The median home value in Carey, OH is $125,000.
This is
lower than
the county median home value of $153,400.
The national median home value is $338,100.
The average price of homes sold in Carey, OH is $125,000.
Approximately 54.51% of Carey homes are owned,
compared to 35.34% rented, while
10.15% are vacant.
Carey real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Carey real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Courtesy: WMS Marketing Services
419-294-4366
Secluded Ranch Home / Mini Farm This property offers the following features: 1,840 Sq. Ft. Brick Ranch, 3 BR, 2 Full Baths, Main Floor Laundry, Modern Kitchen w/Open Floorplan to Living Space, 5+ Car Attached Heated Garage, 20x20 Storage Pole Barn, 54x60 Storage Pole Barn w/Heated Livestock Washroom, 36x64 Cattle / Livestock Pole Building w/Outdoor Pasture Area. 3.51 Acres which includes a 900+ Foot Lane which Offers a Very Private Setting. This is a well kept modern mini farm. Please call ahead for a private showing. 24 Hour Notice Required.
Courtesy: Walton Realty & Auction
419-294-0007
Spacious and charming, this 2+ story large-frame home in Carey, Ohio, offers a perfect blend of comfort and character. Featuring 3 bedrooms and 1.5 baths, this home boasts a shingle roof and a welcoming front porch ideal for relaxing evenings. The property includes a 20'x21' garage and a handy shed for extra storage. Inside, you’ll find a full basement and beautiful woodwork throughout, adding warmth and charm to the home. With its generous space and thoughtful details, this property is ready to become your dream home.
Courtesy: Key Realty
419-857-1435
Lovely property located in the heart of Carey! This home features a large combined kitchen dining area, two downstairs bedrooms, a convenient utility room, and an attached garage. Lots of unique build ins upstairs along with plenty of storage. Newer furnace, water heater, water softener, and generac whole house generator. Well taken care of home. Must see!
Courtesy: BHHS Koehler Realty
419-422-4082
Great investment opportunity. 5 unit property at 517 E Findlay St Carey. All 5 units are rented and barn out back can be rented separately. Each unit has a bedroom, bathroom and kitchen area. Tenants right apply.
Courtesy: Regina Vent Realty
419-294-2000
Discover serenity in this delightful split level ranch home sitting on a 4.57-acre wooded lot with large mature trees. The home has 2650 sq. ft. living area, 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, 2 (1/2) baths, living room, eat-in kitchen, formal dining room, family room with fireplace, large walk-in pantry, laundry room, closed in back porch, oversized 2 car garage with shop space. The 3 outbuildings include a barn with a hay mow and attached corn crib, a shed (tack room/chicken coop) and a two-bay garage with storage. Enjoy sitting on the front or back patio areas watching the sunrises and sunsets!
Courtesy: Regina Vent Realty
419-294-2000
Tons of potential, it's a must see!! The main level includes all the restaurant equipment you will need as you start up your new business in the heart of Carey. Included: mega vent, grill vent, walk in cooler and freezer, 2-40lbs deep fryers, BBQ, 3 compartment wash sink, sandwich unit, griddle, smoke house, tables & chairs, plenty of prep space and 2 handicap accessible restrooms. Additional storage space in the back with plenty of parking. A private stairway will lead you upstairs offering a full bath and tons of space, let your imagination run wild.. Selling as is- sqft is approx.
Courtesy: American Heritage Realty
419-435-6677
Welcome to 619 W. Findlay St. This home offers 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths with spacious rooms to spread out. Laundry on the main floor. Two car detached garage as well as a large pole barn that was built in 2015. This home sits on a little over half of an acre. Enjoy your evenings on the deck overlooking your property. Don't miss out on your opportunity to own this beautiful home. Also includes parcel #1008900200000.
Courtesy: CCR Realty
419-222-0555
Information taken from Auditor website. Room sizes approximate Schedule showings thru Showing Time
Courtesy: BHHS Koehler Realty
419-422-4082
One owner home on 6.739 acres. Living room w/gas fireplace. Large kitchen w/all the appliances and lots of storage. Office w/access to bath. 4 bedrooms upstairs including the master bedroom. The family room features a full stone wall wood-burning fireplace. Basement just waiting for your touch. Enjoy sitting on the front porch or the private backyard patio and koi pond. Don't miss the 45x126 metal pole building-just a few features include a man cave w/bar and wood burner, workshop, office space and 1/2 bath. Please request additional information sheet for list of all the great amenities.
Courtesy: WMS Marketing Services
419-294-4366
18.72 Acres Available w/smaller divisions available. Located on the edge of Carey, Ohio with easy access to US 23 / OH 15 next to retail and food chain businesses. Agent Owned
Lot #67 (Phase 11) - 122.37'x178.61' Building Lot in Carey, Ohio on Summer Drive. Located in a newly developed / developing neighborhood with easy access to State Routes 15, 23, 199, 103 & 568.All closings to be held at Beck & Martin, llc - Carey, OH. Buyers to pay for title insurance.
Courtesy: Key Realty
419-857-1435
Lot 67 Phase 11 122.37'x178.61' Building Lot in Carey, OH on Summer Drive. Located in Newly Developed / Developing Neighborhood with Easy Access to State Route 15, 23, 199, 103 and 568. All Closing to be Held at Beck & Martin LLC in Carey, OH. Buyers to pay for Title Insurance.
Courtesy: Key Realty
419-857-1435
Lot 22 Phase 11 120'x160' Building Lot in Carey, OH on Summer Drive. Located in Newly Developed / Developing Neighborhood with Easy Access to State Route 15, 23, 199, 103 and 568. Buyers to pay for Title Insurance.
Courtesy: Key Realty
419-857-1435
Lot 21 Phase 11 157.39'x160.49' Building Lot in Carey, OH on Summer Drive. Located in Newly Developed / Developing Neighborhood with Easy Access to State Route 15, 23, 199, 103 and 568. Buyers to pay for Title Insurance.
Courtesy: Key Realty
419-857-1435
Lot 20 Phase 11 137.70'x160.58' Building Lot in Carey, OH on Summer Drive. Located in Newly Developed / Developing Neighborhood with Easy Access to State Route 15, 23, 199, 103 and 568. Buyers to pay for Title Insurance.
Courtesy: Key Realty
419-857-1435
Lot 19 Phase 11 137.70'x160.65' Building Lot in Carey, OH on Summer Drive. Located in Newly Developed / Developing Neighborhood with Easy Access to State Route 15, 23, 199, 103 and 568.. Buyers to pay for Title Insurance.
Courtesy: Key Realty
419-857-1435
Lot 18 Phase 11 150'x143.82' Building Lot in Carey, OH on Summer Drive. Located in Newly Developed / Developing Neighborhood with Easy Access to State Route 15, 23, 199, 103 and 568. Buyers to pay for Title Insurance.
Courtesy: Key Realty
419-857-1435
Lot 17 Phase 11 149'x162.90' Building Lot in Carey, OH on Summer Drive. Located in Newly Developed / Developing Neighborhood with Easy Access to State Route 15, 23, 199, 103 and 568. Buyers to pay for Title Insurance.
Courtesy: Key Realty
419-857-1435
Lot 16 Phase 11 100'x162.90' Building Lot in Carey, OH on Summer Drive. Located in a Newly Developed / Developing Neighborhood with easy Access to State Route 15, 23, 199, 103 and 568. Buyers to pay For Title Insurance.
Courtesy: Scalf Realty Group
937-470-7879
This Victorian Beauty is now available in Carey! Home features a welcoming front porch and a gorgeous entryway with beautiful original woodwork, transom window above the doorway and an open staircase. The stained glass windows add to the charm, as do the pocket doors. Original hardwood floors on the main floor living and family rooms. Original woodwork throughout. On the main floor there is a half bath and laundry and a large eat-in kitchen with oak cabinets. Upstairs you will find 3 bedroom and a good-sized bathroom, all with original doors and woodwork. There is also a large storage room. The garage is a wood workers dream, 28' x 34' and is insulated and heated with lots of storage. Concrete pad for parking multiple cars/campers, etc. Fenced back and side yard. The furniture in the garage and house is currently for sale and negotiable. Agent is related to the seller.
Courtesy: Key Realty
419-857-1435
Lot #15 (Phase 9)- 100'x157.53' Building Lot in Carey, Ohio on Summer Drive. Located in a newly developed / developing neighborhood with easy access to State Routes 15, 23, 199, 103 & 568. Buyers to pay for title insurance.
Courtesy: Key Realty
419-857-1435
Lot #56 - 120' x 160' Building Lot in Carey, Ohio on Autumn Avenue. Located in a newly developed / developing neighborhood with easy access to State Routes 15, 23, 199, 103 & 568. Buyers to pay for title insurance.
Courtesy: Key Realty
419-857-1435
Lot #57 - 120' x 160' Building Lot in Carey, Ohio on Autumn Avenue. Located in a newly developed / developing neighborhood with easy access to State Routes 15, 23, 199, 103 & 568. Buyers to pay for title insurance.
Courtesy: Key Realty
419-857-1435
Lot #85 - 100' x 160' Building Lot in Carey, Ohio on Autumn Avenue. Located in a newly developed / developing neighborhood with easy access to State Routes 15, 23, 199, 103 & 568. We are here to help you find the builder that fits your needs. Buyers to pay for title insurance.
Andrea D. Conner, License BRKP.2017002935, Xome Inc., License REC.2015001703, [email protected], 844-400-XOME (9663), 11427 Read Hartman Hwy, Suite 236, Cincinnati, OH 45241
Information is provided exclusively for consumers personal, non - commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Copyright 2025, Firelands Association of REALTORS, all rights reserved.
Andrea D. Conner, License BRKP.2017002935, Xome Inc., License REC.2015001703, [email protected], 844-400-XOME (9663), 11427 Read Hartman Hwy, Suite 236, Cincinnati, OH 45241
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website is provided courtesy of Dayton REALTORS® MLS IDX Database. Real estate listings from the Dayton REALTORS® MLS IDX Database held by brokerage firms other than Xome, Inc. are marked with the IDX logo and are provided by the Dayton REALTORS® MLS IDX Database. Information is provided for consumers` personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in. Copyright © 2025 Dayton REALTORS. All rights reserved.
