Courtesy: River Hills Properties LLC Lf
315-508-5268
Commanding the corner in the heart of Historic Cherry Valley, 1 Main Street is a landmark mixed-use investment property offering over 9,000 square feet of income-producing space. This impressive multi-story brick building blends timeless architecture with strong commercial visibility, featuring a ground-level storefront and 9+ residential apartments above. Its prominent Main Street location places tenants and customers within steps of village shops, dining, and local amenities, while the building’s classic brick façade, wraparound porches, and corner presence create undeniable curb appeal. The scale and layout of the property present exceptional flexibility for investors seeking steady rental income, future value-add potential, or a flagship asset in a charming historic community. With multiple revenue streams already established and room to enhance long-term returns, this is a rare opportunity to own one of Cherry Valley’s signature buildings. Whether expanding a portfolio or securing a cornerstone investment in a desirable village setting, 1 Main Street delivers location, character, and opportunity in one compelling package.
Courtesy: Cooperstown Brokers, LLC
607-435-9288
The Historic Tryon Inn & Back Door Bar in Cherry Valley, NY: this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to acquire the venerable Tryon Inn, a cornerstone of the charming, historic village of Cherry Valley. More than just a building, this is a turnkey, fully renovated, and well-established business that serves as the beloved social hub of the community and a destination for travelers along scenic Route 20. While historically operating as a tavern, you may have a vision for a brew pub, with loads of parking and indoor and outdoor space for entertainment. Cherry Valley is a community of very involved residents, artists, musicians, teachers, tradespeople and business owners. With an eclectic population and beautiful farming countryside, Cherry Valley is a peaceful town to live and work. Investment Highlights • Turn-Key Business: 129 seat restaurant, plus the lively 34-seat Back Door Bar and the outdoor patio seating for 32 in the warm months. • Large sparkling kitchen is fully equipped, bright and completely up to date. • The current structure, built around 1900 on the site of the original 1780s tavern, is steeped in local history and Colonial Revival charm, attracting history buffs and patrons seeking an authentic upstate experience. • Strategically located on Main Street in the heart of historic Cherry Valley, an area famous for its proximity to Cooperstown (Baseball Hall of Fame, Glimmerglass Opera) and stunning upstate scenery. • Significant Real Estate totaling 5,048 sq ft in the tavern building alone, on a generous 4.25-acre lot, offering ample space and expansion potential. The additional circa 1800 federal style “Inn” building measures an additional 2400 sq ft over two stories. The “Inn” building is freestanding and separate from the turnkey tavern establishment and needs restoration/renovation in order to operate. This is your chance to own a piece of New York state history and step into a successful, cash-flowing business. The Tryon Inn is the definitive social anchor of Cherry Valley, poised for continued success under new ownership. Maintain the beloved local tradition or evolve the concept—the groundwork is laid for your triumph.
Courtesy: Benson Agency Real Estate LLC
607-432-4391
This former church sits on more than a half acre with great visibility and proximity to Cherry Valley, Oneonta and Cooperstown! Charming interior with stained glass windows, metal ceilings and a beautiful sanctuary space plus a large kitchen area. The open floor plan has the potential to be transformed into a unique residence, an artist's studio, a charming gallery space or a multitude of other uses. Property is being sold "AS IS". Call me for more details. Property is church-owned, therefore currently tax exempt but with an assessment of $90,100 with a FMV of $128,714 and may take a couple of months to close. There is no septic.
Endless opportunity in this 2,920 sqft commercial property, currently a tavern, on a .66-acre corner lot with private parking and municipal water. The two-story building offers versatile space and endless potential. The main level features seating for 70, a stunning classic bar, and fully equipped kitchen. Upstairs offers two bedrooms, full bath—perfect potential owner's residence or rental income. With its vibrant structure and adaptable layout, this building offers limitless potential for many uses. Located in a charming, culturally rich village of Cherry Valley—known for natural beauty, historic heritage, and vibrant arts scene—this property is surrounded by year-round events, shops, and a welcoming community. A short drive to Cooperstown's Dream Park, Opera, and Baseball Hall of Fame.
 |
| © 2026 Greater Capital Association of REALTORS (CRMLSNY). All rights reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website have been downloaded from CRMLS. The IDX logo indicates listings of other real estate firms that are identified in the detailed listing information. Information herein is deemed reliable but not guaranteed, representations are approximate, individual verification's recommended. Per New York legal requirement, click here for the Standard Operating Procedures. |
Cherry Valley is located in New York. Cherry Valley, New York has a population of 1,054. Cherry Valley is more family-centric than the surrounding county with 25.61% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 24%.
The median household income in Cherry Valley, New York is $68,542. The median household income for the surrounding county is $60,523 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Cherry Valley is 43.9 years.
The average high temperature in July is 77.8 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 12.9 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 44.9 inches per year, with 94.2 inches of snow per year.
