The median home value in Theresa, NY is $225,000.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $179,100.
The national median home value is $338,100.
The average price of homes sold in Theresa, NY is $225,000.
Approximately 38.7% of Theresa homes are owned,
compared to 16.16% rented, while
45.14% are vacant.
Theresa real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Theresa real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Courtesy: Marble Key Realty LLC
315-783-0191
Discover the essence of this property with excellent craftsmanship located on the outskirts of Theresa. This property has it all! Previously being used as a business, this building is has a open floor plan and endless potential. With a circle driveway and 2400 sq ft sitting on over 5 acres this property is a blank canvas. Be welcomed into the facility with a warm cozy entry way. But the work area is set up for ease, with easy to clean metal walls and concrete floors, 2- 12' garage doors and a separated sealed and insulated room used as a walk in cooler. This building is truly top notch, spared no cost, leaving you lots of space to turn into your dreams and no updates or repairs to worry about!
Courtesy: Marble Key Realty LLC
315-783-0191
Discover the essence of this property with excellent craftsmanship of a thriving business located on the outskirts of Theresa. Whether you are looking for a commercial building with space to grow or ready to take on it's original purpose as a butcher shop, this property is ready to make you successful. This commercial property has it all! With ample parking and 2400 sq ft sitting on over 5 acres any business has room to expand. Your clients can be welcomed into your facility with a warm cozy entry way. But the work area is set up for ease, with easy to clean metal walls and concrete floors, 2- 12' garage doors and a separated sealed and insulated room used as a walk in cooler. This building is truly top notch, spared no cost, leaving you nothing to do but move in and start operating!!
Courtesy: Lake Ontario Realty, LLC
315-649-3434
This stunning 63+ acre property offers the perfect blend of tranquility, adventure and the entertainer's dream. Nestled in nature, the land features a few apple trees, ATV trails throughout and tons of wildlife, providing a serene setting for outdoor exploration. The beautiful stone patio at the back of the home features a cozy bonfire area and a built-in grill, perfect for gathering with friends and family. On the side of the house, you will find a large structure. Originally a gift shop, the space now boasts all the charm and character you could want for entertaining, with ample space and fully equipped furnishings for any celebration or get-together. The bar features everything needed for serving guests in style. With plenty of seating and room for dancing, it offers an inviting and cozy atmosphere, whether you’re hosting a family reunion or a casual party with friends. A full gravel parking lot offers easy access and ample parking. The space is fully insulated, and a propane heater monitor ensures comfort in the winter. For modern convenience, the bar is equipped with buried cable underneath the house for seamless Wi-Fi access, ensuring you stay connected for any event needs, music, or live streaming. Whether you're hosting a special occasion or just looking for a fun place to hang out, this gift shop-turned-bar is the perfect spot, offering the perfect combination of rustic charm and modern amenities. Now let's talk about the house! The 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom ranch-style home boasts an open concept floor plan, with natural light all over. Inside, the kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring brand-new Caesarstone countertops and stainless-steel appliances. The home also features all-new, waterproof Life Proof laminate flooring throughout, offering both durability and style. A brand-new central air system to boot! With half a mile of access to Hyde Lake, you'll have easy access to the water for fishing or kayaking. The garage has two bays large enough to store your boat and vehicles in with plenty of room for a workshop! This property truly offers the best features—a private, nature-filled retreat, close to lake access and endless recreational opportunities.
Courtesy: Marble Key Realty LLC
315-783-0191
This stunning ranch-style home combines modern updates with timeless charm, just minutes from Fort Drum! The open floor plan is perfect for gatherings, featuring a spacious living area and a beautifully updated kitchen with and ample storage. Enjoy the versatility of the large, finished attic space – perfect as a 4th bedroom, home office, playroom, or guest retreat. With three cozy bedrooms on the main level, two updated bathrooms, and a convenient location near schools and amenities, this home is move-in ready and waiting for you. Many updates such as: New Front deck, back deck, exterior lights in garage, new ceiling fans, new hood range, new carpeting upstairs, whole house was painted. New Furnace and Refrigerator. 15 minutes from Fort Drum.
Courtesy: Lake Ontario Realty, LLC
315-649-3434
LAST LOT LEFT!!! Incredible lot on beautiful Lake of the Woods. 6.4 acres with 197 ft of waterfront. It's the perfect place to build your dream home or vacation home. Gorgeous granite outcroppings, mature pine, oak and white birch trees and a sandy beach waterfront makes this acreage one of a kind! This is the last remaining lot available on this pristine deep water lake with world class fishing.(Both summer and winter). Make an investment in your future! Come see the beautiful scenery and listen to the peace and quiet of the surroundings. You will fall in love!
Courtesy: NNY Homes Inc
315-782-4476
For Sale: Charming 3 Bed, 2.5 Bath Home with Dual Garages and Bonus Space! Welcome to your dream home! This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath property offers comfort, convenience, and exceptional features perfect for any lifestyle. Key Features: • Spacious Living Areas: An open floor plan with natural light, perfect for entertaining or relaxing. • Modern Kitchen: Updated appliances, ample counter space, and a layout that’s great for both cooking and gathering. • Primary Suite: A luxurious retreat with a private en-suite bath and generous closet space. • Two Additional Bedrooms: Ideal for guests or a home office. • 2.5 Baths: Convenience for everyone in the household. Garage Space & Bonus Room: • Attached 2-Car Garage: Easy access and plenty of storage. • Detached Heated Garage: Perfect for year-round use, with a finished bonus room upstairs—ideal for an office, studio, or guest suite. The property also features over 5 acres! Ideal for outdoor activities or relaxation. Conveniently located near schools, shopping, and recreation, this home offers the perfect blend of functionality and style. Contact today to schedule your private tour! Homes like this don’t last long!
Courtesy: Lake Ontario Realty, LLC
315-649-3434
This is a steal!! Explore the potential of this unique waterfront fixer-upper! This 3.30-acre property boasts 450' of Riverfront along the Indian River. With 3+ bedrooms, 1 full bath, spacious dining and living areas, a bonus room, and open/enclosed porches, this home is ready for transformation. All renovation supplies are ready to go; windows, flooring, etc., it just needs a handyman's touch to restore its beauty. Plus, it's conveniently located near Fort Drum and Watertown. Don't miss this opportunity!
Courtesy: Grey Arrow Realty, Inc.
315-921-5034
Have you been dreaming of an easily accessible lot with over 100 acres? This lot is mostly wooded, with water frontage on Indian River, and some low lying areas where water builds up during certain times of the year. With road frontage on both Schell and Rt 26 just outside of Theresa this one isn't to be missed. There is a mixture of wetlands and rock outcrops, and a place or tow to build your dream home. There are power lines and a fire hydrant on the property.
Courtesy: Whitetail Properties Real Estate LLC
217-285-9000
Nestled amidst the tranquil embrace of nature, this vacant wooded double lot offers an unparalleled opportunity to craft your dream retreat or home. Situated on State Route 37, this picturesque plots boasts towering pine trees, providing the perfect canopy and canvas for your vision. Located 13 miles from Alexandria Bay and 22 miles from Watertown allows for this location to have a country setting but close to two of the most visited and popular locations in the Thousand Island's Region. This land has a lot to offer the next owner with the possibilities it presents. This property is also just an hour from Kingston Canada, which is another frequently visited spot over the border. With vacant land becoming increasingly scarce, seize the opportunity to invest in a piece of wilderness to call your own with potential for future development or appreciation. Contact us today to see the opportunities
Courtesy: Bridgeview Real Estate
315-782-9292
Completely renovated inside & out including a finished basement & 3 car garage! Enclosed front porch finished in knotty pine has closets on both ends perfect for storage. As you enter the home the 1st floor offers an open floor plan w/hardwood floors throughout perfect for entertaining! Custom kitchen with slow close cabinets, center island plus extended breakfast bar, stainless appliances & corian counters. 1st floor laundry, pantry & full bath w/standup shower. The custom made wide staircase leads to 4 bedrooms. The primary suite offers a walk in closet, full bath w/stand up shower, dual sinks & corner jetted tub. Pull down attic stairs lead to additional storage area. The finished basement has been turned into additional living space including a bar & pool table. Outside you will have 3/4 of an acre complete w/an above ground pool that has a heater for the chilly nights, composite deck w/entertaining space, hot tub hook up, numerous berry bushes & a waterfall/pond complete w/fish! Your dream 30 x 40 garage offers 3 stalls w/openers, electricity, workshop area & a full upstairs for additional storage. Conveniently located blocks away from amenities & only 15 minutes to Fort Drum.
Courtesy: Lake Ontario Realty, LLC
315-649-3434
Step into Jezi's Cafe, a beautifully renovated unique gem that not only boasts deep roots in the community but also tells the story of its past. Jezi's was the original workshop of W.D. Chapman, known for his exquisite wooden lures, clocks, and watches circa 1890. A bronze plaque showcases its historical authenticity, a testament to its significance in the community. The exterior features a striking partial octagon design, blending historic character with contemporary flair. A standout feature is the 9’x7’ triple insulated all-glass garage door that opens to a charming patio. Venture outside to discover an enchanting outdoor space that harmonizes with nature. Enjoy the soothing sounds of a realistic man-made waterfall, while kids explore the play zone. The outdoor area is perfect for entertaining, featuring a pull-down movie screen, cascading multi-level deck seating, an outdoor concrete bar, a cozy covered lounge, and a fire pit for those cooler evenings. Jezi's is a truly unique venue, ideal for hosting events and celebrations, where history and nature intertwine beautifully. All equipment and furnishings stay! It’s truly a turn key operation! If you're seeking an opportunity to invest in up-and-coming community, contact your agent today!
Courtesy: Marble Key Realty LLC
315-783-0191
Welcome to this beautifully remodeled 3-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom home in the Village of Theresa! This home offers modern updates throughout, creating a fresh and inviting atmosphere. The kitchen features updated cabinetry countertops and appliances, while the cozy living area is perfect for relaxation. The full basement offers endless potential to expand your living space or add additional rooms. Outside, enjoy a fenced-in yard ideal for privacy and outdoor activities. Conveniently located just 20 minutes from Fort Drum, it’s an easy commute to work and nearby amenities. New metal roof, new oil furnace and kitchen remodeled all in 2018. New heated, 1-stall detached garage with metal roof built in 2022. Quaint, wood burning fire place is very efficient, heats the whole home and limits fuel use
Courtesy: Marble Key Realty LLC
315-783-0191
Discover your own private oasis on this stunning 16.6-acre lot, perfectly situated along a serene lake. This property offers a rare combination of breathtaking waterfront views, lush surroundings, and unparalleled tranquility. With 16.6 acres, there’s plenty of room to explore, build, or create your dream retreat. Enjoy your own private beach area, perfect for swimming, fishing, or simply relaxing by the water. Fresh Water Spring: Experience the tranquility of nature with a fresh water spring on the property, providing a serene atmosphere and natural beauty. A preliminary driveway has been established, offering convenient access to the lot and making it easier to envision your future home. Escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life in this peaceful, secluded setting, surrounded by nature and wildlife. It is an ideal choice for those seeking a truly off-grid lifestyle or a chance to design a sustainable living space. Whether you’re looking to build a dream home, a cozy cabin, or simply want a personal retreat, this lakefront lot offers endless possibilities. Embrace the beauty of nature and create your own sanctuary in this idyllic setting!
Courtesy: Grey Arrow Realty, Inc.
315-921-5034
Have you been searching for a spacious home with tons of layout options. This was a duplex at one time, and could likely be changed back by adding a kitchen and a door. However, as a single family home this home has 2 bedrooms on the main level, one with an attached half bath. A laundry room. A spacious living room with pellet stove and a dining room and kitchen. There is also a lovely 3 season room with lots of light. Upstairs you'll find a large landing, that is still plumbed as a kitchen, a large closet that was a laundry room, 2 bedrooms and a sitting room along with another full bath. There is electric heaters in most rooms, along with baseboard heat. There is also a pellet stove in the living room to keep you extra warm. There is an attached 2 car garage with covered space for additional parking for lawn mower, or whatever you need it for. There are two driveways, one is shared. Spacious rooms, large lot and lots of parking.
Courtesy: Staie on the Seaway Real Estate Services RES, LLC.
315-482-4590
Great opportunity to move your offices to this amazing office building. Offering eight offices, a full bath, kitchenette and conference area. Building is made from poured concrete walls, so very efficent for heating and cooling. The furnace is FWA with LP Gas and has central air. There is an automatic generator. Nice covered porch on the front and a concrete patio off the rear. Black top driveway offering eight parking spaces. Great location at Coopers Corners just off State Route 37. Must see newer built office building.
Courtesy: Bennett Realty Group LLC
315-259-1516
Stunning waterfront property awaits your dream home. Relish in breathtaking sunsets and abundant wildlife. Just a short drive away, explore the scenic Adirondack Mountains, perfect for sightseeing and hiking adventures.Situated on 1.6 acres the seller has already cleared a building spot.Call for more information.
Courtesy: Matteson Property Management, LLC
315-767-9878
2.11 acres of buildable land with beautiful scenery. Take advantage of the beauty of being in the country but within driving distance of restaurants, shopping, and entertainment. This property offers the ability of building your new forever home while also having a spacious and beautiful, partially wooded backyard.
Courtesy: Lake Ontario Realty, LLC
315-649-3434
Your private Indian River getaway awaits! This rare affordable waterfront lot is ready for a new owner. Imagine kayaking, fishing, and swimming on your own land. This would be a great lot to build a camp! The Indian River offers a quiet location and scenic views of wildlife. Many species of fish call the Indian River home including bass, pike, walleye, bullhead, crappie, rockbass, and more! Priced below the assessed value! Call today!
Courtesy: North Star Real Estate & Property Management
315-777-4365
Looking for a unique business opportunity in a thriving community? Look no further! This fully renovated, turnkey bowling alley in the heart of Theresa, NY, is now available for sale. Situated on a spacious 2.20-acre lot, this property is not just a bowling alley—it's a full-fledged entertainment hub! - **Prime Location:** This property offers excellent visibility and easy access, making it a local favorite and a destination for visitors. **Completely Renovated: With over a million dollars invested in renovations, everything is brand new! From the new propane furnace, A/C, and roofing, to the brand-new kitchen and gleaming wood lanes, no expense has been spared. Beyond bowling, this venue hosts live bands and comedy shows, offering a lively atmosphere for all ages. The on-site kitchen serves a delicious menu, complemented by a well-stocked bar offering a variety of drinks.This business is fully operational and ready for you to step in and start earning. With all the hard work already done, you can focus on continuing to grow this vibrant community hotspot.Call today to schedule a showing!
Courtesy: Door to Door Realty
315-786-6666
Don't Miss out on this one. Home features 4 bedrooms and three full baths. Enter the house into the formal dining room that passes through to the large kitchen with an island. There is an addition that includes a large living room with cathedral ceilings and primary suite that also has French doors that lead to a huge deck to simply relax. The basement has another bedroom with sliding glass doors that lead to the back yard. Home has beautiful curb appeal, with a great covered front porch that is partially enclosed with screens. There is a detached two stall garage and paved driveway, all situated on just under three acres.
Courtesy: TLC Real Estate LLC - Carthage
315-493-1111
Welcome home to this 4 Bedroom / 2 bath home with detached 20 X 20 garage situated on just over 4 acres of land in Theresa. Enjoy Village amenities such as public water, public sewer and Theresa Municipal Power but have that Country setting to call home! The Soapstone Creek flows thru the property so you can enjoy fishing, watching the water flow or the tranquility of listening to nature. The home has an open floor plan of the main living area which consists of a modern kitchen with a large island and walk in pantry, formal dining area and spacious living room. The primary bedroom has a walk in closet and spacious bathroom with dual vanity. The other end of the home has 3 bedrooms, a full bath and separate laundry room. This home is in Indian River School District. Propane Forced air furnace. Located about 20 minutes from the Fort Drum gates. Schedule your showing today!
Courtesy: Bridgeview Real Estate
315-782-9292
Looking to own a bit of history? This over 4500 square foot church was built in 1870 & has been kept in the most pristine condition. From the concrete covered entry to the brick facade, from the stunning wood cathedral ceilings to the impressive stained-glass windows this building boats of times past. Located in the business district this building offers endless possibilities. As you enter through the original solid wood doors there is large room currently used as a nursery to the right, a 1/2 bath & office to the left plus pull down stairs for additional storage. then you enter the sanctuary where it opens to the great room complete with vaulted ceilings & seating for 120. In the back is the altar/stage & another room to the side which is currently used as a classroom. The metal roof is only 8 years old, 2 new furnaces are only 3 years old & baseboard heat was installed in the nursery. Stone parking area offers ample parking for 20 or more vehicles. Priced less than assessment.
Courtesy: Bridgeview Real Estate
315-782-9292
Commercial building for sale in the heart of Theresa. Endless opportunities await in this prime location complete with a 2nd lot and ample parking for numerous vehicles. Large common area, breakfast bar leads to kitchen, & a back office. A handicap bathroom with stand up shower & another 1/2 bath. Separate storage room & also exterior storage room. Many updates have been done including new insulation, sheetrock, windows, plumbing & baseboard electric heat. A new kitchen was installed complete with appliances. There used to be an overhead door/garage area which the door was removed & interior turned into finished space but could easily be switched back. Priced less than assessment this is the perfect time to scoop up this commercial space & take advantage of the high traffic exposure for your business!
Courtesy: Bridgeview Real Estate-Clayton
315-686-5500
Check out this great spot with waterfront on the Indian River. This would be the perfect place for a house or a camp. The river is perfect for canoes and kayaks and also some good fishing. Call to take a look today!
Courtesy: eXp Realty
888-276-0630
Discover the perfect blend of comfort and convenience in this fully renovated 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home. With an impressive 2187 sqft layout, this home features a stunning open-concept kitchen, dining, and living area, complete with stainless steel appliances and sleek hardwood floors. Enjoy the practicality of a mudroom and an attached garage, enhancing your daily convenience. Nature lovers will revel in the property’s exclusive 133 feet of waterfront on the scenic Indian River, perfect for tranquil mornings. Your new home is designed for all seasons, equipped with new spray foam insulation and a powerful 14,000 BTU window air conditioner ensuring year-round comfort. Located within walking distance to Theresa Primary School, post office and downtown. The backyard offers a fully fenced area. Offering an assumable mortgage at 5.6% and a seller open to negotiation, this property is not only a peaceful haven but also a smart financial choice. Experience budget-friendly living with municipal power which is reduced electrical costs. Don't miss out on this incredible opportunity—your dream home awaits! Seller to credit buyer $1k for propane. Located just 15 minutes from Fort Drum.
