Courtesy: Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties
607-431-2540
Located in the heart of downtown Oneonta, 373-375 Main Street presents a rare opportunity to own a landmark mixed-use property that has been lovingly maintained and has not been on the market for over 50 years. Opportunities like this simply do not come along often. Major capital improvements have already been completed, including over $100,000 invested in updated HVAC systems featuring 4 separate forced hot air furnaces, with central air conditioning serving the first-floor spaces. The exterior was freshly scraped, primed, and painted with two coats in September 2025, giving the building outstanding curb appeal and long-term protection. 5ft White vinyl fence professionally installed July 2023. New flooring in the kitchen and bathroom of unit #3 upstairs apartment (Spring 2026). Additional updates include upgraded first-floor electric, four separate 100-amp electric panels, a replaced side roof, new garage door, freshly painted interiors, new carpeting throughout with original oak floors underneath, and a professionally sealed and striped parking lot with 12 spaces completed in October 2024. The property offers the perfect blend of historic character, strong visibility, flexible space, and extensive infrastructure improvements already in place. Positioned directly on Main Street with excellent exposure, this is an exceptional opportunity for investors, business owners, or those seeking a signature downtown property with endless potential.
Courtesy: The Holscher Group
607-376-7505
Neahwa Park Apartments at 70 Market Street offers a rare blend of history, stability, and optionality in the vibrant City of Oneonta. This well-located, fully compliant, 24-unit building generates strong cash flow, with a clear path to materially higher income. The property currently produces revenue of approximately $29,546 per month and expected to be roughly $354,552 annually. The fundamentals are already in place whether your strategy is a long-term hold, a refinance, student housing or hybrid conversion, a blend of short term rental and long term, or eventual redevelopment. Originally built as a freight warehouse for the Delaware & Hudson (D&H) Railroad, the iconic brick building was converted to residential use in the 1990s. The building includes 63-bedrooms, 19,160 square feet, set on 0.94 acres across two adjacent parcels (with room to add wing to the structure). Another adjacent mixed use property available for sale offers development options. The conservative long-term-rental pro forma still pencils to $224,735 of NOI and an 8.03% cap rate. Ownership refined this property over two decades, and the sale conveys an established operating platform: TurboTenant property-management software, assigned and guest parking behind a fenced perimeter, and a communal Speed Queen laundry. A new fire-alarm system with two outdoor pull stations report directly to dispatch (2025), a flat roof roughly three years old, a four-year-old concrete deck, new lower-level windows, and a multi-camera system. About 80% of in-unit appliances, hot-water tanks, ovens, refrigerators, and dishwashers have been replaced within the last one to three years. Up to date Certificate of Substantial Compliance for all 24 units and an active City short-term-rental permit. Located in a designated Opportunity Zone (OZ 2.0). Walkable to SUNY Oneonta and Hartwick College, A.O. Fox Hospital, Main Street's shops and restaurants, the Foothills Performing Arts Center, and OPT bus lines, and it sits directly beside Neahwa Park and its ballfields, with quick access to Interstate 88. Short drive to Allstar Village baseball park for excellent short term rental options.
Courtesy: Coldwell Banker Faith Properties Il
315-574-2260
When opportunity arises, be ready to act. This standalone commercial building offers 420 square feet of flexible space for your business. Located just minutes from two colleges and downtown Oneonta, it provides a range of possibilities. Has your home business outgrown your home? Starting a new business or have a new side gig that needs space? This spot may be perfect for you. The small parking lot supports on-site sales, or you may choose to operate as a delivery-only business.
Courtesy: Oneonta Realty, LLC
607-441-7312
GREAT LOCATION for this 6 UNIT APARTMENT BUILDING CLOSE TO DOWNTOWN, COLLEGES AND BUS ROUTE. There are 4 two bedroom apartments, 1 studio apartment and 1 one bedroom apartment. Each apartment has been TASTFULLY UPDATED. Each apartment has SEPERATE UTLITIES along with easy access to a common area for laundry. Total rents currently are $3750 monthly, $45,000/yr. There are two vacant apartments that are being freshened up for incoming tenants. Income when fully rented $5550/month, $66,600/yr. Rents could be higher! This is a nice building with updated apartments in the perfect location!
Courtesy: Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties
607-336-3636
For the first time in 75 years, this remarkable property presents a unique and advantageous opportunity for investors and forward-thinking entrepreneurs to capitalize on the growing energy in Upstate New York. Established in 1801, 4 Washington Park has been an integral part of the Village of Oxford and has a fascinating history. The property began as a popular tavern, was later transformed into hotel, then an apartment complex and now serving as an adult care facility. Spanning an impressive 10,000 square feet, the thoughtfully designed and expansive layout harmoniously blends its historical charm with the flexibility and adaptability required for various modern uses. With a total of 23 rooms, the current floor plan features a spacious dining area, a fully equipped commercial- grade kitchen, a welcoming foyer, four versatile common spaces, up to 15 generously sized bedrooms, and seven bathrooms. Additionally, the second floor offers an exceptional opportunity for conversion into either a comfortable owner’s suite or a dedicated property manager’s living quarters. Conveniently located within a 60-mile radius of Binghamton, Syracuse, Utica, and Oneonta, 4 Washington Park is surrounded by charming historic homes and a quaint Village park, creating a serene and picturesque ambiance from its expansive 80-foot covered porch. Currently operating as a fully regulated Level 3 Congregate Care facility, the property is equipped with updated and modern mechanical systems and comprehensive safety checks, ensuring a secure and comfortable environment for its residents. Beyond this established use, the property is well-suited for a wide range of alternative uses. Although some may require proper zoning approvals, potential uses include a charming Bed & Breakfast, a Boutique Inn, sophisticated Executive Housing, a versatile office building, apartment conversion, a thriving community center, or even a well respected boarding school. Regardless of your specific vision or aspirations, 4 Washington Park is ready for you to write it's next chapter.
Courtesy: Benson Agency Real Estate LLC
607-432-4391
This historic little church offers a prime opportunity to repurpose the building located on the high-visibility Route 7 in Emmons, just minutes from Interstate 88 and on the road from Oneonta to Cooperstown. This unique property features classic architectural elements, including tall stained glass windows, lovely wooden benches and an open interior space, offering a flexible layout ideal for a wide range of uses. The building sits on almost 1/2 acre lot. Whether you're an investor or an entrepreneur seeking a distinctive space for your business or studio this property presents a rare and adaptable opportunity. There is a kitchen but no well or septic on the property. Believe that there is a cesspool. 2 newer propane furnaces. The oil tank in basement is empty and not in use. Some chairs and books will be removed prior to closing. Property is sold "AS IS". Square footage is estimated.
Courtesy: Benson Agency Real Estate LLC
607-432-4391
Investor Alert – Turnkey Commercial Property with an almost 10% Cap Rate in Oneonta’s West End. Whether you’re expanding your portfolio or seeking a secure, income-generating asset, this premier building offers the stability and growth you’re looking for! This modern, fully leased dermatology facility is located in the highly sought-after West End of Oneonta and offers a solid return on your investment, making it an attractive option for investors seeking stable, income-producing assets. The space is thoughtfully designed with a spacious waiting area, reception desk, nurses’ station, 5 private offices, 10 exam rooms, 2 operating rooms, a records room, and a break room. Conveniently, there are 6 half baths throughout the building. Ample paved parking is available in both the front and rear of the property, with an additional lot at the back for future expansion or added parking. The property is under a lease for the next 2.5 years with an established tenant and includes an option to renew—ensuring consistent cash flow and long-term potential. Perfectly located just minutes from I-88 and close to Cooperstown All-Star Village, this property offers excellent accessibility and visibility. If you're looking for a high-performing investment in a turnkey updated property, this is it. Secure a return on your investment from day one!
Courtesy: Benson Agency Real Estate LLC
607-432-4391
Premium location! Premium opportunity! Own and operate a turn-key restaurant building in the very heart of downtown Oneonta, at a location that is second to NONE! Muller Plaza adjoins building, including the brand new outdoor Al Galladoro performance stage- part of the number one downtown community gathering space year-round! Restaurant offers 1,435 sq ft per floor (1st floor and basement) and features tile flooring, French doors to exterior dining area, gorgeous centerpiece natural oak bar, and 3 baths. 2nd floor has brand new carpeting throughout and features two to three bedrooms and one and a half baths plus laundry room, all with newly installed electric heat upstairs for apartment. Restaurant space is tastefully decorated with brick, oak, and stucco finishes. Public parking on street with municipal lots (2) within 2-3 blocks. This building and location must be seen to be appreciated! Views from apartment to city hill-scapes and downtown square are special!
Courtesy: Benson Agency Real Estate LLC
607-432-4391
Prime opportunity to own a well-maintained commercial building with flexible rental potential and a high-visibility location just moments from downtown. The Property Features a brick construction with excellent curb appeal and can be configured into up to 4 rental office units. There is a private parking lot for 4–6 vehicles and an additional public parking lot directly across the street. The building is ideal for professional offices, wellness services, administrative space, or mixed-use concepts and is currently occupied by a reliable month-to-month tenant. The proximity to downtown, makes it convenient for clients and employees with easy access to main roads, shops, restaurants, and municipal services This property offers flexibility along with income potential, and a strong location—perfect for investors or business owners looking to expand or relocate.
Courtesy: eXp Realty
888-276-0630
Nestled in a central location, near I-88 and surrounded by picturesque parks, 26 Main Street offers the perfect blend of accessibility and tranquility. Discover a breathtaking balcony offering a glimpse of the city's pulse. And the landscape, an enchanting masterpiece, provides an oasis of serenity for all who visit. Additionally, there are two on-site apartments collectively spanning 2,300 square feet awaits you. Three bedrooms, three bathrooms, a luxurious retreat seamlessly integrated into this remarkable space for an added revenue stream.The full liquor license, extending to the inviting outdoor seating, opens doors to endless possibilities. And for your patrons' convenience, 50 parking spaces, ensuring accessibility that exceeds expectations. This timeless two-story structure spans 7,754 sqft was originally built in 1904, revived to perfection in 2019 and 2 year old hot water heater, furnace, and AC unit. 163 feet of captivating frontage along Main Street, invites guests with a promise of remarkable experiences.Whether you're envisioning your restaurant, a microbrewery, wellness center, B&B, or a gallery, the Commercial zoning sets the stage for your imagination to run???????????????????????????????????????? wild.
Courtesy: eXp Realty
888-276-0630
Welcome to a remarkable investment opportunity nestled in the heart of historic Oneonta, New York. This exquisite property at 58-60 Market Street, formerly Oneonta's train station from 1892, spans a magnificent 8,000 sq ft and offers an array of possibilities, from an upscale residence to a thriving commercial enterprise. Set against the backdrop of a vibrant college town, this location is strategically poised to cater to the needs of neighboring educational institutions and businesses, such as The Foothills Performing Arts & Civic Center NEXT DOOR, making it a valuable asset in the heart of the community. With a prime location, this property is tailor-made for a range of commercial ventures including a full service kitchen, and three separate heating systems throughout the property. Imagine boutique shops, restaurants, or professional offices gracing the ground floor, drawing in both locals and college students alike. A brand new roof, meticulous basement, bar, radiant heating, 5 new HVACs, ample parking for customers, makes this unique property turnkey, AND could also be transformed into a luxurious urban residence, offering the perfect fusion of downtown living and convenience.
Courtesy: Benson Agency Real Estate LLC
607-432-4391
Legendary restaurant location for sale. Continuously operational for five decades! This well-kept and extremely popular restaurant is now for sale. Includes all equipment throughout. Three dining areas out front, and "back of house" is a fully equipped, two-line kitchen with separate prep areas, plus walk-in cooler/freezer and a full inventory of all necessary equipment. List is attached. Bonus: 1,150 sq ft 3 br manufactured home with new roof and several upgrades- ideal for staff or ownership! Great visibility, large lot, seating for 108, and freshly paved/striped parking lot with 38 spaces. This restaurant is turn-key ready! This type of opportunity is rare- fully equipped, fully operational, and ready for your menu. your drive, and your ambitions to succeed at this long-term, successful location!
Courtesy: Benson Agency Real Estate LLC
607-432-4391
DESTINATION LOCATION This former nursery and landscape business location of 2,200 square feet plus 2,500 square feet of hard-scape walkways, and open/covered patios is turn-key ready including an operating greenhouse, underground water/electric, and ample yard space! Centerpiece entry features gorgeous water garden with gentle rock waterfalls to pond stocked with koi and other wildlife, surrounded by colorful perennials of all varieties! Owner has recently completed major upgrades to both interior and exterior!!! If you are seeking a unique indoor and outdoor venue for restaurant, coffee shop, cafe, or brewery...look no further! The indoor greenhouse room, large finished service/retail rooms, conference room, offices, and bath are all in place, and are ideal to create a working kitchen environment and the perfect flow of indoor to outdoor seating/fire-pit/music venue! Country-like atmosphere meets a 5 minute drive to I88, downtown, and the Cooperstown All Star Village! If you want living space as well, the 850 square foot BRAND NEW upscale 2nd floor apartment with deck features a cathedral ceiling 'great room", two bedrooms and bath and a half. Call today to view this property sitting on 1,3 acres in the city ;limits of Oneonta, NY!
Oneonta is located in New York. Oneonta, New York has a population of 12,764. Oneonta is less family-centric than the surrounding county with 21.07% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 24%.
The median household income in Oneonta, New York is $58,499. The median household income for the surrounding county is $60,523 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Oneonta is 21.9 years.
The average high temperature in July is 78.3 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 12.1 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 41.7 inches per year, with 82.6 inches of snow per year.
