The median home value in Newcomerstown, OH is $150,000.
This is
lower than
the county median home value of $169,900.
The national median home value is $338,100.
The average price of homes sold in Newcomerstown, OH is $150,000.
Approximately 60.39% of Newcomerstown homes are owned,
compared to 32.89% rented, while
6.72% are vacant.
Newcomerstown real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Newcomerstown real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Dream Home on 14.4 Acres – Your Private Oasis Awaits! Welcome to a property that offers endless opportunities and incredible potential! This spacious 5-bedroom, 4.5-bathroom Cape Cod-style home is nestled on 14.4 picturesque acres, providing the perfect blend of open spaces, mature woods, and serene beauty. Home Features: 5 Bedrooms and 4.5 Bathrooms – Plenty of room for family, guests, or flexible living arrangements. Fully finished basement, offering additional living or recreational space. Oversized garage, perfect for vehicles, storage, or hobbies. Outdoor Highlights: Expansive 14.4-acre property with a mix of open fields and wooded areas, including mature trees. A large pole barn, ideal for storage, projects, or hobbies. Abundant wildlife and deer signs, making this property a hunter's paradise or nature enthusiast’s retreat. Whether you're seeking a private escape, a place to enjoy outdoor activities, or a smart investment with tons of upside, this property delivers it all. Don't miss out on this rare opportunity—schedule your private showing today and make your dreams a reality!
Auction 12/6/2024 11:00 AM - Parcel 9: 6.3 Acres w/ 500’ frontage. Open w/ Well & Septic - A great opportunity to purchase a family-owned generational farm ideal for hunting and recreation with parcels ranging in size from 6 to 33.6 acres. The property features mostly wooded land with good young growth of hardwood timber, trails, a fixer upper home, an older barn, and shop. This farm provides plenty of road frontage and private building sites for country homes or cabins. Join us for the preview day or contact agents for a private showing as the family will be hunting the property until sale day. Immediate hunting rights will be granted. Sellers will retain mineral rights.
Auction 12/6/2024 11:00 AM - Parcel 8: 33.6 Acres w/ 236’ frontage. Mostly Wooded - A great opportunity to purchase a family-owned generational farm ideal for hunting and recreation with parcels ranging in size from 6 to 33.6 acres. The property features mostly wooded land with good young growth of hardwood timber, trails, a fixer upper home, an older barn, and shop. This farm provides plenty of road frontage and private building sites for country homes or cabins. Join us for the preview day or contact agents for a private showing as the family will be hunting the property until sale day. Immediate hunting rights will be granted. Sellers will retain mineral rights.
Auction 12/6/2024 11:00 AM - Parcel 7: 7.1 Acres w/ 468’ frontage. Home & Shop - A great opportunity to purchase a family-owned generational farm ideal for hunting and recreation with parcels ranging in size from 6 to 33.6 acres. The property features mostly wooded land with good young growth of hardwood timber, trails, a fixer upper home, an older barn, and shop. This farm provides plenty of road frontage and private building sites for country homes or cabins. Join us for the preview day or contact agents for a private showing as the family will be hunting the property until sale day. Immediate hunting rights will be granted. Sellers will retain mineral rights.
Auction Dec 16. Summary: These 54 acres are loaded with Wildlife! There is fenced pasture for your animals, pole barns for the animals and equipment and a 1997 Redman Doublewide-4BR 2 Bath Home. The home needs some updates but could be a great family home or hunting cabin. You will love the quick access off the main road, yet pretty secluded for that great place to reside in solitude or have a fabulous place to hunt! Immediate hunting rights with valid down payment!! A mix of mid-size growing trees, deer bedding areas. A sweet piece of land in a great location! Use of free gas as per lease. Owned rights will transfer-currently held by production. Please call before walking the property
3 Parcels Located in Newcomerstown totaling 1.92 acres City water and sewage are available at Bridge street. Call your local agent to walk the property
AMERICAN CRAFTSMAN ARCHITECTURE AT ITS FINEST! Beautiful original woodwork, pocket doors, bookcases, professionally refinished floors. Extra deep private porch. Impressive leaded front door/side lights. Foyer entrance, closet & seat storage. Open to liv room w/fireplace, bookcases. Lg formal din room, pocket doors, fireplace, leaded bookcases, coffered ceiling. White eat-in kitchen, appliances pantry, ceramic fls. Both bathrooms w/quality renovation,tiles & fixtures. 2nd fl has an open concept hallway, 3 lg bedrooms/storage.Most cedar lined closets.Lg. 2nd floor laundry, cabinets. This room could double as an office/hobby room. Bright light highlights the stained glass window on the open staircase landing. Fireplaces have not been used. MANY UPDATES: House roof & garage 2014, gutters, soil pipe, water lines, carpet baths. New boiler Jan. 2024. Central air in entire house. Updated H20 heater. The house has been rewired. Kitchen appliances 2018. Most recent updates: electrical, new back porch, fence, garage door/opener, front porch new stain, plumbing, water softener. This home has been totally redone. It is a clean, move-in condition property. Convenient location. Seller purchased January, 2024. Seller circumstances have changed. No fault of the property.
On-site auction Friday, December 13th at 2:00 PM. This 6.9 acre building lot is perfect for those looking to build in a serene rural setting. 765’ of frontage on Post Boy Road, and 410’ of frontage on Kedigh Hollow Rd SW. Address is for location purposes and does not constitute a mailing address.
On-site auction Friday, December 13th at 2:00 PM. This tract offers 13.5 acres w/575’ of frontage on Post Boy Road. Featuring a 42’x50’ bank barn, several outbuildings, concrete silo, open fields, and partially wooded areas. This versatile lot is ideal for a hunting tract, or a scenic place to build a home. Address is for location purposes and does not constitute a mailing address.
On-site auction Friday, December 13th at 2:00 PM. This tract offers 31.3 acres w/1,148’ of frontage on Post Boy Rd. Perfect for recreational use or hunting, featuring well-maintained trails, harvestable timber, and open fields. Address is for location purposes and does not constitute a mailing address.
On-site auction Friday, December 13th at 2:00 PM. 19.1 acres w/1,180’ of frontage on Post Boy Rd. Currently an agricultural field, this parcel lends itself to either an excellent building lot or expand your agricultural portfolio. Parcel is nearby or adjacent to this address.
On-site auction Friday, December 13th at 2:00 PM. 33.1 acres w/50’ access point from Post Boy Rd. An excellent recreational tract with a mix of wooded sections, trails and open areas. Offering field edge hunting or hilltop food plots. Parcel is nearby or adjacent to this address.
On-site auction Friday, December 13th at 2:00 PM. This tract is 5.4-acres w/515’ of frontage on Post Boy Rd. Flat building lot currently used as farmland. Enjoy peaceful country scenes, ideal for a future homesite. Parcel is nearby or adjacent to this address.
On-site auction Friday, December 13th at 2:00 PM. 5.1-acre building lot w/350’+/- along Kedigh Hollow Rd, each offering excellent country views in a peaceful, rural environment. A fantastic option for families or investors looking to build in a quiet country setting. Address is for location purposes and does not constitute a mailing address.
On-site auction Friday, December 13th at 2:00 PM. 5.1-acre building lot w/350’+/- along Kedigh Hollow Rd, each offering excellent country views in a peaceful, rural environment. A fantastic option for families or investors looking to build in a quiet country setting. Address is for location purposes and does not constitute a mailing address.
On-site auction Friday, December 13th at 2:00 PM. 5.1-acre building lot w/350’+/- along Kedigh Hollow Rd, each offering excellent country views in a peaceful, rural environment. A fantastic option for families or investors looking to build in a quiet country setting. Address is for location purposes and does not constitute a mailing address.
On-site auction Friday, December 13th at 2:00 PM. 46.9 acres w/50’ of frontage accessed from Kedigh Hollow Rd. Mostly wooded, this recreational paradise includes large harvestable hardwoods, and several food plot areas, making it a prime choice for hunting enthusiasts. Address is for location purposes and does not constitute a mailing address.
On-site auction Friday, December 13th at 2:00 PM. This expansive 175+ acre property is divided into 11 distinct parcels and offers a perfect blend of rural charm, investment potential, and recreational opportunities. Whether you’re seeking farmland, a secluded building site, or prime hunting land with mature harvestable timber, this property has something to fit every need and budget. Lot's of road frontage on two roads gives options for everyone. Featuring a well maintained 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom home and a spacious barn that’s perfect for storing equipment. Move-in ready and full of charm here’s a small country home along with a 42’x50’ bank barn, several outbuildings & concrete silo, open fields, and partially wooded areas. Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own your own farm in the countryside. Furthering the investment potential, 50% of the mineral rights will transfer to the new buyer. Call today or attend the open house to learn more about these parcels and see which one is right for you!
On-site auction Friday, December 13th at 2:00 PM. 5.1 acres w/375’ of frontage on Post Boy Road. Featuring a well maintained 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom home and a spacious barn that’s perfect for storing equipment. Move-in ready and full of charm here’s a small country home with a spacious lot. Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own a slice of the countryside. Call today or attend the open house to learn more about this parcel!
Auction 12/6/2024 11:00 AM - Parcel 6: 27.3 Acres w/ 193’ frontage. Mostly Wooded - A great opportunity to purchase a family-owned generational farm ideal for hunting and recreation with parcels ranging in size from 6 to 33.6 acres. The property features mostly wooded land with good young growth of hardwood timber, trails, a fixer upper home, an older barn, and shop. This farm provides plenty of road frontage and private building sites for country homes or cabins. Join us for the preview day or contact agents for a private showing as the family will be hunting the property until sale day. Immediate hunting rights will be granted. Sellers will retain mineral rights. Open for Inspection: Monday November 25th – 2:00 to 4:00 PM
Auction 12/6/2024 11:00 AM - Parcel 5: 24.1 Acres w/ 252’ frontage. Mostly Wooded - A great opportunity to purchase a family-owned generational farm ideal for hunting and recreation with parcels ranging in size from 6 to 33.6 acres. The property features mostly wooded land with good young growth of hardwood timber, trails, a fixer upper home, an older barn, and shop. This farm provides plenty of road frontage and private building sites for country homes or cabins. Join us for the preview day or contact agents for a private showing as the family will be hunting the property until sale day. Immediate hunting rights will be granted. Sellers will retain mineral rights. Open for Inspection: Monday November 25th – 2:00 to 4:00 PM
Auction 12/6/2024 11:00 AM - Parcel 4: 7 Acres w/ 304’ frontage. Open & Wooded w/ Barn - A great opportunity to purchase a family-owned generational farm ideal for hunting and recreation with parcels ranging in size from 6 to 33.6 acres. The property features mostly wooded land with good young growth of hardwood timber, trails, a fixer upper home, an older barn, and shop. This farm provides plenty of road frontage and private building sites for country homes or cabins. Join us for the preview day or contact agents for a private showing as the family will be hunting the property until sale day. Immediate hunting rights will be granted. Sellers will retain mineral rights. Open for Inspection: Monday November 25th – 2:00 to 4:00 PM
Auction 12/6/2024 11:00 AM - Parcel 3: 17.3 Acres w/ 50’ frontage. Mostly Wooded - A great opportunity to purchase a family-owned generational farm ideal for hunting and recreation with parcels ranging in size from 6 to 33.6 acres. The property features mostly wooded land with good young growth of hardwood timber, trails, a fixer upper home, an older barn, and shop. This farm provides plenty of road frontage and private building sites for country homes or cabins. Join us for the preview day or contact agents for a private showing as the family will be hunting the property until sale day. Immediate hunting rights will be granted. Sellers will retain mineral rights. Open for Inspection: Monday November 25th – 2:00 to 4:00 PM
Auction 12/6/2024 11:00 AM - Parcel 2: 6.2 Acres w/ 439’ frontage. Mostly Wooded - A great opportunity to purchase a family-owned generational farm ideal for hunting and recreation with parcels ranging in size from 6 to 33.6 acres. The property features mostly wooded land with good young growth of hardwood timber, trails, a fixer upper home, an older barn, and shop. This farm provides plenty of road frontage and private building sites for country homes or cabins. Join us for the preview day or contact agents for a private showing as the family will be hunting the property until sale day. Immediate hunting rights will be granted. Sellers will retain mineral rights. Open for Inspection: Monday November 25th – 2:00 to 4:00 PM
Auction 12/6/2024 11:00 AM - Parcel 1: 6 Acres w/ 356’ frontage. All Wooded - A great opportunity to purchase a family-owned generational farm ideal for hunting and recreation with parcels ranging in size from 6 to 33.6 acres. The property features mostly wooded land with good young growth of hardwood timber, trails, a fixer upper home, an older barn, and shop. This farm provides plenty of road frontage and private building sites for country homes or cabins. Join us for the preview day or contact agents for a private showing as the family will be hunting the property until sale day. Immediate hunting rights will be granted. Sellers will retain mineral rights. Open for Inspection: Monday November 25th – 2:00 to 4:00 PM
