while the inviting foyer leads to a cozy living room, dining area, and a bright eat-in kitchen with sliding doors to a covered patio. The home is adorned with high ceilings, high hats, and convenient indoor sprinklers. Enjoy modern comforts like central air and hot forced air heating. Additional highlights include a garage and driveway, ensuring ample parking. Colonial Manors offers an array of amenities designed to enhance your lifestyle, including an exercise room, pool, jacuzzi, bocce courts, and serene walking trails winding around a picturesque lake. Just minutes away, from Fire Island National Seashore enjoy camping, beaches, boating and fishing. You will find so much to do!
Courtesy: Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life
631-878-6080
This 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath in line raised ranch set on a 200 ft deep lot toward the far end of the block is ready for you to move right in! Enter from the front porch into the high ceiling living room, AC wall unit and deep coat closet. Round the corner to the eat in kitchen that opens to the dining room with overhead chandelier, bright bay window and side entrance. Down the hall is the full bath with tub and recessed medicine cabinet, a linen closet, three bedrooms - master bedroom with half bath and ceiling fan to circulate cool air. Solid wood interior doors. Full basement with partially finished living space to fit your specific needs - playroom, family room, room for mom, home office, etc. Unfinished storage/utility area. Laundry area. Fenced rear yard with two sheds, garbage storage and wood deck. Brand new roof, heating system and carpets. Longwood Schools.
Courtesy: Signature Premier Properties
631-642-2300
Investor delight!!This 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom ranch home offers a fantastic opportunity for investors and buyers with a vision. Situated on a spacious lot, this property is in need of some TLC, making it the perfect canvas for renovation and improvement. Featuring a full basement that provides ample space for expansion or storage, this home has incredible potential to be transformed into a stunning investment or a dream residence.
Courtesy: Signature Premier Properties
516-799-7100
Discover the potential of this 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom home located in the heart of Shirley, NY. Offering a spacious kitchen with propane cooking, living room, and dining room with a breezeway leading to the backyard, this property provides a solid foundation for your vision. Central Air System. The home also features a full basement with walk-out access and a 1-car garage, sitting on a level quarter-acre lot. Conveniently located in the William Floyd School District, it’s close to parkways, shopping, and the train station, making commuting and errands a breeze.
Courtesy: Keller Williams Realty Liberty
718-848-4700
Courtesy: Century 21 Cor Ace Realty Inc
631-878-3400
NEW CONSTRUCTION, OVERSIZED LOT, THIS LUXURY HOME TO BE BUILT FEATURES OVER 2300 SQ FT, 4 BEDROOMS, 2.5 BATHROOM, PRIMARY SUITE WITH ENSUITE BATH, GOURMET KITCHEN WITH STAINLESS STEEL APPLIANCES, CENTER ISLAND AND QUARTZ COUNTERTOPS, 42" UPPER CABINETRY, BREAKFAST AREA, PANTRY, 9' CELINGS 1ST FLOOR, 36" GAS FIREPLACE IN FAMILY ROOM, FORMAL LIVING ROOM, FORMAL DINING ROOM, HARDWOOD FLOORS, FULL BASEMENT 8"CEILINGS, 2 CAR GARAGE, 200 AMP ELECTRIC,
Courtesy: Century 21 Cor Ace Realty Inc
631-878-3400
Lovely Brand New Construction Colonial, 3 Bedrooms, 2 Bathrooms. Kitchen With Center Island, Shaker Cabinets, 42" Upper Cabinetry and Quartz Counters, Stainless Steel Appliances, Gas Range, Pantry, Full Basement With 8" Ceilings and Egress Window, One Car Garage, Hardwood Flooring, Primary Bedroom Walk In Closet, Vinyl Siding, 35 Year Architectural Roof, Construction Underway!! Make this New Home Yours !
Courtesy: Century 21 Cor Ace Realty Inc
631-878-3400
"FOR SALE" Professional Office Condos - Units 11 & 12. These Units are the Perfect Choice for Professionals and are even Medical Use Approved - This Professional Space Offers Approximately 1950 Interior Sq Ft. of Work Space and its Many Features Include: Waiting Room, Reception & Record Area, 2 Examination Rooms, Staff Lounge, 3 Bathrooms and has a Total of 4 Offices. Join a Host of Busy Professionals, Doctors, Lawyers, Etc.. Located in the William Floyd Commons, an 18,000 Sq Ft Complex. Monthly Common Area Maintenance Charge is $900 and the Common Area Maintenance Covers All Exterior Utilities, Landscaping, Garbage Pick Up, Snow Removal, Water and Fire Alarm Monitoring. 2025 Taxes are $10,997.62, and is Conveniently Located Right Off of William Floyd Parkway in a High Volume Traffic Area. Office is ADA accessible.
Courtesy: Exit Realty Liberty
631-576-4140
Charming saltbox Colonial on a Spacious Lot. Nestled on a generous third of an acre, this beautifully updated three-bedroom, two-bath home is the epitome of modern comfort and coziness. The home features gleaming wood floors, a tastefully updated kitchen with premium finishes, and fully updated bathrooms. Cac,, Leased Solar panels to help with electric cost. Hard wood floors and a pellet stove perfect for low heating cost. A full basement partially finished offers versatile space for entertainment, work, or fitness. The one-car garage provides convenience, while the backyard is an entertainer’s dream, boasting a stunning patio and cozy fire pit for year-round enjoyment, above ground pool. This home truly has it all!
Courtesy: VYLLA Home
888-575-2773
CASH ONLY!! Discover the potential of this 3-bedroom, 1-bath home at 43 Adobe Dr. Situated in a quiet neighborhood, this property offers a spacious layout and great bones, ready for your personal touch. With a little TLC, it’s an excellent opportunity for first-time buyers or savvy investors. The large backyard provides plenty of space for outdoor enjoyment. Conveniently located near local amenities, parks, and beaches. Don’t miss out on this affordable home with endless possibilities!
Courtesy: RE/MAX Integrity Leaders
631-736-2000
Charming Cape features a welcoming living room, 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, a detached 2-car garage, and a full, partially finished basement for additional living or storage space. Located just 3 miles from Smith Point Beach, this home offers a generous backyard for outdoor enjoyment and a peaceful setting near the shore.
Courtesy: Century 21 Cor Ace Realty Inc
631-878-3400
Incredible Opportunity to Purchase Established Pizzeria Business in a High Volume Traffic Vicinity with High Visibility and Foot Traffic. Offers: 2,300 Sq Ft, Fully Equipped with 4 Pizza Ovens, Display Cases, Freezer, Fully Equipped Kitchen and Seating for 16.
Courtesy: Coldwell Banker American Homes
631-331-9700
Beautifully Renovated Ranch has alot to offer. Legal 1 Bdrm Accessory Apt with private entrance. New Roof 2015- Renovations to KIchen- Granite with Porcelain tile floors. Updated Bathroom, Newly Painted, Pvc Fenced, Cesspools Maintained, Hardwood floors. Living room w/ Fplc. also extending into Bsmt. Full Basement w/OSE to and from inside of house, rough plumbing for Bathroom, w/d hook up. Outside Deck/ w hottub. Solar panels make this house a must See!!!
Courtesy: New Door Properties LLC
516-521-0334
Contract Vendee, As-Is, Sold Occupied. 7 Bedroom, 2 full bath hi-ranch. Perfect for investors!
Courtesy: Found It LLC
631-772-7800
Welcome to this stunning 5-bedroom, 4-bathroom Victorian masterpiece. This exquisite home boasts an ornate facade, complete with intricate woodwork, a steeply pitched roof, and a charming porch. Step inside to discover grand bay windows that flood the space with natural light, and rich hardwood floors throughout. The first floor features a formal living room , a stately dining room perfect for entertaining, and a beautifully updated kitchen blending with modern amenities, including high-end appliances and a spacious center island. The primary suite is complete with an en-suite bath featuring a walk-in shower and three additional large bedrooms Outside, enjoy a private backyard , perfect for gatherings or quiet evenings. This home is a rare find, combining architectural beauty, ample living space, and modern conveniences in a prime location. Don’t miss the chance to own this historic gem!”
